[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"summary-spdd-scale-llm-coding-to-teams-via-structured-prom-summary":3,"summaries-facets-categories":517,"summary-related-spdd-scale-llm-coding-to-teams-via-structured-prom-summary":4922},{"id":4,"title":5,"ai":6,"body":13,"categories":475,"created_at":477,"date_modified":477,"description":465,"extension":478,"faq":477,"featured":479,"kicker_label":477,"meta":480,"navigation":499,"path":500,"published_at":477,"question":477,"scraped_at":501,"seo":502,"sitemap":503,"source_id":504,"source_name":505,"source_type":506,"source_url":507,"stem":508,"tags":509,"thumbnail_url":477,"tldr":514,"tweet":477,"unknown_tags":515,"__hash__":516},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Fspdd-scale-llm-coding-to-teams-via-structured-prom-summary.md","SPDD: Scale LLM Coding to Teams via Structured Prompts",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":9,"output_tokens":10,"processing_time_ms":11,"cost_usd":12},"openrouter","x-ai\u002Fgrok-4.1-fast",8681,2953,26706,0.0031902,{"type":14,"value":15,"toc":464},"minimark",[16,21,25,28,31,35,38,153,156,159,163,166,275,278,281,284,288,291,297,303,309,314,357,363,366,369,372,376,379,399,402,405,409,415,420,428,431,435],[17,18,20],"h2",{"id":19},"prompts-as-first-class-artifacts-to-bridge-individual-and-team-gains","Prompts as First-Class Artifacts to Bridge Individual and Team Gains",[22,23,24],"p",{},"AI coding assistants boost individual developer speed, but teams face friction from ambiguous requirements turning into scaled misunderstandings, harder reviews, integration issues, and production risks. Thoughtworks' internal IT teams developed Structured Prompt-Driven Development (SPDD) to make LLM-assisted changes governable at scale. Instead of ad hoc chats, SPDD elevates prompts to version-controlled assets alongside code, capturing requirements, domain models, design intent, constraints, and tasks. This predictability enables reviews on a single artifact, not scattered logs or diffs.",[22,26,27],{},"The core problem: Local speed (\"Ferrari engine\") doesn't fix systemic roads like poor alignment. SPDD rejects freeform prompting for a structured approach, drawing from spec-driven development but evolving prompts as living specs that co-evolve with code. When code diverges, update the prompt first—enforcing a closed loop where feedback refines intent before implementation.",[22,29,30],{},"\"It's like buying a Ferrari and driving it on muddy roads: the engine is powerful, but your arrival time is determined by road conditions and traffic.\" This analogy from the authors highlights why individual AI wins fail organizationally without governance.",[17,32,34],{"id":33},"reasons-canvas-abstract-intent-before-concrete-execution","REASONS Canvas: Abstract Intent Before Concrete Execution",[22,36,37],{},"SPDD's foundation is the REASONS Canvas, a seven-part prompt structure forcing clarity on intent, design, execution, and governance before code generation.",[39,40,41,57],"table",{},[42,43,44],"thead",{},[45,46,47,51,54],"tr",{},[48,49,50],"th",{},"Section",[48,52,53],{},"Focus",[48,55,56],{},"Why It Matters",[58,59,60,75,88,101,114,127,140],"tbody",{},[45,61,62,69,72],{},[63,64,65],"td",{},[66,67,68],"strong",{},"R - Requirements",[63,70,71],{},"Problem, Definition of Done",[63,73,74],{},"Aligns on business value and success metrics.",[45,76,77,82,85],{},[63,78,79],{},[66,80,81],{},"E - Entities",[63,83,84],{},"Domain model, relationships",[63,86,87],{},"Grounds in shared domain language.",[45,89,90,95,98],{},[63,91,92],{},[66,93,94],{},"A - Approach",[63,96,97],{},"High-level strategy",[63,99,100],{},"Sets solution direction with trade-offs.",[45,102,103,108,111],{},[63,104,105],{},[66,106,107],{},"S - Structure",[63,109,110],{},"System fit, components, deps",[63,112,113],{},"Ensures architectural consistency.",[45,115,116,121,124],{},[63,117,118],{},[66,119,120],{},"O - Operations",[63,122,123],{},"Task breakdown, testable steps",[63,125,126],{},"Makes execution concrete and verifiable.",[45,128,129,134,137],{},[63,130,131],{},[66,132,133],{},"N - Norms",[63,135,136],{},"Naming, observability, coding standards",[63,138,139],{},"Enforces team conventions.",[45,141,142,147,150],{},[63,143,144],{},[66,145,146],{},"S - Safeguards",[63,148,149],{},"Invariants, perf limits, security",[63,151,152],{},"Prevents regressions.",[22,154,155],{},"Abstract sections (R,E,A,S) capture design before specifics; execution (O) follows; governance (N,S) bounds output. This shifts uncertainty left, compounding expertise across iterations into reusable libraries. Reviewers validate one canvas, not code alone.",[22,157,158],{},"Decision chain: Teams considered ad hoc vs. structured prompts. Chose REASONS because it balances expressiveness with consistency—too vague risks hallucination; too rigid stifles creativity. Trade-off: Upfront canvas time (10-30 mins) pays off in predictable generations and fewer review cycles.",[17,160,162],{"id":161},"closed-loop-workflow-powered-by-openspdd-cli","Closed-Loop Workflow Powered by openspdd CLI",[22,164,165],{},"SPDD integrates prompts into git workflows via openspdd, a CLI tool with commands enforcing discipline:",[39,167,168,181],{},[42,169,170],{},[45,171,172,175,178],{},[48,173,174],{},"Command",[48,176,177],{},"Purpose",[48,179,180],{},"Key Benefit",[58,182,183,197,210,223,236,249,262],{},[45,184,185,191,194],{},[63,186,187],{},[188,189,190],"code",{},"spdd-story",[63,192,193],{},"Split requirements into INVEST stories",[63,195,196],{},"Manages large epics.",[45,198,199,204,207],{},[63,200,201],{},[188,202,203],{},"spdd-analysis",[63,205,206],{},"Extract domain keywords, scan code, analyze risks",[63,208,209],{},"Contextualizes without full codebase dump.",[45,211,212,217,220],{},[63,213,214],{},[188,215,216],{},"spdd-reasons-canvas",[63,218,219],{},"Build full canvas from analysis",[63,221,222],{},"Generates executable blueprint.",[45,224,225,230,233],{},[63,226,227],{},[188,228,229],{},"spdd-generate",[63,231,232],{},"Produce code task-by-task per canvas",[63,234,235],{},"Bounded, reproducible output.",[45,237,238,243,246],{},[63,239,240],{},[188,241,242],{},"spdd-api-test",[63,244,245],{},"Curl-based E2E tests",[63,247,248],{},"Verifies ACs.",[45,250,251,256,259],{},[63,252,253],{},[188,254,255],{},"spdd-prompt-update",[63,257,258],{},"Evolve canvas on req changes",[63,260,261],{},"Req → prompt → code.",[45,263,264,269,272],{},[63,265,266],{},[188,267,268],{},"spdd-sync",[63,270,271],{},"Back-propagate code changes to canvas",[63,273,274],{},"Code → prompt sync.",[22,276,277],{},"Workflow: Requirements → Analysis → Canvas → Code → Tests → Review → Commit. Rule: Divergence? Fix prompt first. This creates short feedback loops within iterations and cumulative context across them, turning prompts into a library.",[22,279,280],{},"Compared to spec-driven dev, SPDD adds governance via versioned prompts and sync mechanisms. Trade-offs: Tool overhead for small changes (skip for trivial); shines on enhancements where context matters.",[22,282,283],{},"\"When reality diverges, fix the prompt first — then update the code.\" This rule from the workflow prevents intent drift, making SPDD a true closed loop.",[17,285,287],{"id":286},"billing-engine-enhancement-from-static-to-dynamic-pricing","Billing Engine Enhancement: From Static to Dynamic Pricing",[22,289,290],{},"Example: Enhance a token-based LLM billing engine (GitHub: token-billing, iteration-1 baseline) for model-aware, multi-plan billing.",[22,292,293,296],{},[66,294,295],{},"Before:"," Single global rate, quota for all.",[22,298,299,302],{},[66,300,301],{},"Opportunity:"," User feedback demands model-specific rates (e.g., fast-model $0.01\u002F1K tokens, reasoning-model $0.03\u002F1K), Standard plan (quota + overage), Premium (no quota, split prompt\u002Fcompletion billing).",[22,304,305,308],{},[66,306,307],{},"Options considered:"," Monolith if-else vs. extensible patterns. Rejected tight coupling; chose Strategy\u002FFactory for plans, respecting ISP\u002FSRP.",[22,310,311],{},[66,312,313],{},"Step chain:",[315,316,317,324,327,339,345,351],"ol",{},[318,319,320,323],"li",{},[188,321,322],{},"\u002Fspdd-story"," on enhancement idea → Two stories (Standard + Premium), consolidated to one with Given\u002FWhen\u002FThen ACs (e.g., Standard overage: 100K quota, 90K used, 30K fast-model → $0.20 charge).",[318,325,326],{},"Manual clarify: Core logic (routing by plan), scope (calc only, no CRUD), DoD (4 scenarios).",[318,328,329,332,333],{},[188,330,331],{},"\u002Fspdd-analysis"," → Domain concepts (new: modelId, plans), risks (edge cases like negative tokens), strategy (Strategy pattern).\n",[334,335,336],"ul",{},[318,337,338],{},"Review: Aligned on OOP principles; surfaced extra edges (e.g., unknown models → 404).",[318,340,341,344],{},[188,342,343],{},"\u002Fspdd-reasons-canvas"," → Full prompt with REASONS.",[318,346,347,350],{},[188,348,349],{},"\u002Fspdd-generate"," → Code: Added modelId validation, ModelRateRepository, PlanStrategyFactory, Standard\u002FPremiumStrategy impls.",[318,352,353,356],{},[188,354,355],{},"\u002Fspdd-api-test"," → Curl tests for ACs.",[22,358,359,362],{},[66,360,361],{},"Results:"," API now handles modelId, dynamic rates, plan-specific logic. Quota exhausts correctly; Premium bills splits (e.g., 10K prompt + 20K completion reasoning → $1.50). Extensible for future plans.",[22,364,365],{},"Trade-offs: Factory adds indirection (minor perf hit, justified by extensibility); analysis review caught risks early.",[22,367,368],{},"Repo diffs show full artifacts: prompts, code, tests. Replicable in ~1 hour.",[22,370,371],{},"\"The AI's analysis largely aligned with our architectural intent; in fact, its considerations were even more comprehensive than ours in certain areas.\" Review insight shows AI augmenting human foresight.",[17,373,375],{"id":374},"three-core-skills-alignment-abstraction-first-iterative-review","Three Core Skills: Alignment, Abstraction-First, Iterative Review",[22,377,378],{},"Effectiveness demands:",[334,380,381,387,393],{},[318,382,383,386],{},[66,384,385],{},"Alignment:"," Review analysis\u002Fcanvas against human understanding; catch misalignments early.",[318,388,389,392],{},[66,390,391],{},"Abstraction-first:"," Define intent\u002Fdesign before ops; prevents premature optimization.",[318,394,395,398],{},[66,396,397],{},"Iterative review:"," Treat prompts as code—peer review, refine on divergence.",[22,400,401],{},"These counter LLM non-determinism, turning variability into strength via governance.",[22,403,404],{},"\"Reviews move away from 'spot the bug' toward 'check the intent.'\" Captures SPDD's review shift.",[17,406,408],{"id":407},"fitness-and-trade-offs-not-for-every-change","Fitness and Trade-offs: Not for Every Change",[22,410,411,414],{},[66,412,413],{},"Assess fit:"," High-context enhancements, teams new to AI (builds discipline), domains with reusable patterns. Skip for one-liners.",[22,416,417],{},[66,418,419],{},"Trade-offs:",[334,421,422,425],{},[318,423,424],{},"Pros: Consistency, reuse, safer scaling.",[318,426,427],{},"Cons: Prompt overhead (5-20% more upfront), learning curve, tool dependency.",[22,429,430],{},"Fits AI-First Software Delivery; breaks \"expert-only\" barrier by codifying expertise.",[17,432,434],{"id":433},"key-takeaways","Key Takeaways",[334,436,437,440,443,446,449,452,455,458,461],{},[318,438,439],{},"Treat prompts as git-tracked artifacts to scale AI beyond solo devs.",[318,441,442],{},"Use REASONS Canvas: Abstract (REAS) → Execute (O) → Govern (NS).",[318,444,445],{},"Enforce 'fix prompt first' on divergence for closed-loop evolution.",[318,447,448],{},"Leverage openspdd CLI for workflow: analysis → canvas → generate → sync.",[318,450,451],{},"Review at analysis\u002Fcanvas stages; abstraction-first uncovers edges.",[318,453,454],{},"Ideal for enhancements: e.g., add model-aware billing via Strategy pattern.",[318,456,457],{},"Builds prompt libraries compounding team knowledge.",[318,459,460],{},"Trade-off: Upfront structure for downstream predictability.",[318,462,463],{},"Core skills: Align intents, abstract before code, iterate reviews.",{"title":465,"searchDepth":466,"depth":466,"links":467},"",2,[468,469,470,471,472,473,474],{"id":19,"depth":466,"text":20},{"id":33,"depth":466,"text":34},{"id":161,"depth":466,"text":162},{"id":286,"depth":466,"text":287},{"id":374,"depth":466,"text":375},{"id":407,"depth":466,"text":408},{"id":433,"depth":466,"text":434},[476],"AI & LLMs",null,"md",false,{"content_references":481,"triage":494},[482,487,490],{"type":483,"title":484,"url":485,"context":486},"tool","openspdd","https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002Fgszhangwei\u002Fopen-spdd","mentioned",{"type":483,"title":488,"url":489,"context":486},"token-billing","https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002Fgszhangwei\u002Ftoken-billing",{"type":491,"title":492,"url":493,"context":486},"other","Spec-Driven Development","https:\u002F\u002Fen.wikipedia.org\u002Fwiki\u002FSpec-driven_development",{"relevance":495,"novelty":496,"quality":496,"actionability":496,"composite":497,"reasoning":498},5,4,4.35,"Category: AI & LLMs. The article introduces Structured Prompt-Driven Development (SPDD), a novel approach to managing AI-generated code, which addresses the pain point of governance in team settings. It provides a structured framework (REASONS Canvas) that teams can adopt to enhance clarity and collaboration, making it actionable for developers looking to implement AI in a systematic way.",true,"\u002Fsummaries\u002Fspdd-scale-llm-coding-to-teams-via-structured-prom-summary","2026-04-28 15:16:24",{"title":5,"description":465},{"loc":500},"a62c1fc44f0e9d89","Martin Fowler","article","https:\u002F\u002Fmartinfowler.com\u002Farticles\u002Fstructured-prompt-driven\u002F","summaries\u002Fspdd-scale-llm-coding-to-teams-via-structured-prom-summary",[510,511,512,513],"llm","prompt-engineering","software-engineering","dev-productivity","Structured Prompt-Driven Development (SPDD) treats prompts as versioned artifacts using a REASONS canvas and workflow to make AI-generated code governable, reviewable, and reusable across teams.",[512,513],"xClGNybjROxGO1gEcjs6XrsHtW9cGAgWsLlqTu7CCK0",[518,521,523,526,528,531,534,537,540,542,544,546,548,550,552,554,556,558,560,562,564,566,568,571,573,575,577,579,581,583,585,587,589,591,593,595,597,599,601,603,605,607,609,611,613,616,618,620,622,624,626,628,630,632,634,636,638,640,642,644,646,648,650,652,654,656,658,660,662,664,666,668,670,672,674,676,678,680,682,684,686,688,690,692,694,696,698,700,702,704,706,708,710,712,714,716,718,720,722,724,726,728,730,732,734,736,738,740,742,744,746,748,750,752,754,756,758,760,762,764,766,768,770,772,774,776,778,780,782,784,786,788,790,792,794,796,798,800,802,804,806,808,810,812,814,816,818,820,822,824,826,828,830,832,834,836,838,840,842,844,846,848,850,852,854,856,858,860,862,864,866,868,870,872,874,876,878,881,883,885,887,889,891,893,895,897,899,901,903,905,907,909,911,913,915,917,919,921,923,925,927,929,931,933,935,937,939,941,943,945,947,949,951,953,955,957,959,961,963,965,968,970,972,974,976,978,980,982,984,986,988,990,992,994,996,998,1000,1002,1004,1006,1008,1010,1012,1014,1016,1018,1020,1022,1024,1026,1028,1030,1032,1034,1036,1038,1040,1042,1044,1046,1048,1050,1052,1054,1056,1058,1060,1062,1064,1066,1068,1070,1072,1074,1076,1078,1080,1082,1084,1086,1088,1090,1092,1094,1096,1098,1100,1102,1104,1106,1108,1110,1112,1114,1116,1118,1120,1122,1124,1126,1128,1130,1132,1134,1136,1138,1140,1142,1144,1146,1148,1150,1152,1154,1156,1158,1160,1162,1164,1166,1168,1170,1172,1174,1176,1178,1180,1182,1184,1186,1188,1190,1192,1194,1196,1198,1200,1202,1204,1206,1208,1210,1212,1214,1216,1218,1220,1222,1224,1226,1228,1230,1232,1234,1236,1238,1240,1242,1244,1246,1248,1250,1252,1254,1256,1258,1260,1262,1264,1266,1268,1270,1272,1274,1276,1278,1280,1282,1284,1286,1288,1290,1292,1294,1296,1298,1300,1302,1304,1306,1308,1310,1312,1314,1316,1318,1320,1322,1324,1326,1328,1330,1332,1334,1336,1338,1340,1342,1344,1346,1348,1350,1352,1354,1356,1358,1360,1362,1364,1366,1368,1370,1372,1374,1376,1378,1380,1382,1384,1386,1388,1390,1392,1394,1396,1398,1400,1402,1404,1406,1408,1410,1412,1414,1416,1418,1420,1422,1424,1426,1428,1430,1432,1434,1436,1438,1440,1442,1444,1446,1448,1450,1452,1454,1456,1458,1460,1462,1464,1466,1468,1470,1472,1474,1476,1478,1480,1482,1484,1486,1488,1490,1492,1494,1496,1498,1500,1502,1504,1506,1508,1510,1512,1514,1516,1518,1520,1522,1524,1526,1528,1530,1532,1534,1536,1538,1540,1542,1544,1546,1548,1550,1552,1554,1556,1558,1560,1562,1564,1566,1568,1570,1572,1574,1576,1578,1580,1582,1584,1586,1588,1590,1592,1594,1596,1598,1600,1602,1604,1606,1608,1610,1612,1614,1616,1618,1620,1622,1624,1626,1628,1630,1632,1634,1636,1638,1640,1642,1644,1646,1648,1650,1652,1654,1656,1658,1660,1662,1664,1666,1668,1670,1672,1674,1676,1678,1680,1682,1684,1686,1688,1690,1692,1694,1696,1698,1700,1702,1704,1706,1708,1710,1712,1714,1716,1718,1720,1722,1724,1726,1728,1730,1732,1734,1736,1738,1740,1742,1744,1746,1748,1750,1752,1754,1756,1758,1760,1762,1764,1766,1768,1770,1772,1774,1776,1778,1780,1782,1784,1786,1788,1790,1792,1794,1796,1798,1800,1802,1804,1806,1808,1810,1812,1814,1816,1818,1820,1822,1824,1826,1828,1830,1832,1834,1836,1838,1840,1842,1844,1846,1848,1850,1852,1854,1856,1858,1860,1862,1864,1866,1868,1870,1872,1874,1876,1878,1880,1882,1884,1886,1888,1890,1892,1894,1896,1898,1900,1902,1904,1906,1908,1910,1912,1914,1916,1918,1920,1922,1924,1926,1928,1930,1932,1934,1936,1938,1940,1942,1944,1946,1948,1950,1952,1954,1956,1958,1960,1962,1964,1966,1968,1970,1972,1974,1976,1978,1980,1982,1984,1986,1988,1990,1992,1994,1996,1998,2000,2002,2004,2006,2008,2010,2012,2014,2016,2018,2020,2022,2024,2026,2028,2030,2032,2034,2036,2038,2040,2042,2044,2046,2048,2050,2052,2054,2056,2058,2060,2062,2064,2066,2068,2070,2072,2074,2076,2078,2080,2082,2084,2086,2088,2090,2092,2094,2096,2098,2100,2102,2104,2106,2108,2110,2112,2114,2116,2118,2120,2122,2124,2126,2128,2130,2132,2134,2136,2138,2140,2142,2144,2146,2148,2150,2152,2154,2156,2158,2160,2162,2164,2166,2168,2170,2172,2174,2176,2178,2180,2182,2184,2186,2188,2190,2192,2194,2196,2198,2200,2202,2204,2206,2208,2210,2212,2214,2216,2218,2220,2222,2224,2226,2228,2230,2232,2234,2236,2238,2240,2242,2244,2246,2248,2250,2252,2254,2256,2258,2260,2262,2264,2266,2268,2270,2272,2274,2276,2278,2280,2282,2284,2286,2288,2290,2292,2294,2296,2298,2300,2302,2304,2306,2308,2310,2312,2314,2316,2318,2320,2322,2324,2326,2328,2330,2332,2334,2336,2338,2340,2342,2344,2346,2348,2350,2352,2354,2356,2358,2360,2362,2364,2366,2368,2370,2372,2374,2376,2378,2380,2382,2384,2386,2388,2390,2392,2394,2396,2398,2400,2402,2404,2406,2408,2410,2412,2414,2416,2418,2420,2422,2424,2426,2428,2430,2432,2434,2436,2438,2440,2442,2444,2446,2448,2450,2452,2454,2456,2458,2460,2462,2464,2466,2468,2470,2472,2474,2476,2478,2480,2482,2484,2486,2488,2490,2492,2494,2496,2498,2500,2502,2504,2506,2508,2510,2512,2514,2516,2518,2520,2522,2524,2526,2528,2530,2532,2534,2536,2538,2540,2542,2544,2546,2548,2550,2552,2554,2556,2558,2560,2562,2564,2566,2568,2570,2572,2574,2576,2578,2580,2582,2584,2586,2588,2590,2592,2594,2596,2598,2600,2602,2604,2606,2608,2610,2612,2614,2616,2618,2620,2622,2624,2626,2628,2630,2632,2634,2636,2638,2640,2642,2644,2646,2648,2650,2652,2654,2656,2658,2660,2662,2664,2666,2668,2670,2672,2674,2676,2678,2680,2682,2684,2686,2688,2690,2692,2694,2696,2698,2700,2702,2704,2706,2708,2710,2712,2714,2716,2718,2720,2722,2724,2726,2728,2730,2732,2734,2736,2738,2740,2742,2744,2746,2748,2750,2752,2754,2756,2758,2760,2762,2764,2766,2768,2770,2772,2774,2776,2778,2780,2782,2784,2786,2788,2790,2792,2794,2796,2798,2800,2802,2804,2806,2808,2810,2812,2814,2816,2818,2820,2822,2824,2826,2828,2830,2832,2834,2836,2838,2840,2842,2844,2846,2848,2850,2852,2854,2856,2858,2860,2862,2864,2866,2868,2870,2872,2874,2876,2878,2880,2882,2884,2886,2888,2890,2892,2894,2896,2898,2900,2902,2904,2906,2908,2910,2912,2914,2916,2918,2920,2922,2924,2926,2928,2930,2932,2934,2936,2938,2940,2942,2944,2946,2948,2950,2952,2954,2956,2958,2960,2962,2964,2966,2968,2970,2972,2974,2976,2978,2980,2982,2984,2986,2988,2990,2992,2994,2996,2998,3000,3002,3004,3006,3008,3010,3012,3014,3016,3018,3020,3022,3024,3026,3028,3030,3032,3034,3036,3038,3040,3042,3044,3046,3048,3050,3052,3054,3056,3058,3060,3062,3064,3066,3068,3070,3072,3074,3076,3078,3080,3082,3084,3086,3088,3090,3092,3094,3096,3098,3100,3102,3104,3106,3108,3110,3112,3114,3116,3118,3120,3122,3124,3126,3128,3130,3132,3134,3136,3138,3140,3142,3144,3146,3148,3150,3152,3154,3156,3158,3160,3162,3164,3166,3168,3170,3172,3174,3176,3178,3180,3182,3184,3186,3188,3190,3192,3194,3196,3198,3200,3202,3204,3206,3208,3210,3212,3214,3216,3218,3220,3222,3224,3226,3228,3230,3232,3234,3236,3238,3240,3242,3244,3246,3248,3250,3252,3254,3256,3258,3260,3262,3264,3266,3268,3270,3272,3274,3276,3278,3280,3282,3284,3286,3288,3290,3292,3294,3296,3298,3300,3302,3304,3306,3308,3310,3312,3314,3316,3318,3320,3322,3324,3326,3328,3330,3332,3334,3336,3338,3340,3342,3344,3346,3348,3350,3352,3354,3356,3358,3360,3362,3364,3366,3368,3370,3372,3374,3376,3378,3380,3382,3384,3386,3388,3390,3392,3394,3396,3398,3400,3402,3404,3406,3408,3410,3412,3414,3416,3418,3420,3422,3424,3426,3428,3430,3432,3434,3436,3438,3440,3442,3444,3446,3448,3450,3452,3454,3456,3458,3460,3462,3464,3466,3468,3470,3472,3474,3476,3478,3480,3482,3484,3486,3488,3490,3492,3494,3496,3498,3500,3502,3504,3506,3508,3510,3512,3514,3516,3518,3520,3522,3524,3526,3528,3530,3532,3534,3536,3538,3540,3542,3544,3546,3548,3550,3552,3554,3556,3558,3560,3562,3564,3566,3568,3570,3572,3574,3576,3578,3580,3582,3584,3586,3588,3590,3592,3594,3596,3598,3600,3602,3604,3606,3608,3610,3612,3614,3616,3618,3620,3622,3624,3626,3628,3630,3632,3634,3636,3638,3640,3642,3644,3646,3648,3650,3652,3654,3656,3658,3660,3662,3664,3666,3668,3670,3672,3674,3676,3678,3680,3682,3684,3686,3688,3690,3692,3694,3696,3698,3700,3702,3704,3706,3708,3710,3712,3714,3716,3718,3720,3722,3724,3726,3728,3730,3732,3734,3736,3738,3740,3742,3744,3746,3748,3750,3752,3754,3756,3758,3760,3762,3764,3766,3768,3770,3772,3774,3776,3778,3780,3782,3784,3786,3788,3790,3792,3794,3796,3798,3800,3802,3804,3806,3808,3810,3812,3814,3816,3818,3820,3822,3824,3826,3828,3830,3832,3834,3836,3838,3840,3842,3844,3846,3848,3850,3852,3854,3856,3858,3860,3862,3864,3866,3868,3870,3872,3874,3876,3878,3880,3882,3884,3886,3888,3890,3892,3894,3896,3898,3900,3902,3904,3906,3908,3910,3912,3914,3916,3918,3920,3922,3924,3926,3928,3930,3932,3934,3936,3938,3940,3942,3944,3946,3948,3950,3952,3954,3956,3958,3960,3962,3964,3966,3968,3970,3972,3974,3976,3978,3980,3982,3984,3986,3988,3990,3992,3994,3996,3998,4000,4002,4004,4006,4008,4010,4012,4014,4016,4018,4020,4022,4024,4026,4028,4030,4032,4034,4036,4038,4040,4042,4044,4046,4048,4050,4052,4054,4056,4058,4060,4062,4064,4066,4068,4070,4072,4074,4076,4078,4080,4082,4084,4086,4088,4090,4092,4094,4096,4098,4100,4102,4104,4106,4108,4110,4112,4114,4116,4118,4120,4122,4124,4126,4128,4130,4132,4134,4136,4138,4140,4142,4144,4146,4148,4150,4152,4154,4156,4158,4160,4162,4164,4166,4168,4170,4172,4174,4176,4178,4180,4182,4184,4186,4188,4190,4192,4194,4196,4198,4200,4202,4204,4206,4208,4210,4212,4214,4216,4218,4220,4222,4224,4226,4228,4230,4232,4234,4236,4238,4240,4242,4244,4246,4248,4250,4252,4254,4256,4258,4260,4262,4264,4266,4268,4270,4272,4274,4276,4278,4280,4282,4284,4286,4288,4290,4292,4294,4296,4298,4300,4302,4304,4306,4308,4310,4312,4314,4316,4318,4320,4322,4324,4326,4328,4330,4332,4334,4336,4338,4340,4342,4344,4346,4348,4350,4352,4354,4356,4358,4360,4362,4364,4366,4368,4370,4372,4374,4376,4378,4380,4382,4384,4386,4388,4390,4392,4394,4396,4398,4400,4402,4404,4406,4408,4410,4412,4414,4416,4418,4420,4422,4424,4426,4428,4430,4432,4434,4436,4438,4440,4442,4444,4446,4448,4450,4452,4454,4456,4458,4460,4462,4464,4466,4468,4470,4472,4474,4476,4478,4480,4482,4484,4486,4488,4490,4492,4494,4496,4498,4500,4502,4504,4506,4508,4510,4512,4514,4516,4518,4520,4522,4524,4526,4528,4530,4532,4534,4536,4538,4540,4542,4544,4546,4548,4550,4552,4554,4556,4558,4560,4562,4564,4566,4568,4570,4572,4574,4576,4578,4580,4582,4584,4586,4588,4590,4592,4594,4596,4598,4600,4602,4604,4606,4608,4610,4612,4614,4616,4618,4620,4622,4624,4626,4628,4630,4632,4634,4636,4638,4640,4642,4644,4646,4648,4650,4652,4654,4656,4658,4660,4662,4664,4666,4668,4670,4672,4674,4676,4678,4680,4682,4684,4686,4688,4690,4692,4694,4696,4698,4700,4702,4704,4706,4708,4710,4712,4714,4716,4718,4720,4722,4724,4726,4728,4730,4732,4734,4736,4738,4740,4742,4744,4746,4748,4750,4752,4754,4756,4758,4760,4762,4764,4766,4768,4770,4772,4774,4776,4778,4780,4782,4784,4786,4788,4790,4792,4794,4796,4798,4800,4802,4804,4806,4808,4810,4812,4814,4816,4818,4820,4822,4824,4826,4828,4830,4832,4834,4836,4838,4840,4842,4844,4846,4848,4850,4852,4854,4856,4858,4860,4862,4864,4866,4868,4870,4872,4874,4876,4878,4880,4882,4884,4886,4888,4890,4892,4894,4896,4898,4900,4902,4904,4906,4908,4910,4912,4914,4916,4918,4920],{"categories":519},[520],"Business & SaaS",{"categories":522},[520],{"categories":524},[525],"AI News & Trends",{"categories":527},[],{"categories":529},[530],"AI Automation",{"categories":532},[533],"Marketing & Growth",{"categories":535},[536],"Design & Frontend",{"categories":538},[539],"Software Engineering",{"categories":541},[530],{"categories":543},[],{"categories":545},[536],{"categories":547},[536],{"categories":549},[530],{"categories":551},[536],{"categories":553},[536],{"categories":555},[476],{"categories":557},[536],{"categories":559},[536],{"categories":561},[],{"categories":563},[536],{"categories":565},[536],{"categories":567},[476],{"categories":569},[570],"Developer Productivity",{"categories":572},[476],{"categories":574},[476],{"categories":576},[476],{"categories":578},[525],{"categories":580},[476],{"categories":582},[530],{"categories":584},[520],{"categories":586},[525],{"categories":588},[533],{"categories":590},[],{"categories":592},[],{"categories":594},[530],{"categories":596},[530],{"categories":598},[530],{"categories":600},[533],{"categories":602},[476],{"categories":604},[570],{"categories":606},[525],{"categories":608},[],{"categories":610},[],{"categories":612},[],{"categories":614},[615],"Data Science & Visualization",{"categories":617},[],{"categories":619},[530],{"categories":621},[539],{"categories":623},[530],{"categories":625},[530],{"categories":627},[476],{"categories":629},[533],{"categories":631},[530],{"categories":633},[],{"categories":635},[],{"categories":637},[],{"categories":639},[536],{"categories":641},[536],{"categories":643},[530],{"categories":645},[533],{"categories":647},[570],{"categories":649},[536],{"categories":651},[476],{"categories":653},[539],{"categories":655},[476],{"categories":657},[],{"categories":659},[530],{"categories":661},[476],{"categories":663},[570],{"categories":665},[570],{"categories":667},[],{"categories":669},[533],{"categories":671},[520],{"categories":673},[476],{"categories":675},[520],{"categories":677},[520],{"categories":679},[530],{"categories":681},[533],{"categories":683},[530],{"categories":685},[520],{"categories":687},[530],{"categories":689},[536],{"categories":691},[476],{"categories":693},[536],{"categories":695},[476],{"categories":697},[520],{"categories":699},[476],{"categories":701},[533],{"categories":703},[],{"categories":705},[476],{"categories":707},[520],{"categories":709},[],{"categories":711},[525],{"categories":713},[539],{"categories":715},[],{"categories":717},[476],{"categories":719},[536],{"categories":721},[476],{"categories":723},[536],{"categories":725},[],{"categories":727},[530],{"categories":729},[],{"categories":731},[],{"categories":733},[],{"categories":735},[476],{"categories":737},[],{"categories":739},[476],{"categories":741},[476],{"categories":743},[536],{"categories":745},[476],{"categories":747},[570],{"categories":749},[530],{"categories":751},[533],{"categories":753},[570],{"categories":755},[570],{"categories":757},[570],{"categories":759},[533],{"categories":761},[533],{"categories":763},[476],{"categories":765},[476],{"categories":767},[536],{"categories":769},[520],{"categories":771},[536],{"categories":773},[539],{"categories":775},[520],{"categories":777},[520],{"categories":779},[520],{"categories":781},[536],{"categories":783},[],{"categories":785},[],{"categories":787},[476],{"categories":789},[476],{"categories":791},[539],{"categories":793},[476],{"categories":795},[476],{"categories":797},[],{"categories":799},[476],{"categories":801},[476],{"categories":803},[],{"categories":805},[476],{"categories":807},[525],{"categories":809},[525],{"categories":811},[],{"categories":813},[],{"categories":815},[533],{"categories":817},[533],{"categories":819},[539],{"categories":821},[476],{"categories":823},[],{"categories":825},[],{"categories":827},[530],{"categories":829},[476],{"categories":831},[476],{"categories":833},[],{"categories":835},[476,520],{"categories":837},[476],{"categories":839},[],{"categories":841},[476],{"categories":843},[476],{"categories":845},[],{"categories":847},[],{"categories":849},[530],{"categories":851},[476],{"categories":853},[476],{"categories":855},[530],{"categories":857},[476],{"categories":859},[],{"categories":861},[],{"categories":863},[476],{"categories":865},[],{"categories":867},[476],{"categories":869},[476],{"categories":871},[],{"categories":873},[530],{"categories":875},[536],{"categories":877},[],{"categories":879},[530,880],"DevOps & Cloud",{"categories":882},[476],{"categories":884},[530],{"categories":886},[476],{"categories":888},[],{"categories":890},[],{"categories":892},[],{"categories":894},[],{"categories":896},[476],{"categories":898},[530],{"categories":900},[],{"categories":902},[530],{"categories":904},[],{"categories":906},[476],{"categories":908},[],{"categories":910},[],{"categories":912},[],{"categories":914},[],{"categories":916},[530],{"categories":918},[536],{"categories":920},[476],{"categories":922},[533],{"categories":924},[525],{"categories":926},[520],{"categories":928},[570],{"categories":930},[],{"categories":932},[530],{"categories":934},[530],{"categories":936},[476],{"categories":938},[],{"categories":940},[],{"categories":942},[],{"categories":944},[530],{"categories":946},[],{"categories":948},[530],{"categories":950},[530],{"categories":952},[525],{"categories":954},[530],{"categories":956},[476],{"categories":958},[],{"categories":960},[476],{"categories":962},[],{"categories":964},[525],{"categories":966},[530,967],"Product Strategy",{"categories":969},[539],{"categories":971},[880],{"categories":973},[967],{"categories":975},[476],{"categories":977},[530],{"categories":979},[],{"categories":981},[525],{"categories":983},[525],{"categories":985},[530],{"categories":987},[],{"categories":989},[530],{"categories":991},[476],{"categories":993},[476],{"categories":995},[570],{"categories":997},[476],{"categories":999},[],{"categories":1001},[476,539],{"categories":1003},[525],{"categories":1005},[476],{"categories":1007},[525],{"categories":1009},[530],{"categories":1011},[525],{"categories":1013},[],{"categories":1015},[539],{"categories":1017},[520],{"categories":1019},[],{"categories":1021},[530],{"categories":1023},[530],{"categories":1025},[530],{"categories":1027},[530],{"categories":1029},[520],{"categories":1031},[536],{"categories":1033},[533],{"categories":1035},[],{"categories":1037},[530],{"categories":1039},[],{"categories":1041},[525],{"categories":1043},[525],{"categories":1045},[525],{"categories":1047},[530],{"categories":1049},[525],{"categories":1051},[476],{"categories":1053},[570],{"categories":1055},[476],{"categories":1057},[539],{"categories":1059},[476,570],{"categories":1061},[570],{"categories":1063},[570],{"categories":1065},[570],{"categories":1067},[570],{"categories":1069},[476],{"categories":1071},[],{"categories":1073},[],{"categories":1075},[533],{"categories":1077},[],{"categories":1079},[476],{"categories":1081},[570],{"categories":1083},[476],{"categories":1085},[536],{"categories":1087},[539],{"categories":1089},[],{"categories":1091},[476],{"categories":1093},[570],{"categories":1095},[533],{"categories":1097},[525],{"categories":1099},[539],{"categories":1101},[476],{"categories":1103},[],{"categories":1105},[539],{"categories":1107},[536],{"categories":1109},[520],{"categories":1111},[520],{"categories":1113},[],{"categories":1115},[536],{"categories":1117},[520],{"categories":1119},[525],{"categories":1121},[570],{"categories":1123},[530],{"categories":1125},[530],{"categories":1127},[476],{"categories":1129},[476],{"categories":1131},[525],{"categories":1133},[525],{"categories":1135},[570],{"categories":1137},[525],{"categories":1139},[],{"categories":1141},[967],{"categories":1143},[530],{"categories":1145},[525],{"categories":1147},[525],{"categories":1149},[525],{"categories":1151},[476],{"categories":1153},[530],{"categories":1155},[530],{"categories":1157},[520],{"categories":1159},[520],{"categories":1161},[476],{"categories":1163},[525],{"categories":1165},[],{"categories":1167},[476],{"categories":1169},[520],{"categories":1171},[530],{"categories":1173},[530],{"categories":1175},[530],{"categories":1177},[536],{"categories":1179},[530],{"categories":1181},[570],{"categories":1183},[525],{"categories":1185},[525],{"categories":1187},[525],{"categories":1189},[525],{"categories":1191},[525],{"categories":1193},[],{"categories":1195},[],{"categories":1197},[570],{"categories":1199},[525],{"categories":1201},[525],{"categories":1203},[525],{"categories":1205},[],{"categories":1207},[476],{"categories":1209},[],{"categories":1211},[],{"categories":1213},[536],{"categories":1215},[520],{"categories":1217},[],{"categories":1219},[525],{"categories":1221},[530],{"categories":1223},[530],{"categories":1225},[530],{"categories":1227},[533],{"categories":1229},[530],{"categories":1231},[],{"categories":1233},[525],{"categories":1235},[525],{"categories":1237},[476],{"categories":1239},[],{"categories":1241},[533],{"categories":1243},[533],{"categories":1245},[476],{"categories":1247},[525],{"categories":1249},[520],{"categories":1251},[539],{"categories":1253},[476],{"categories":1255},[],{"categories":1257},[476],{"categories":1259},[476],{"categories":1261},[539],{"categories":1263},[476],{"categories":1265},[476],{"categories":1267},[476],{"categories":1269},[533],{"categories":1271},[525],{"categories":1273},[476],{"categories":1275},[476],{"categories":1277},[525],{"categories":1279},[530],{"categories":1281},[570],{"categories":1283},[520],{"categories":1285},[476],{"categories":1287},[570],{"categories":1289},[570],{"categories":1291},[],{"categories":1293},[533],{"categories":1295},[525],{"categories":1297},[525],{"categories":1299},[570],{"categories":1301},[530],{"categories":1303},[530],{"categories":1305},[530],{"categories":1307},[530],{"categories":1309},[536],{"categories":1311},[476],{"categories":1313},[476],{"categories":1315},[967],{"categories":1317},[476],{"categories":1319},[476],{"categories":1321},[530],{"categories":1323},[520],{"categories":1325},[533],{"categories":1327},[],{"categories":1329},[520],{"categories":1331},[520],{"categories":1333},[],{"categories":1335},[536],{"categories":1337},[476],{"categories":1339},[],{"categories":1341},[],{"categories":1343},[525],{"categories":1345},[525],{"categories":1347},[525],{"categories":1349},[525],{"categories":1351},[],{"categories":1353},[525],{"categories":1355},[476],{"categories":1357},[476],{"categories":1359},[],{"categories":1361},[525],{"categories":1363},[525],{"categories":1365},[520],{"categories":1367},[476],{"categories":1369},[],{"categories":1371},[],{"categories":1373},[525],{"categories":1375},[525],{"categories":1377},[525],{"categories":1379},[476],{"categories":1381},[525],{"categories":1383},[525],{"categories":1385},[525],{"categories":1387},[525],{"categories":1389},[525],{"categories":1391},[],{"categories":1393},[530],{"categories":1395},[476],{"categories":1397},[533],{"categories":1399},[520],{"categories":1401},[530],{"categories":1403},[476],{"categories":1405},[],{"categories":1407},[533],{"categories":1409},[525],{"categories":1411},[525],{"categories":1413},[525],{"categories":1415},[525],{"categories":1417},[570],{"categories":1419},[539],{"categories":1421},[],{"categories":1423},[476],{"categories":1425},[530],{"categories":1427},[530],{"categories":1429},[530],{"categories":1431},[880],{"categories":1433},[530],{"categories":1435},[476],{"categories":1437},[476],{"categories":1439},[539],{"categories":1441},[880],{"categories":1443},[615],{"categories":1445},[476],{"categories":1447},[615],{"categories":1449},[],{"categories":1451},[533],{"categories":1453},[533],{"categories":1455},[536],{"categories":1457},[880],{"categories":1459},[530],{"categories":1461},[476],{"categories":1463},[476],{"categories":1465},[530],{"categories":1467},[530],{"categories":1469},[530],{"categories":1471},[570],{"categories":1473},[570],{"categories":1475},[530],{"categories":1477},[530],{"categories":1479},[],{"categories":1481},[530],{"categories":1483},[530],{"categories":1485},[476],{"categories":1487},[615],{"categories":1489},[530],{"categories":1491},[530],{"categories":1493},[530],{"categories":1495},[530],{"categories":1497},[520],{"categories":1499},[536],{"categories":1501},[525],{"categories":1503},[539],{"categories":1505},[880],{"categories":1507},[539],{"categories":1509},[615],{"categories":1511},[],{"categories":1513},[539],{"categories":1515},[],{"categories":1517},[],{"categories":1519},[539],{"categories":1521},[476],{"categories":1523},[],{"categories":1525},[],{"categories":1527},[],{"categories":1529},[520],{"categories":1531},[],{"categories":1533},[],{"categories":1535},[615],{"categories":1537},[476],{"categories":1539},[880],{"categories":1541},[476],{"categories":1543},[],{"categories":1545},[530],{"categories":1547},[570],{"categories":1549},[570],{"categories":1551},[533],{"categories":1553},[533],{"categories":1555},[533],{"categories":1557},[880],{"categories":1559},[539],{"categories":1561},[530],{"categories":1563},[520],{"categories":1565},[520],{"categories":1567},[539],{"categories":1569},[536],{"categories":1571},[615],{"categories":1573},[536],{"categories":1575},[],{"categories":1577},[476],{"categories":1579},[530],{"categories":1581},[530],{"categories":1583},[570],{"categories":1585},[530],{"categories":1587},[530],{"categories":1589},[536],{"categories":1591},[536],{"categories":1593},[530],{"categories":1595},[880],{"categories":1597},[476],{"categories":1599},[],{"categories":1601},[533],{"categories":1603},[530],{"categories":1605},[520],{"categories":1607},[530],{"categories":1609},[530],{"categories":1611},[],{"categories":1613},[476],{"categories":1615},[530],{"categories":1617},[530],{"categories":1619},[570],{"categories":1621},[530],{"categories":1623},[476],{"categories":1625},[],{"categories":1627},[530],{"categories":1629},[],{"categories":1631},[536],{"categories":1633},[570],{"categories":1635},[476],{"categories":1637},[539],{"categories":1639},[536],{"categories":1641},[570],{"categories":1643},[615],{"categories":1645},[570],{"categories":1647},[],{"categories":1649},[476],{"categories":1651},[476],{"categories":1653},[967],{"categories":1655},[539],{"categories":1657},[476,530],{"categories":1659},[530],{"categories":1661},[476],{"categories":1663},[530],{"categories":1665},[530,539],{"categories":1667},[530],{"categories":1669},[476],{"categories":1671},[],{"categories":1673},[570],{"categories":1675},[476],{"categories":1677},[530],{"categories":1679},[476],{"categories":1681},[],{"categories":1683},[539],{"categories":1685},[520],{"categories":1687},[530],{"categories":1689},[],{"categories":1691},[615],{"categories":1693},[539],{"categories":1695},[530],{"categories":1697},[539],{"categories":1699},[],{"categories":1701},[530],{"categories":1703},[],{"categories":1705},[530],{"categories":1707},[],{"categories":1709},[],{"categories":1711},[536],{"categories":1713},[570],{"categories":1715},[476],{"categories":1717},[530],{"categories":1719},[],{"categories":1721},[530],{"categories":1723},[539],{"categories":1725},[476],{"categories":1727},[476],{"categories":1729},[539],{"categories":1731},[539],{"categories":1733},[570],{"categories":1735},[520],{"categories":1737},[],{"categories":1739},[476],{"categories":1741},[476],{"categories":1743},[476],{"categories":1745},[530],{"categories":1747},[476],{"categories":1749},[],{"categories":1751},[536],{"categories":1753},[476],{"categories":1755},[530],{"categories":1757},[],{"categories":1759},[476],{"categories":1761},[],{"categories":1763},[476],{"categories":1765},[],{"categories":1767},[],{"categories":1769},[],{"categories":1771},[476],{"categories":1773},[476],{"categories":1775},[476],{"categories":1777},[476],{"categories":1779},[],{"categories":1781},[476],{"categories":1783},[476],{"categories":1785},[476],{"categories":1787},[],{"categories":1789},[476],{"categories":1791},[],{"categories":1793},[533],{"categories":1795},[476],{"categories":1797},[],{"categories":1799},[],{"categories":1801},[],{"categories":1803},[476],{"categories":1805},[525],{"categories":1807},[525],{"categories":1809},[],{"categories":1811},[530],{"categories":1813},[476],{"categories":1815},[],{"categories":1817},[476],{"categories":1819},[476],{"categories":1821},[525],{"categories":1823},[],{"categories":1825},[476],{"categories":1827},[525],{"categories":1829},[530],{"categories":1831},[476],{"categories":1833},[],{"categories":1835},[],{"categories":1837},[],{"categories":1839},[530],{"categories":1841},[530],{"categories":1843},[530],{"categories":1845},[530],{"categories":1847},[476],{"categories":1849},[536],{"categories":1851},[536],{"categories":1853},[530],{"categories":1855},[530],{"categories":1857},[570],{"categories":1859},[967],{"categories":1861},[570],{"categories":1863},[570],{"categories":1865},[476],{"categories":1867},[530],{"categories":1869},[476],{"categories":1871},[570],{"categories":1873},[476],{"categories":1875},[530],{"categories":1877},[530],{"categories":1879},[530],{"categories":1881},[530],{"categories":1883},[530],{"categories":1885},[476],{"categories":1887},[570],{"categories":1889},[570],{"categories":1891},[533],{"categories":1893},[530],{"categories":1895},[],{"categories":1897},[530],{"categories":1899},[],{"categories":1901},[525],{"categories":1903},[476],{"categories":1905},[],{"categories":1907},[520],{"categories":1909},[536],{"categories":1911},[536],{"categories":1913},[530],{"categories":1915},[530],{"categories":1917},[476],{"categories":1919},[476],{"categories":1921},[525],{"categories":1923},[525],{"categories":1925},[880],{"categories":1927},[530],{"categories":1929},[525],{"categories":1931},[],{"categories":1933},[476],{"categories":1935},[530],{"categories":1937},[530],{"categories":1939},[530],{"categories":1941},[530],{"categories":1943},[476],{"categories":1945},[476],{"categories":1947},[476],{"categories":1949},[476],{"categories":1951},[530],{"categories":1953},[530],{"categories":1955},[530],{"categories":1957},[530],{"categories":1959},[],{"categories":1961},[536],{"categories":1963},[476],{"categories":1965},[476],{"categories":1967},[476],{"categories":1969},[],{"categories":1971},[533],{"categories":1973},[],{"categories":1975},[570],{"categories":1977},[],{"categories":1979},[530],{"categories":1981},[570],{"categories":1983},[536],{"categories":1985},[570],{"categories":1987},[],{"categories":1989},[570],{"categories":1991},[570],{"categories":1993},[],{"categories":1995},[536],{"categories":1997},[530],{"categories":1999},[530],{"categories":2001},[570],{"categories":2003},[476],{"categories":2005},[476],{"categories":2007},[],{"categories":2009},[525],{"categories":2011},[],{"categories":2013},[533],{"categories":2015},[],{"categories":2017},[536],{"categories":2019},[525],{"categories":2021},[536],{"categories":2023},[536],{"categories":2025},[536],{"categories":2027},[536],{"categories":2029},[536],{"categories":2031},[536],{"categories":2033},[536],{"categories":2035},[536],{"categories":2037},[536],{"categories":2039},[536],{"categories":2041},[],{"categories":2043},[530],{"categories":2045},[536],{"categories":2047},[476],{"categories":2049},[476],{"categories":2051},[536],{"categories":2053},[536],{"categories":2055},[536],{"categories":2057},[536],{"categories":2059},[536],{"categories":2061},[536],{"categories":2063},[536],{"categories":2065},[476,536],{"categories":2067},[536],{"categories":2069},[536],{"categories":2071},[536],{"categories":2073},[536],{"categories":2075},[],{"categories":2077},[536],{"categories":2079},[536],{"categories":2081},[536],{"categories":2083},[536],{"categories":2085},[536],{"categories":2087},[536],{"categories":2089},[536],{"categories":2091},[536],{"categories":2093},[536],{"categories":2095},[536,476],{"categories":2097},[536],{"categories":2099},[536],{"categories":2101},[],{"categories":2103},[525],{"categories":2105},[],{"categories":2107},[476],{"categories":2109},[],{"categories":2111},[530],{"categories":2113},[880],{"categories":2115},[967],{"categories":2117},[530],{"categories":2119},[530],{"categories":2121},[],{"categories":2123},[530],{"categories":2125},[],{"categories":2127},[530],{"categories":2129},[],{"categories":2131},[],{"categories":2133},[476],{"categories":2135},[476],{"categories":2137},[476],{"categories":2139},[525],{"categories":2141},[525],{"categories":2143},[525],{"categories":2145},[525],{"categories":2147},[],{"categories":2149},[525],{"categories":2151},[],{"categories":2153},[525],{"categories":2155},[476],{"categories":2157},[525],{"categories":2159},[525],{"categories":2161},[525],{"categories":2163},[525],{"categories":2165},[476],{"categories":2167},[525],{"categories":2169},[530],{"categories":2171},[],{"categories":2173},[530],{"categories":2175},[525],{"categories":2177},[476],{"categories":2179},[525],{"categories":2181},[525],{"categories":2183},[525],{"categories":2185},[476],{"categories":2187},[476],{"categories":2189},[476],{"categories":2191},[],{"categories":2193},[],{"categories":2195},[476],{"categories":2197},[525],{"categories":2199},[],{"categories":2201},[476],{"categories":2203},[530],{"categories":2205},[476],{"categories":2207},[530],{"categories":2209},[530],{"categories":2211},[476],{"categories":2213},[],{"categories":2215},[],{"categories":2217},[530],{"categories":2219},[530],{"categories":2221},[530],{"categories":2223},[530],{"categories":2225},[530],{"categories":2227},[530],{"categories":2229},[530],{"categories":2231},[530],{"categories":2233},[],{"categories":2235},[530],{"categories":2237},[530],{"categories":2239},[530],{"categories":2241},[476],{"categories":2243},[476],{"categories":2245},[476],{"categories":2247},[525],{"categories":2249},[476],{"categories":2251},[476],{"categories":2253},[476],{"categories":2255},[530],{"categories":2257},[533],{"categories":2259},[533],{"categories":2261},[533],{"categories":2263},[530],{"categories":2265},[],{"categories":2267},[476],{"categories":2269},[],{"categories":2271},[],{"categories":2273},[476],{"categories":2275},[],{"categories":2277},[530],{"categories":2279},[536],{"categories":2281},[570],{"categories":2283},[615],{"categories":2285},[476],{"categories":2287},[530],{"categories":2289},[536],{"categories":2291},[],{"categories":2293},[530],{"categories":2295},[533,520],{"categories":2297},[530],{"categories":2299},[530],{"categories":2301},[880],{"categories":2303},[539],{"categories":2305},[533],{"categories":2307},[570],{"categories":2309},[476],{"categories":2311},[],{"categories":2313},[476],{"categories":2315},[],{"categories":2317},[476],{"categories":2319},[476],{"categories":2321},[530],{"categories":2323},[],{"categories":2325},[476],{"categories":2327},[530],{"categories":2329},[476],{"categories":2331},[570],{"categories":2333},[530],{"categories":2335},[476],{"categories":2337},[476,570],{"categories":2339},[570],{"categories":2341},[],{"categories":2343},[476],{"categories":2345},[476],{"categories":2347},[476],{"categories":2349},[],{"categories":2351},[],{"categories":2353},[530],{"categories":2355},[533],{"categories":2357},[525],{"categories":2359},[530],{"categories":2361},[476],{"categories":2363},[525],{"categories":2365},[],{"categories":2367},[570],{"categories":2369},[525],{"categories":2371},[],{"categories":2373},[615],{"categories":2375},[533],{"categories":2377},[520],{"categories":2379},[525],{"categories":2381},[476],{"categories":2383},[530],{"categories":2385},[476],{"categories":2387},[530],{"categories":2389},[530],{"categories":2391},[525],{"categories":2393},[570],{"categories":2395},[536],{"categories":2397},[520],{"categories":2399},[476],{"categories":2401},[476],{"categories":2403},[],{"categories":2405},[],{"categories":2407},[476],{"categories":2409},[],{"categories":2411},[476],{"categories":2413},[525],{"categories":2415},[],{"categories":2417},[530],{"categories":2419},[570],{"categories":2421},[525],{"categories":2423},[570],{"categories":2425},[530],{"categories":2427},[476],{"categories":2429},[],{"categories":2431},[530],{"categories":2433},[530],{"categories":2435},[536],{"categories":2437},[530],{"categories":2439},[536],{"categories":2441},[530],{"categories":2443},[530],{"categories":2445},[536],{"categories":2447},[],{"categories":2449},[],{"categories":2451},[536],{"categories":2453},[536],{"categories":2455},[536],{"categories":2457},[539],{"categories":2459},[570],{"categories":2461},[570],{"categories":2463},[530],{"categories":2465},[525],{"categories":2467},[570],{"categories":2469},[570],{"categories":2471},[533],{"categories":2473},[536],{"categories":2475},[530],{"categories":2477},[530],{"categories":2479},[476],{"categories":2481},[570],{"categories":2483},[476],{"categories":2485},[],{"categories":2487},[880],{"categories":2489},[967],{"categories":2491},[],{"categories":2493},[],{"categories":2495},[530],{"categories":2497},[525],{"categories":2499},[533],{"categories":2501},[533],{"categories":2503},[615],{"categories":2505},[536],{"categories":2507},[615],{"categories":2509},[615],{"categories":2511},[530],{"categories":2513},[],{"categories":2515},[],{"categories":2517},[615],{"categories":2519},[539],{"categories":2521},[476],{"categories":2523},[539],{"categories":2525},[615],{"categories":2527},[539],{"categories":2529},[615],{"categories":2531},[520],{"categories":2533},[539],{"categories":2535},[570],{"categories":2537},[476],{"categories":2539},[],{"categories":2541},[615],{"categories":2543},[880],{"categories":2545},[],{"categories":2547},[476],{"categories":2549},[476],{"categories":2551},[],{"categories":2553},[],{"categories":2555},[476],{"categories":2557},[476],{"categories":2559},[525],{"categories":2561},[476],{"categories":2563},[],{"categories":2565},[525],{"categories":2567},[],{"categories":2569},[],{"categories":2571},[525],{"categories":2573},[525],{"categories":2575},[476],{"categories":2577},[476],{"categories":2579},[476],{"categories":2581},[476],{"categories":2583},[476],{"categories":2585},[476],{"categories":2587},[533],{"categories":2589},[],{"categories":2591},[476],{"categories":2593},[],{"categories":2595},[],{"categories":2597},[530],{"categories":2599},[570],{"categories":2601},[],{"categories":2603},[880],{"categories":2605},[476,880],{"categories":2607},[476],{"categories":2609},[],{"categories":2611},[536],{"categories":2613},[536],{"categories":2615},[536],{"categories":2617},[536],{"categories":2619},[536],{"categories":2621},[],{"categories":2623},[],{"categories":2625},[],{"categories":2627},[539],{"categories":2629},[530],{"categories":2631},[520],{"categories":2633},[539],{"categories":2635},[570],{"categories":2637},[536],{"categories":2639},[],{"categories":2641},[533],{"categories":2643},[967],{"categories":2645},[615],{"categories":2647},[615],{"categories":2649},[615],{"categories":2651},[570],{"categories":2653},[967],{"categories":2655},[570],{"categories":2657},[],{"categories":2659},[520],{"categories":2661},[539],{"categories":2663},[476],{"categories":2665},[536],{"categories":2667},[533],{"categories":2669},[539],{"categories":2671},[533],{"categories":2673},[476],{"categories":2675},[536],{"categories":2677},[539],{"categories":2679},[880],{"categories":2681},[476],{"categories":2683},[525],{"categories":2685},[539],{"categories":2687},[],{"categories":2689},[476],{"categories":2691},[539],{"categories":2693},[539],{"categories":2695},[530],{"categories":2697},[],{"categories":2699},[533],{"categories":2701},[533],{"categories":2703},[533],{"categories":2705},[530],{"categories":2707},[476],{"categories":2709},[],{"categories":2711},[520],{"categories":2713},[570],{"categories":2715},[570],{"categories":2717},[615],{"categories":2719},[520],{"categories":2721},[525],{"categories":2723},[615],{"categories":2725},[],{"categories":2727},[525],{"categories":2729},[525],{"categories":2731},[525],{"categories":2733},[476],{"categories":2735},[520],{"categories":2737},[476],{"categories":2739},[],{"categories":2741},[],{"categories":2743},[],{"categories":2745},[539],{"categories":2747},[530],{"categories":2749},[],{"categories":2751},[570],{"categories":2753},[536],{"categories":2755},[],{"categories":2757},[533],{"categories":2759},[],{"categories":2761},[536],{"categories":2763},[476],{"categories":2765},[570],{"categories":2767},[520],{"categories":2769},[],{"categories":2771},[536],{"categories":2773},[536],{"categories":2775},[476],{"categories":2777},[],{"categories":2779},[],{"categories":2781},[539],{"categories":2783},[476],{"categories":2785},[],{"categories":2787},[530],{"categories":2789},[476],{"categories":2791},[],{"categories":2793},[539],{"categories":2795},[530],{"categories":2797},[476],{"categories":2799},[615],{"categories":2801},[476],{"categories":2803},[],{"categories":2805},[615],{"categories":2807},[476],{"categories":2809},[539],{"categories":2811},[476],{"categories":2813},[615],{"categories":2815},[530],{"categories":2817},[476],{"categories":2819},[476],{"categories":2821},[476,530],{"categories":2823},[530],{"categories":2825},[530],{"categories":2827},[530],{"categories":2829},[536],{"categories":2831},[570],{"categories":2833},[476],{"categories":2835},[570],{"categories":2837},[536],{"categories":2839},[476],{"categories":2841},[],{"categories":2843},[],{"categories":2845},[476],{"categories":2847},[476],{"categories":2849},[476],{"categories":2851},[530],{"categories":2853},[476],{"categories":2855},[],{"categories":2857},[476],{"categories":2859},[476],{"categories":2861},[530],{"categories":2863},[530],{"categories":2865},[476],{"categories":2867},[476],{"categories":2869},[],{"categories":2871},[476],{"categories":2873},[],{"categories":2875},[476],{"categories":2877},[476],{"categories":2879},[476],{"categories":2881},[476],{"categories":2883},[476],{"categories":2885},[476],{"categories":2887},[476],{"categories":2889},[],{"categories":2891},[476],{"categories":2893},[525],{"categories":2895},[525],{"categories":2897},[],{"categories":2899},[],{"categories":2901},[476],{"categories":2903},[],{"categories":2905},[476],{"categories":2907},[476,880],{"categories":2909},[],{"categories":2911},[525],{"categories":2913},[],{"categories":2915},[476],{"categories":2917},[],{"categories":2919},[],{"categories":2921},[],{"categories":2923},[476],{"categories":2925},[],{"categories":2927},[476],{"categories":2929},[],{"categories":2931},[476],{"categories":2933},[476],{"categories":2935},[],{"categories":2937},[],{"categories":2939},[476,880],{"categories":2941},[880,476],{"categories":2943},[525],{"categories":2945},[],{"categories":2947},[476],{"categories":2949},[],{"categories":2951},[476],{"categories":2953},[476],{"categories":2955},[],{"categories":2957},[525],{"categories":2959},[476,520],{"categories":2961},[525],{"categories":2963},[539],{"categories":2965},[],{"categories":2967},[530],{"categories":2969},[476],{"categories":2971},[533],{"categories":2973},[476],{"categories":2975},[570],{"categories":2977},[570],{"categories":2979},[880],{"categories":2981},[525],{"categories":2983},[476],{"categories":2985},[880],{"categories":2987},[539],{"categories":2989},[476],{"categories":2991},[570],{"categories":2993},[],{"categories":2995},[476],{"categories":2997},[],{"categories":2999},[],{"categories":3001},[476],{"categories":3003},[],{"categories":3005},[476],{"categories":3007},[539],{"categories":3009},[520],{"categories":3011},[570],{"categories":3013},[533],{"categories":3015},[530],{"categories":3017},[570],{"categories":3019},[],{"categories":3021},[533],{"categories":3023},[],{"categories":3025},[],{"categories":3027},[476],{"categories":3029},[525],{"categories":3031},[533],{"categories":3033},[],{"categories":3035},[476],{"categories":3037},[525],{"categories":3039},[525],{"categories":3041},[533],{"categories":3043},[525],{"categories":3045},[476],{"categories":3047},[525],{"categories":3049},[476],{"categories":3051},[],{"categories":3053},[476],{"categories":3055},[476],{"categories":3057},[476],{"categories":3059},[525],{"categories":3061},[],{"categories":3063},[],{"categories":3065},[536],{"categories":3067},[525],{"categories":3069},[],{"categories":3071},[476],{"categories":3073},[476],{"categories":3075},[476],{"categories":3077},[476],{"categories":3079},[476],{"categories":3081},[476],{"categories":3083},[476],{"categories":3085},[476],{"categories":3087},[476],{"categories":3089},[533],{"categories":3091},[476,536],{"categories":3093},[525],{"categories":3095},[525],{"categories":3097},[476],{"categories":3099},[539],{"categories":3101},[615],{"categories":3103},[476],{"categories":3105},[476],{"categories":3107},[],{"categories":3109},[],{"categories":3111},[476],{"categories":3113},[476],{"categories":3115},[],{"categories":3117},[536],{"categories":3119},[536],{"categories":3121},[570],{"categories":3123},[476],{"categories":3125},[570],{"categories":3127},[476],{"categories":3129},[476],{"categories":3131},[],{"categories":3133},[476],{"categories":3135},[],{"categories":3137},[],{"categories":3139},[476],{"categories":3141},[],{"categories":3143},[],{"categories":3145},[525],{"categories":3147},[],{"categories":3149},[476],{"categories":3151},[476],{"categories":3153},[476],{"categories":3155},[],{"categories":3157},[476],{"categories":3159},[525],{"categories":3161},[967],{"categories":3163},[530],{"categories":3165},[476],{"categories":3167},[],{"categories":3169},[530],{"categories":3171},[476],{"categories":3173},[],{"categories":3175},[476],{"categories":3177},[],{"categories":3179},[530],{"categories":3181},[],{"categories":3183},[],{"categories":3185},[530],{"categories":3187},[530],{"categories":3189},[530],{"categories":3191},[476],{"categories":3193},[],{"categories":3195},[530],{"categories":3197},[530],{"categories":3199},[],{"categories":3201},[],{"categories":3203},[530],{"categories":3205},[476],{"categories":3207},[525],{"categories":3209},[967],{"categories":3211},[533],{"categories":3213},[],{"categories":3215},[536],{"categories":3217},[476],{"categories":3219},[476],{"categories":3221},[520],{"categories":3223},[525],{"categories":3225},[525],{"categories":3227},[525],{"categories":3229},[525],{"categories":3231},[],{"categories":3233},[530],{"categories":3235},[530],{"categories":3237},[530],{"categories":3239},[530],{"categories":3241},[570],{"categories":3243},[476],{"categories":3245},[520],{"categories":3247},[],{"categories":3249},[570],{"categories":3251},[530],{"categories":3253},[536],{"categories":3255},[536],{"categories":3257},[536],{"categories":3259},[536],{"categories":3261},[536],{"categories":3263},[536],{"categories":3265},[476,520],{"categories":3267},[530],{"categories":3269},[520],{"categories":3271},[525],{"categories":3273},[525],{"categories":3275},[570],{"categories":3277},[],{"categories":3279},[],{"categories":3281},[533],{"categories":3283},[],{"categories":3285},[476],{"categories":3287},[533],{"categories":3289},[476],{"categories":3291},[539],{"categories":3293},[530],{"categories":3295},[520],{"categories":3297},[530],{"categories":3299},[539],{"categories":3301},[570],{"categories":3303},[530],{"categories":3305},[],{"categories":3307},[570],{"categories":3309},[],{"categories":3311},[],{"categories":3313},[530],{"categories":3315},[530],{"categories":3317},[530],{"categories":3319},[476],{"categories":3321},[476],{"categories":3323},[476],{"categories":3325},[476],{"categories":3327},[476],{"categories":3329},[],{"categories":3331},[880],{"categories":3333},[476],{"categories":3335},[],{"categories":3337},[],{"categories":3339},[],{"categories":3341},[570],{"categories":3343},[],{"categories":3345},[476],{"categories":3347},[],{"categories":3349},[525],{"categories":3351},[476],{"categories":3353},[525],{"categories":3355},[476],{"categories":3357},[530],{"categories":3359},[],{"categories":3361},[476],{"categories":3363},[476],{"categories":3365},[],{"categories":3367},[615],{"categories":3369},[615],{"categories":3371},[539],{"categories":3373},[536],{"categories":3375},[],{"categories":3377},[476],{"categories":3379},[530],{"categories":3381},[],{"categories":3383},[],{"categories":3385},[476],{"categories":3387},[539],{"categories":3389},[530],{"categories":3391},[520],{"categories":3393},[570,539],{"categories":3395},[539],{"categories":3397},[476],{"categories":3399},[530],{"categories":3401},[],{"categories":3403},[],{"categories":3405},[],{"categories":3407},[],{"categories":3409},[],{"categories":3411},[],{"categories":3413},[476],{"categories":3415},[],{"categories":3417},[],{"categories":3419},[476],{"categories":3421},[],{"categories":3423},[],{"categories":3425},[],{"categories":3427},[476],{"categories":3429},[525],{"categories":3431},[],{"categories":3433},[],{"categories":3435},[],{"categories":3437},[476],{"categories":3439},[],{"categories":3441},[476],{"categories":3443},[476],{"categories":3445},[],{"categories":3447},[476],{"categories":3449},[539],{"categories":3451},[],{"categories":3453},[570],{"categories":3455},[570],{"categories":3457},[],{"categories":3459},[533],{"categories":3461},[],{"categories":3463},[],{"categories":3465},[],{"categories":3467},[536],{"categories":3469},[525],{"categories":3471},[530],{"categories":3473},[476],{"categories":3475},[520],{"categories":3477},[476],{"categories":3479},[],{"categories":3481},[],{"categories":3483},[520],{"categories":3485},[533],{"categories":3487},[530],{"categories":3489},[],{"categories":3491},[880],{"categories":3493},[],{"categories":3495},[533],{"categories":3497},[476],{"categories":3499},[476],{"categories":3501},[533],{"categories":3503},[476],{"categories":3505},[536],{"categories":3507},[530],{"categories":3509},[476],{"categories":3511},[530],{"categories":3513},[476],{"categories":3515},[530],{"categories":3517},[570],{"categories":3519},[570],{"categories":3521},[536],{"categories":3523},[],{"categories":3525},[476],{"categories":3527},[476],{"categories":3529},[533],{"categories":3531},[967],{"categories":3533},[570],{"categories":3535},[525],{"categories":3537},[476],{"categories":3539},[525],{"categories":3541},[476],{"categories":3543},[476],{"categories":3545},[],{"categories":3547},[476],{"categories":3549},[],{"categories":3551},[476],{"categories":3553},[533],{"categories":3555},[476],{"categories":3557},[476],{"categories":3559},[476],{"categories":3561},[],{"categories":3563},[476],{"categories":3565},[476],{"categories":3567},[967],{"categories":3569},[],{"categories":3571},[525],{"categories":3573},[880],{"categories":3575},[539],{"categories":3577},[],{"categories":3579},[615],{"categories":3581},[],{"categories":3583},[],{"categories":3585},[525],{"categories":3587},[476],{"categories":3589},[],{"categories":3591},[476],{"categories":3593},[476],{"categories":3595},[530],{"categories":3597},[476],{"categories":3599},[525],{"categories":3601},[525],{"categories":3603},[536],{"categories":3605},[536],{"categories":3607},[536],{"categories":3609},[476],{"categories":3611},[615],{"categories":3613},[525],{"categories":3615},[570],{"categories":3617},[],{"categories":3619},[536],{"categories":3621},[536],{"categories":3623},[880],{"categories":3625},[536],{"categories":3627},[536],{"categories":3629},[530],{"categories":3631},[525],{"categories":3633},[880],{"categories":3635},[476],{"categories":3637},[476],{"categories":3639},[476],{"categories":3641},[476],{"categories":3643},[],{"categories":3645},[530],{"categories":3647},[476],{"categories":3649},[536],{"categories":3651},[],{"categories":3653},[],{"categories":3655},[525],{"categories":3657},[],{"categories":3659},[530],{"categories":3661},[530],{"categories":3663},[530],{"categories":3665},[530],{"categories":3667},[530],{"categories":3669},[530],{"categories":3671},[530],{"categories":3673},[530],{"categories":3675},[],{"categories":3677},[],{"categories":3679},[476],{"categories":3681},[],{"categories":3683},[530],{"categories":3685},[570],{"categories":3687},[570],{"categories":3689},[615],{"categories":3691},[520],{"categories":3693},[],{"categories":3695},[],{"categories":3697},[],{"categories":3699},[536],{"categories":3701},[476],{"categories":3703},[],{"categories":3705},[520],{"categories":3707},[520],{"categories":3709},[536],{"categories":3711},[570],{"categories":3713},[615],{"categories":3715},[536],{"categories":3717},[536],{"categories":3719},[],{"categories":3721},[530],{"categories":3723},[520],{"categories":3725},[520],{"categories":3727},[476],{"categories":3729},[530],{"categories":3731},[539],{"categories":3733},[536],{"categories":3735},[],{"categories":3737},[533],{"categories":3739},[615],{"categories":3741},[525],{"categories":3743},[525],{"categories":3745},[525],{"categories":3747},[880],{"categories":3749},[],{"categories":3751},[530],{"categories":3753},[],{"categories":3755},[530],{"categories":3757},[530],{"categories":3759},[476],{"categories":3761},[476],{"categories":3763},[539],{"categories":3765},[530],{"categories":3767},[539],{"categories":3769},[],{"categories":3771},[530],{"categories":3773},[536],{"categories":3775},[536],{"categories":3777},[536],{"categories":3779},[476],{"categories":3781},[530],{"categories":3783},[476],{"categories":3785},[520],{"categories":3787},[525],{"categories":3789},[536],{"categories":3791},[525],{"categories":3793},[476],{"categories":3795},[],{"categories":3797},[525],{"categories":3799},[530],{"categories":3801},[525],{"categories":3803},[525],{"categories":3805},[525],{"categories":3807},[525],{"categories":3809},[],{"categories":3811},[],{"categories":3813},[525],{"categories":3815},[525],{"categories":3817},[],{"categories":3819},[525],{"categories":3821},[525],{"categories":3823},[476],{"categories":3825},[476],{"categories":3827},[525],{"categories":3829},[525],{"categories":3831},[476],{"categories":3833},[],{"categories":3835},[476],{"categories":3837},[530],{"categories":3839},[476],{"categories":3841},[476],{"categories":3843},[],{"categories":3845},[476],{"categories":3847},[476],{"categories":3849},[476],{"categories":3851},[525],{"categories":3853},[],{"categories":3855},[],{"categories":3857},[],{"categories":3859},[],{"categories":3861},[476],{"categories":3863},[476],{"categories":3865},[],{"categories":3867},[533],{"categories":3869},[525],{"categories":3871},[],{"categories":3873},[],{"categories":3875},[],{"categories":3877},[],{"categories":3879},[],{"categories":3881},[476],{"categories":3883},[],{"categories":3885},[],{"categories":3887},[476],{"categories":3889},[],{"categories":3891},[530],{"categories":3893},[530],{"categories":3895},[530],{"categories":3897},[520],{"categories":3899},[],{"categories":3901},[533],{"categories":3903},[539],{"categories":3905},[539],{"categories":3907},[880],{"categories":3909},[525],{"categories":3911},[],{"categories":3913},[476],{"categories":3915},[476],{"categories":3917},[520],{"categories":3919},[],{"categories":3921},[520],{"categories":3923},[],{"categories":3925},[],{"categories":3927},[],{"categories":3929},[539],{"categories":3931},[530],{"categories":3933},[530],{"categories":3935},[530],{"categories":3937},[530],{"categories":3939},[530],{"categories":3941},[],{"categories":3943},[525],{"categories":3945},[476],{"categories":3947},[476],{"categories":3949},[476],{"categories":3951},[],{"categories":3953},[520],{"categories":3955},[],{"categories":3957},[536],{"categories":3959},[615],{"categories":3961},[536],{"categories":3963},[],{"categories":3965},[],{"categories":3967},[476],{"categories":3969},[530],{"categories":3971},[],{"categories":3973},[476],{"categories":3975},[476],{"categories":3977},[476],{"categories":3979},[530],{"categories":3981},[530],{"categories":3983},[476],{"categories":3985},[615],{"categories":3987},[530],{"categories":3989},[],{"categories":3991},[476],{"categories":3993},[],{"categories":3995},[967],{"categories":3997},[539],{"categories":3999},[615],{"categories":4001},[539],{"categories":4003},[880],{"categories":4005},[476],{"categories":4007},[539],{"categories":4009},[525],{"categories":4011},[880],{"categories":4013},[539],{"categories":4015},[536],{"categories":4017},[536],{"categories":4019},[],{"categories":4021},[539],{"categories":4023},[],{"categories":4025},[570],{"categories":4027},[539],{"categories":4029},[],{"categories":4031},[615],{"categories":4033},[615],{"categories":4035},[967],{"categories":4037},[],{"categories":4039},[476],{"categories":4041},[539],{"categories":4043},[880],{"categories":4045},[530],{"categories":4047},[530],{"categories":4049},[615],{"categories":4051},[476],{"categories":4053},[570],{"categories":4055},[476],{"categories":4057},[],{"categories":4059},[],{"categories":4061},[],{"categories":4063},[533],{"categories":4065},[476],{"categories":4067},[536],{"categories":4069},[539],{"categories":4071},[539],{"categories":4073},[476],{"categories":4075},[533],{"categories":4077},[570],{"categories":4079},[476],{"categories":4081},[539],{"categories":4083},[476],{"categories":4085},[539],{"categories":4087},[570],{"categories":4089},[570],{"categories":4091},[530],{"categories":4093},[570],{"categories":4095},[539],{"categories":4097},[520],{"categories":4099},[539],{"categories":4101},[539],{"categories":4103},[539],{"categories":4105},[539],{"categories":4107},[],{"categories":4109},[525],{"categories":4111},[],{"categories":4113},[615],{"categories":4115},[476],{"categories":4117},[476],{"categories":4119},[],{"categories":4121},[],{"categories":4123},[],{"categories":4125},[476],{"categories":4127},[525],{"categories":4129},[476],{"categories":4131},[476],{"categories":4133},[],{"categories":4135},[476],{"categories":4137},[536],{"categories":4139},[476],{"categories":4141},[476],{"categories":4143},[476],{"categories":4145},[],{"categories":4147},[],{"categories":4149},[],{"categories":4151},[880],{"categories":4153},[880],{"categories":4155},[520],{"categories":4157},[530],{"categories":4159},[520,533],{"categories":4161},[476],{"categories":4163},[525],{"categories":4165},[],{"categories":4167},[536],{"categories":4169},[615],{"categories":4171},[476],{"categories":4173},[539],{"categories":4175},[476],{"categories":4177},[],{"categories":4179},[615],{"categories":4181},[880],{"categories":4183},[530],{"categories":4185},[520],{"categories":4187},[880],{"categories":4189},[530],{"categories":4191},[570],{"categories":4193},[530],{"categories":4195},[570],{"categories":4197},[476],{"categories":4199},[570],{"categories":4201},[570],{"categories":4203},[539],{"categories":4205},[615],{"categories":4207},[476],{"categories":4209},[533],{"categories":4211},[],{"categories":4213},[476],{"categories":4215},[536],{"categories":4217},[615],{"categories":4219},[520],{"categories":4221},[476],{"categories":4223},[615],{"categories":4225},[570],{"categories":4227},[476],{"categories":4229},[476],{"categories":4231},[615],{"categories":4233},[476],{"categories":4235},[570],{"categories":4237},[476],{"categories":4239},[],{"categories":4241},[476],{"categories":4243},[476],{"categories":4245},[476],{"categories":4247},[476],{"categories":4249},[],{"categories":4251},[530],{"categories":4253},[880],{"categories":4255},[],{"categories":4257},[],{"categories":4259},[476],{"categories":4261},[520],{"categories":4263},[533],{"categories":4265},[520],{"categories":4267},[520],{"categories":4269},[530],{"categories":4271},[],{"categories":4273},[476],{"categories":4275},[525],{"categories":4277},[476],{"categories":4279},[476],{"categories":4281},[],{"categories":4283},[530],{"categories":4285},[525],{"categories":4287},[476,880],{"categories":4289},[530,880],{"categories":4291},[880],{"categories":4293},[476],{"categories":4295},[530],{"categories":4297},[530],{"categories":4299},[539],{"categories":4301},[539],{"categories":4303},[539],{"categories":4305},[476],{"categories":4307},[536],{"categories":4309},[530],{"categories":4311},[],{"categories":4313},[880],{"categories":4315},[],{"categories":4317},[880],{"categories":4319},[880],{"categories":4321},[520],{"categories":4323},[530],{"categories":4325},[],{"categories":4327},[880],{"categories":4329},[476],{"categories":4331},[525],{"categories":4333},[476],{"categories":4335},[536],{"categories":4337},[539],{"categories":4339},[539],{"categories":4341},[539],{"categories":4343},[880],{"categories":4345},[],{"categories":4347},[],{"categories":4349},[],{"categories":4351},[476],{"categories":4353},[539],{"categories":4355},[476],{"categories":4357},[539],{"categories":4359},[880],{"categories":4361},[880],{"categories":4363},[476],{"categories":4365},[530],{"categories":4367},[],{"categories":4369},[476],{"categories":4371},[476],{"categories":4373},[476],{"categories":4375},[],{"categories":4377},[],{"categories":4379},[880],{"categories":4381},[880],{"categories":4383},[476,880],{"categories":4385},[530],{"categories":4387},[530],{"categories":4389},[530],{"categories":4391},[530],{"categories":4393},[530],{"categories":4395},[530],{"categories":4397},[],{"categories":4399},[539],{"categories":4401},[476],{"categories":4403},[539],{"categories":4405},[533],{"categories":4407},[476],{"categories":4409},[967],{"categories":4411},[967],{"categories":4413},[530],{"categories":4415},[539],{"categories":4417},[],{"categories":4419},[530],{"categories":4421},[476],{"categories":4423},[],{"categories":4425},[536],{"categories":4427},[],{"categories":4429},[476],{"categories":4431},[530],{"categories":4433},[525],{"categories":4435},[476],{"categories":4437},[],{"categories":4439},[],{"categories":4441},[536],{"categories":4443},[536],{"categories":4445},[570],{"categories":4447},[536],{"categories":4449},[530],{"categories":4451},[],{"categories":4453},[530],{"categories":4455},[525],{"categories":4457},[476],{"categories":4459},[476],{"categories":4461},[],{"categories":4463},[476],{"categories":4465},[570],{"categories":4467},[476],{"categories":4469},[],{"categories":4471},[615],{"categories":4473},[539],{"categories":4475},[539],{"categories":4477},[520],{"categories":4479},[520],{"categories":4481},[520],{"categories":4483},[530],{"categories":4485},[520],{"categories":4487},[530],{"categories":4489},[880],{"categories":4491},[967],{"categories":4493},[525],{"categories":4495},[525],{"categories":4497},[525],{"categories":4499},[880],{"categories":4501},[525,520],{"categories":4503},[615],{"categories":4505},[530],{"categories":4507},[],{"categories":4509},[476],{"categories":4511},[],{"categories":4513},[539],{"categories":4515},[615],{"categories":4517},[536],{"categories":4519},[539],{"categories":4521},[570],{"categories":4523},[],{"categories":4525},[530],{"categories":4527},[],{"categories":4529},[967],{"categories":4531},[],{"categories":4533},[536],{"categories":4535},[536],{"categories":4537},[615],{"categories":4539},[],{"categories":4541},[476],{"categories":4543},[615],{"categories":4545},[],{"categories":4547},[476],{"categories":4549},[476],{"categories":4551},[],{"categories":4553},[570],{"categories":4555},[476],{"categories":4557},[],{"categories":4559},[476],{"categories":4561},[],{"categories":4563},[],{"categories":4565},[530],{"categories":4567},[530],{"categories":4569},[],{"categories":4571},[539],{"categories":4573},[539],{"categories":4575},[539],{"categories":4577},[476,530],{"categories":4579},[530],{"categories":4581},[530],{"categories":4583},[530],{"categories":4585},[615],{"categories":4587},[615],{"categories":4589},[],{"categories":4591},[525],{"categories":4593},[476],{"categories":4595},[615],{"categories":4597},[615],{"categories":4599},[525],{"categories":4601},[520],{"categories":4603},[530],{"categories":4605},[539],{"categories":4607},[476],{"categories":4609},[476],{"categories":4611},[530],{"categories":4613},[539],{"categories":4615},[530],{"categories":4617},[476],{"categories":4619},[533],{"categories":4621},[],{"categories":4623},[476],{"categories":4625},[],{"categories":4627},[476],{"categories":4629},[476],{"categories":4631},[539],{"categories":4633},[],{"categories":4635},[615],{"categories":4637},[476],{"categories":4639},[530],{"categories":4641},[530],{"categories":4643},[539],{"categories":4645},[570],{"categories":4647},[570],{"categories":4649},[525],{"categories":4651},[476],{"categories":4653},[530],{"categories":4655},[],{"categories":4657},[530],{"categories":4659},[476],{"categories":4661},[525],{"categories":4663},[476],{"categories":4665},[476],{"categories":4667},[476],{"categories":4669},[530],{"categories":4671},[615],{"categories":4673},[476],{"categories":4675},[536],{"categories":4677},[476],{"categories":4679},[476],{"categories":4681},[476],{"categories":4683},[476],{"categories":4685},[],{"categories":4687},[476],{"categories":4689},[615],{"categories":4691},[536],{"categories":4693},[476],{"categories":4695},[536],{"categories":4697},[],{"categories":4699},[],{"categories":4701},[],{"categories":4703},[476],{"categories":4705},[],{"categories":4707},[],{"categories":4709},[],{"categories":4711},[],{"categories":4713},[530],{"categories":4715},[570],{"categories":4717},[530],{"categories":4719},[530],{"categories":4721},[539],{"categories":4723},[520],{"categories":4725},[476],{"categories":4727},[476],{"categories":4729},[476],{"categories":4731},[520],{"categories":4733},[570],{"categories":4735},[],{"categories":4737},[615],{"categories":4739},[533],{"categories":4741},[476],{"categories":4743},[536],{"categories":4745},[570],{"categories":4747},[570],{"categories":4749},[967],{"categories":4751},[530],{"categories":4753},[476],{"categories":4755},[476],{"categories":4757},[570],{"categories":4759},[476],{"categories":4761},[],{"categories":4763},[],{"categories":4765},[880],{"categories":4767},[536],{"categories":4769},[570],{"categories":4771},[476],{"categories":4773},[525],{"categories":4775},[570],{"categories":4777},[520],{"categories":4779},[530],{"categories":4781},[530],{"categories":4783},[525],{"categories":4785},[476],{"categories":4787},[],{"categories":4789},[],{"categories":4791},[],{"categories":4793},[476],{"categories":4795},[],{"categories":4797},[525],{"categories":4799},[],{"categories":4801},[476],{"categories":4803},[],{"categories":4805},[525],{"categories":4807},[530],{"categories":4809},[476],{"categories":4811},[880],{"categories":4813},[476],{"categories":4815},[570],{"categories":4817},[476],{"categories":4819},[570],{"categories":4821},[570],{"categories":4823},[],{"categories":4825},[],{"categories":4827},[570],{"categories":4829},[570],{"categories":4831},[570],{"categories":4833},[],{"categories":4835},[570],{"categories":4837},[530],{"categories":4839},[530],{"categories":4841},[],{"categories":4843},[476],{"categories":4845},[533],{"categories":4847},[615],{"categories":4849},[476],{"categories":4851},[],{"categories":4853},[570],{"categories":4855},[476],{"categories":4857},[967],{"categories":4859},[570],{"categories":4861},[570],{"categories":4863},[533],{"categories":4865},[539],{"categories":4867},[539],{"categories":4869},[],{"categories":4871},[539],{"categories":4873},[476],{"categories":4875},[],{"categories":4877},[],{"categories":4879},[530],{"categories":4881},[],{"categories":4883},[530],{"categories":4885},[530],{"categories":4887},[525],{"categories":4889},[476],{"categories":4891},[525],{"categories":4893},[570],{"categories":4895},[525],{"categories":4897},[539],{"categories":4899},[539],{"categories":4901},[539],{"categories":4903},[525],{"categories":4905},[476],{"categories":4907},[530],{"categories":4909},[880],{"categories":4911},[520],{"categories":4913},[880],{"categories":4915},[880],{"categories":4917},[539],{"categories":4919},[880],{"categories":4921},[880],[4923,5273,5333,5537],{"id":4924,"title":4925,"ai":4926,"body":4930,"categories":5251,"created_at":477,"date_modified":477,"description":465,"extension":478,"faq":477,"featured":479,"kicker_label":477,"meta":5252,"navigation":499,"path":5264,"published_at":477,"question":477,"scraped_at":5265,"seo":5266,"sitemap":5267,"source_id":504,"source_name":505,"source_type":506,"source_url":507,"stem":5268,"tags":5269,"thumbnail_url":477,"tldr":5270,"tweet":477,"unknown_tags":5271,"__hash__":5272},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Fspdd-governable-llm-coding-for-teams-summary.md","SPDD: Governable LLM Coding for Teams",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":9,"output_tokens":4927,"processing_time_ms":4928,"cost_usd":4929},2592,20305,0.0030097,{"type":14,"value":4931,"toc":5242},[4932,4936,4939,4942,4945,4949,4952,4996,4999,5002,5006,5015,5092,5095,5099,5107,5123,5129,5160,5168,5171,5174,5178,5181,5201,5204,5208,5211,5214,5216],[17,4933,4935],{"id":4934},"scaling-ai-coding-beyond-individuals","Scaling AI Coding Beyond Individuals",[22,4937,4938],{},"Individual developers gain speed from LLM assistants, but teams face amplified issues: ambiguous requirements turn into scaled bugs, reviews drown in diffs, integration fails despite generation, and production risks rise with change volume. Thoughtworks' Global IT teams developed SPDD to make AI-generated changes governable, reviewable, and reusable. Instead of ad-hoc chats, SPDD elevates prompts to first-class artifacts in version control, capturing intent, design, and constraints upfront. This shifts focus from \"generate more code\" to aligning business needs with predictable outputs.",[22,4940,4941],{},"\"It's like buying a Ferrari and driving it on muddy roads: the engine is powerful, but your arrival time is determined by road conditions and traffic.\" This analogy from authors Wei Zhang and Jessie Xia highlights why local productivity doesn't yield system throughput without process fixes.",[22,4943,4944],{},"SPDD creates a closed loop: business input → abstraction → execution → validation → release, with prompts and code evolving together. Divergences trigger prompt-first fixes, turning reviews into intent checks rather than bug hunts. Over time, prompts accumulate domain knowledge into reusable libraries, reducing team variability.",[17,4946,4948],{"id":4947},"reasons-canvas-prompt-structure-for-predictability","REASONS Canvas: Prompt Structure for Predictability",[22,4950,4951],{},"The REASONS Canvas structures prompts into seven parts, forcing clarity before code generation:",[334,4953,4954,4960,4966,4972,4978,4984,4990],{},[318,4955,4956,4959],{},[66,4957,4958],{},"R: Requirements"," – Problem, Definition of Done (DoD).",[318,4961,4962,4965],{},[66,4963,4964],{},"E: Entities"," – Domain model, relationships.",[318,4967,4968,4971],{},[66,4969,4970],{},"A: Approach"," – Solution strategy.",[318,4973,4974,4977],{},[66,4975,4976],{},"S: Structure"," – System fit, components, dependencies.",[318,4979,4980,4983],{},[66,4981,4982],{},"O: Operations"," – Concrete, testable steps.",[318,4985,4986,4989],{},[66,4987,4988],{},"N: Norms"," – Naming, observability, defensive coding.",[318,4991,4992,4995],{},[66,4993,4994],{},"S: Safeguards"," – Invariants, perf limits, security.",[22,4997,4998],{},"Abstract parts (R,E,A,S) define intent and design; O executes; N\u002FS govern. Reviewers validate one artifact, not chats or partial code. This anchors LLM outputs, curbing non-determinism. Compared to spec-driven development, SPDD evolves prompts as living specs alongside code, per Birgitta Böckeler's \"spec-anchored\" category.",[22,5000,5001],{},"\"The canvas aligns intent and boundaries before code is generated, moving uncertainty to the left.\" Prompts compound expertise across iterations, starting new work from governed baselines.",[17,5003,5005],{"id":5004},"spdd-workflow-versioned-prompts-meet-code-discipline","SPDD Workflow: Versioned Prompts Meet Code Discipline",[22,5007,5008,5009,5014],{},"Implemented via openspdd CLI (",[5010,5011,485],"a",{"href":485,"rel":5012},[5013],"nofollow","), the workflow mirrors code practices: commit, review, gates. Key commands:",[39,5016,5017,5025],{},[42,5018,5019],{},[45,5020,5021,5023],{},[48,5022,174],{},[48,5024,177],{},[58,5026,5027,5036,5045,5054,5063,5072,5082],{},[45,5028,5029,5033],{},[63,5030,5031],{},[188,5032,322],{},[63,5034,5035],{},"Splits requirements into INVEST user stories (optional).",[45,5037,5038,5042],{},[63,5039,5040],{},[188,5041,331],{},[63,5043,5044],{},"Scans codebase for domain context, risks, strategy.",[45,5046,5047,5051],{},[63,5048,5049],{},[188,5050,343],{},[63,5052,5053],{},"Builds full REASONS prompt.",[45,5055,5056,5060],{},[63,5057,5058],{},[188,5059,349],{},[63,5061,5062],{},"Produces code per operations\u002Fnorms\u002Fsafeguards.",[45,5064,5065,5069],{},[63,5066,5067],{},[188,5068,355],{},[63,5070,5071],{},"Generates cURL tests (optional).",[45,5073,5074,5079],{},[63,5075,5076],{},[188,5077,5078],{},"\u002Fspdd-prompt-update",[63,5080,5081],{},"Updates prompt on requirement changes.",[45,5083,5084,5089],{},[63,5085,5086],{},[188,5087,5088],{},"\u002Fspdd-sync",[63,5090,5091],{},"Syncs code changes back to prompt.",[22,5093,5094],{},"Rule: Fix prompts first on divergence. This enforces alignment, with prompts as collaboration hubs for devs and product owners.",[17,5096,5098],{"id":5097},"billing-engine-enhancement-end-to-end-spdd-in-action","Billing Engine Enhancement: End-to-End SPDD in Action",[22,5100,5101,5102,5106],{},"Starting from a simple token-usage biller (",[5010,5103,5104],{"href":5104,"rel":5105},"https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002Fgszhangwei\u002Ftoken-billing\u002Ftree\u002Fiteration-1-end",[5013],"), SPDD enhanced it for model-aware, multi-plan pricing:",[334,5108,5109],{},[318,5110,5111,5114,5115,5118,5119,5122],{},[66,5112,5113],{},"Enhancement needs",": Add ",[188,5116,5117],{},"modelId"," to ",[188,5120,5121],{},"\u002Fapi\u002Fusage","; dynamic rates (e.g., fast-model $0.01\u002F1K tokens, reasoning-model $0.03\u002F1K); Standard plan (quota + overage); Premium (no quota, split prompt\u002Fcompletion billing); extensible via Strategy\u002FFactory.",[22,5124,5125,5128],{},[66,5126,5127],{},"Step synthesis",":",[315,5130,5131,5136,5139,5144,5147,5152,5157],{},[318,5132,5133,5135],{},[188,5134,322],{}," on enhancement idea yields two stories (Standard + Premium), consolidated to one with Given\u002FWhen\u002FThen ACs (e.g., Standard: 100K quota, 90K used, 30K fast-model → $0.20 overage; Premium: 10K prompt + 20K completion reasoning-model → $1.50).",[318,5137,5138],{},"Clarify: Core logic (routing by plan), boundaries (no CRUD\u002Fsubscriptions), DoD scenarios.",[318,5140,5141,5143],{},[188,5142,331],{}," scans code, outputs domain concepts (e.g., quota, overage), strategy (Strategy pattern respecting ISP\u002FSRP), risks\u002Fedges (e.g., negative tokens).",[318,5145,5146],{},"Review analysis: Aligns on OOP, surfaces edges; accept as-is.",[318,5148,5149,5151],{},[188,5150,343],{}," generates prompt.",[318,5153,5154,5156],{},[188,5155,349],{}," produces code: API updates, plan strategies, rate lookups.",[318,5158,5159],{},"Generate\u002Freview tests; deploy.",[22,5161,5162,5163,5167],{},"Result: Production-ready feature matching ACs, with prompts\u002Fversioned code for reuse. Example repo shows full artifacts (",[5010,5164,5165],{"href":5165,"rel":5166},"https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002Fgszhangwei\u002Ftoken-billing\u002Fcompare\u002Fiteration-1-start...iteration-1-end",[5013],").",[22,5169,5170],{},"Trade-offs surface: Prompts need tweaks for non-determinism; abstraction-first delays details but uncovers issues early.",[22,5172,5173],{},"\"When reality diverges, fix the prompt first — then update the code.\" This rule prevents drift, ensuring prompts record current reality.",[17,5175,5177],{"id":5176},"three-core-skills-for-spdd-success","Three Core Skills for SPDD Success",[22,5179,5180],{},"Developers need:",[334,5182,5183,5189,5195],{},[318,5184,5185,5188],{},[66,5186,5187],{},"Alignment",": Review analysis\u002Fprompts against business understanding; pair PO\u002Fdev for stories.",[318,5190,5191,5194],{},[66,5192,5193],{},"Abstraction-first",": Define intent\u002Fdesign before ops; simulate via AI to spot issues.",[318,5196,5197,5200],{},[66,5198,5199],{},"Iterative review",": Check prompts pre-code; sync divergences; refine for reuse.",[22,5202,5203],{},"These skills break \"expert-only\" barriers, enabling juniors via governed patterns.",[17,5205,5207],{"id":5206},"fitness-and-trade-offs","Fitness and Trade-offs",[22,5209,5210],{},"SPDD fits enhancements on brownfield codebases with clear domain\u002Fmodels. Assess: High ambiguity? Use it. Simple CRUD? Skip for direct generation. Trade-offs: Upfront prompt time (offset by reuse); LLM variance needs reviews; scales best with shared prompt libraries.",[22,5212,5213],{},"\"By following the same structure, every prompt becomes governable in the same way.\"",[17,5215,434],{"id":433},[334,5217,5218,5221,5224,5227,5230,5233,5236,5239],{},[318,5219,5220],{},"Treat prompts as versioned first-class artifacts to scale AI from solo to team.",[318,5222,5223],{},"Use REASONS Canvas for structured prompts: abstract intent first, then execute with governance.",[318,5225,5226],{},"Implement via CLI like openspdd: analysis → canvas → generate → sync.",[318,5228,5229],{},"Always fix prompts before code on divergence; review intent over diffs.",[318,5231,5232],{},"Build skills in alignment (business sync), abstraction-first (design simulation), iterative review.",[318,5234,5235],{},"Start on enhancements: clarifies domain, accumulates reusable patterns.",[318,5237,5238],{},"Expect non-determinism: tweak prompts, but gains compound over iterations.",[318,5240,5241],{},"Measure success by team throughput, not lines generated: safer reviews, less rework.",{"title":465,"searchDepth":466,"depth":466,"links":5243},[5244,5245,5246,5247,5248,5249,5250],{"id":4934,"depth":466,"text":4935},{"id":4947,"depth":466,"text":4948},{"id":5004,"depth":466,"text":5005},{"id":5097,"depth":466,"text":5098},{"id":5176,"depth":466,"text":5177},{"id":5206,"depth":466,"text":5207},{"id":433,"depth":466,"text":434},[],{"content_references":5253,"triage":5262},[5254,5255,5256,5257],{"type":483,"title":484,"url":485,"context":486},{"type":491,"title":488,"url":489,"context":486},{"type":491,"title":492,"url":493,"context":486},{"type":491,"title":5258,"author":5259,"url":5260,"context":5261},"sdd-3-tools.html","Birgitta Böckeler","https:\u002F\u002Fmartinfowler.com\u002Farticles\u002Fexploring-gen-ai\u002Fsdd-3-tools.html","cited",{"relevance":495,"novelty":496,"quality":496,"actionability":496,"composite":497,"reasoning":5263},"Category: AI & LLMs. The article introduces the Structured Prompt-Driven Development (SPDD) framework, which directly addresses the pain points of teams using LLMs by providing a structured approach to prompt engineering. It offers actionable insights on how to implement the REASONS Canvas for better governance and predictability in AI coding, making it highly relevant and practical for the target audience.","\u002Fsummaries\u002Fspdd-governable-llm-coding-for-teams-summary","2026-05-03 17:02:03",{"title":4925,"description":465},{"loc":5264},"summaries\u002Fspdd-governable-llm-coding-for-teams-summary",[511,510,512,513],"Thoughtworks' Structured Prompt-Driven Development (SPDD) treats prompts as versioned artifacts via REASONS Canvas and CLI workflow, scaling AI assistants from solo speedups to team-safe, reusable code generation.",[512,513],"pOL5w0bSLEbV0_Lit3E8AN02nSU0gSiV0-Ug9RC8svU",{"id":5274,"title":5275,"ai":5276,"body":5281,"categories":5309,"created_at":477,"date_modified":477,"description":465,"extension":478,"faq":477,"featured":479,"kicker_label":477,"meta":5310,"navigation":499,"path":5320,"published_at":5321,"question":477,"scraped_at":5322,"seo":5323,"sitemap":5324,"source_id":5325,"source_name":5326,"source_type":506,"source_url":5327,"stem":5328,"tags":5329,"thumbnail_url":477,"tldr":5330,"tweet":477,"unknown_tags":5331,"__hash__":5332},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Fgoogle-s-auto-diagnose-llm-diagnoses-test-failures-summary.md","Google's Auto-Diagnose: LLM Diagnoses Test Failures at 90% Accuracy",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":5277,"output_tokens":5278,"processing_time_ms":5279,"cost_usd":5280},7775,1678,12431,0.00237135,{"type":14,"value":5282,"toc":5304},[5283,5287,5290,5294,5297,5301],[17,5284,5286],{"id":5285},"slash-integration-test-debug-time-with-llm-log-analysis","Slash Integration Test Debug Time with LLM Log Analysis",[22,5288,5289],{},"Integration tests at Google, which are 78% functional per a 239-developer survey, often fail with generic symptoms like timeouts while root causes hide in SUT component logs amid noise. Developers report 38.4% of failures take over an hour to diagnose (vs. 2.7% for unit tests), and 8.9% exceed a day—top complaint in a 6,059-developer EngSat survey. Auto-Diagnose triggers on failure via pub\u002Fsub, aggregates INFO+ logs across data centers\u002Fprocesses\u002Fthreads, joins and sorts them by timestamp into one stream, adds component metadata, and feeds to Gemini 2.5 Flash (temperature=0.1, topp=0.8). This yields p50 latency of 56s and p90 of 346s, with 110k input\u002F6k output tokens per run, letting devs act before context-switching.",[17,5291,5293],{"id":5292},"step-by-step-prompting-ensures-reliable-root-causes","Step-by-Step Prompting Ensures Reliable Root Causes",[22,5295,5296],{},"No fine-tuning needed—pure prompt engineering guides the LLM: scan sections, read context, locate failure, summarize errors, conclude only with evidence, and apply hard negatives like 'no conclusion if missing component logs.' Output post-processes to markdown with ==Conclusion== (root cause), ==Investigation Steps==, and ==Most Relevant Log Lines== (clickable links), auto-posted to Critique code reviews. Manual eval on 71 failures from 39 teams hit 90.14% root cause accuracy; failures exposed infra bugs like unsaved crash logs, fixed via feedback loop.",[17,5298,5300],{"id":5299},"production-feedback-ranks-it-top-38-of-tools","Production Feedback Ranks It Top 3.8% of Tools",[22,5302,5303],{},"Deployed on 52,635 failing tests across 224,782 executions and 91,130 changes by 22,962 devs. Of 517 feedbacks from 437 devs, 84.3% were reviewer 'Please fix' requests; dev helpfulness 63%, 'Not helpful' just 5.8% (under 10% live threshold), #14 of 370 Critique tools (top 3.78%). Replicate by building similar pipelines: aggregate\u002Fsort logs, chain-of-thought prompt general LLMs, integrate with review tools for instant value.",{"title":465,"searchDepth":466,"depth":466,"links":5305},[5306,5307,5308],{"id":5285,"depth":466,"text":5286},{"id":5292,"depth":466,"text":5293},{"id":5299,"depth":466,"text":5300},[476],{"content_references":5311,"triage":5317},[5312],{"type":5313,"title":5314,"url":5315,"context":5316},"paper","Auto-Diagnose Pre-Print","https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fpdf\u002F2604.12108","recommended",{"relevance":495,"novelty":496,"quality":496,"actionability":495,"composite":5318,"reasoning":5319},4.55,"Category: AI & LLMs. The article provides a detailed overview of Google's Auto-Diagnose system, which uses LLMs to improve integration test debugging, directly addressing the pain point of long diagnosis times for developers. It includes specific steps for replicating the system, making it highly actionable for the target audience.","\u002Fsummaries\u002Fgoogle-s-auto-diagnose-llm-diagnoses-test-failures-summary","2026-04-18 06:00:41","2026-04-19 01:22:38",{"title":5275,"description":465},{"loc":5320},"941741f2e1ae4f3e","MarkTechPost","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.marktechpost.com\u002F2026\u002F04\u002F17\u002Fgoogle-ai-releases-auto-diagnose-an-large-language-model-llm-based-system-to-diagnose-integration-test-failures-at-scale\u002F","summaries\u002Fgoogle-s-auto-diagnose-llm-diagnoses-test-failures-summary",[510,511,513],"Prompt-engineer Gemini 2.5 Flash on timestamp-sorted logs to auto-diagnose integration test root causes, posting fixes to code reviews—90.14% accurate on 71 real failures, 5.8% 'Not helpful' in production across 52k+ tests.",[513],"1IfOl8VTBB8X4eq_ZhCLlb3u4kwfmQvPqrxf6XPPpbg",{"id":5334,"title":5335,"ai":5336,"body":5341,"categories":5520,"created_at":477,"date_modified":477,"description":5521,"extension":478,"faq":477,"featured":479,"kicker_label":477,"meta":5522,"navigation":499,"path":5523,"published_at":5524,"question":477,"scraped_at":5525,"seo":5526,"sitemap":5527,"source_id":5528,"source_name":5529,"source_type":5530,"source_url":5531,"stem":5532,"tags":5533,"thumbnail_url":477,"tldr":5534,"tweet":477,"unknown_tags":5535,"__hash__":5536},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Fslash-llm-token-costs-10x-by-fixing-6-bad-habits-summary.md","Slash LLM Token Costs 10x by Fixing 6 Bad Habits",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":5337,"output_tokens":5338,"processing_time_ms":5339,"cost_usd":5340},8213,2447,18362,0.00257525,{"type":14,"value":5342,"toc":5511},[5343,5347,5350,5356,5362,5366,5369,5374,5377,5382,5386,5389,5394,5397,5401,5404,5410,5413,5418,5422,5425,5431,5434,5439,5443,5446,5466,5469,5472,5477,5479],[17,5344,5346],{"id":5345},"file-formats-are-your-biggest-beginner-token-trap","File Formats Are Your Biggest Beginner Token Trap",[22,5348,5349],{},"Raw PDFs, images, and screenshots explode token counts because LLMs encode binary structure, headers, footers, fonts, and layout metadata. A newbie drags in three 1,500-word PDFs (4,500 words total) and asks Claude to \"Summarize these.\" What should be ~5,000 tokens balloons to 100,000+ due to formatting overhead. This waste compounds as the bloated context bounces back in every turn, filling your window fast.",[22,5351,5352,5355],{},[66,5353,5354],{},"Fix:"," Convert to markdown first. Free web tools or a quick Claude prompt strips junk, yielding 4-6,000 clean tokens—a 20x saving. The speaker built a plugin for Open Brain ecosystem: ingest file, hit \"transform,\" get markdown. For 99% of cases, you only need text, not style. Trade-off: Lose visual fidelity, but gain speed and cost control. He calls file formats \"designed to be human readable, not AI readable.\"",[5357,5358,5359],"blockquote",{},[22,5360,5361],{},"\"4500 words of content can become a 100 plus thousand tokens if you're not careful all you have to do to avoid that is just think in terms of markdown... saving you 20x on the memory.\"\n(Context: Explaining PDF bloat; this quote shows why rookies hit limits in one chat.)",[17,5363,5365],{"id":5364},"conversation-sprawl-wastes-more-than-you-think","Conversation Sprawl Wastes More Than You Think",[22,5367,5368],{},"Intermediate users sprawl chats to 20-40 turns, diluting original instructions amid noise. Models compress history but still resend the full context each turn—every reply costs the entire prior exchange. Mixing research, ideation, and execution in one thread confuses the model and burns tokens.",[22,5370,5371,5373],{},[66,5372,5354],{}," Separate modes. Use short, focused chats (10-15 turns max) for heavy work: gather intel in dedicated threads (Grok for X sentiment, ChatGPT for earnings, Perplexity for research, Claude for blogs), then synthesize in a final crisp prompt. Mark evolving chats upfront: \"Our goal is to evolve and conclude together.\" End with \"Summarize this.\" Start fresh often—long threads correlate with \"LLM psychosis\" as models drift.",[22,5375,5376],{},"Trade-off: More chats mean manual synthesis, but you avoid context dilution and get clearer outputs. Every turn resends history, so sprawling is like \"filling up the context window with croft.\"",[5357,5378,5379],{},[22,5380,5381],{},"\"Why make them suffer... why not just ask for what you want upfront... your objective... should be to be so clear that the AI needs to do nothing else and it just goes and gets the work done.\"\n(Context: Critiquing multi-mode sprawl; highlights single-turn design of LLMs.)",[17,5383,5385],{"id":5384},"plugins-and-preloads-the-silent-context-tax","Plugins and Preloads: The Silent Context Tax",[22,5387,5388],{},"Loading 10+ plugins (e.g., Google Drive you never use) adds 50,000+ tokens before you type—every chat. It's like dumping every workshop tool on the bench before picking a hammer. Hype drives additions, but they barnacle on forever.",[22,5390,5391,5393],{},[66,5392,5354],{}," Audit ruthlessly. Use \u002Fcontext in Claude Code to check loads; disable unused connectors. Only equip 3-5 per task. For advanced setups, prune system prompts weekly—ditch lines from Claude 3.5 era.",[22,5395,5396],{},"Trade-off: Lose convenience for rarely used tools, but gain focus. Models pick wrong tools amid clutter.",[17,5398,5400],{"id":5399},"model-tiering-delivers-8-10x-savings-without-losing-quality","Model Tiering Delivers 8-10x Savings Without Losing Quality",[22,5402,5403],{},"Using Opus (or GPT-4o) for everything—formatting, proofreading, execution—is overkill. A production pipeline the speaker reviewed analyzes long conversations across dozens of dimensions on frontier models, yet costs \u003C25¢\u002Fuser because they tier: Opus for reasoning, Sonnet for execution, Haiku for polish.",[22,5405,5406,5409],{},[66,5407,5408],{},"Example math (5-hour session, same output):"," Sloppy (raw PDFs, 30-turn sprawl, all-Opus): 800k-1M input tokens + 150-200k output = $8-10 ($5\u002FM input, $25\u002FM output). Clean (markdown, fresh chats every 10-15 turns, tiered models, scoped context): 100-150k input + 50-80k output = ~$1. Scale to 10-person team API: $2,000 vs. $250\u002Fmonth.",[22,5411,5412],{},"Trade-off: Test cheaper models per task; Haiku shines on polish but flops on complex reasoning. As models improve, lean out context—trust retrieval over frontloading.",[5357,5414,5415],{},[22,5416,5417],{},"\"Don't bring a Ferrari to the grocery store.\"\n(Context: Model tiering; punchy metaphor for using Opus everywhere.)",[17,5419,5421],{"id":5420},"production-levers-caching-search-and-auditing","Production Levers: Caching, Search, and Auditing",[22,5423,5424],{},"Advanced users screw up at scale (millions of tokens). Ignore prompt caching? Miss 90% discounts (Opus: $0.50\u002FM cached vs. $5\u002FM). System prompts bloat from unpruned cruft. Web search via native Claude burns 10-50k tokens\u002Fquery vs. Perplexity (5x faster, structured citations).",[22,5426,5427,5430],{},[66,5428,5429],{},"Fixes:"," Cache stable context (prompts, tools, docs). Use MCP connectors for cheap search (e.g., Perplexity service). For agents\u002Frepos, test context needs per model gen—dumber models needed fat windows; now trim.",[22,5432,5433],{},"Jen-Hsun Huang pegs engineer token spend at $250k\u002Fyear—don't be that person. With Mythos\u002FGPT-next\u002FGemini (GB300-trained, 10x Opus pricing rumored: $50\u002FM in, $250\u002FM out), sloppy habits scale painfully.",[5357,5435,5436],{},[22,5437,5438],{},"\"The models are not expensive it's your habits that cost a lot... your mistakes scale with the price of intelligence.\"\n(Context: Thesis opener and closer; frames costs as behavioral, not inherent.)",[17,5440,5442],{"id":5441},"tools-to-diagnose-and-fix-your-usage","Tools to Diagnose and Fix Your Usage",[22,5444,5445],{},"Speaker built a \"stupid button\" (Open Brain plugin\u002Fskill\u002Fguardrails):",[315,5447,5448,5454,5460],{},[318,5449,5450,5453],{},[66,5451,5452],{},"Audit prompt:"," Paste recent chat; flags raw docs, sprawl, model misuse, redundant loads—prioritizes fixes.",[318,5455,5456,5459],{},[66,5457,5458],{},"Gas tank skill:"," Measures per-session overhead (system prompts, plugins); before\u002Fafter baselines.",[318,5461,5462,5465],{},[66,5463,5464],{},"Guardrails:"," Blocks token-waste on knowledge stores.",[22,5467,5468],{},"Run it: Answers 6 questions (raw files? Fresh chats? All-Opus? Preloads? Caching? Cheap search?). No setup for prompt version.",[22,5470,5471],{},"Real pipeline proves frontier AI viability: Dozens of analysis dimensions on long convos, personalized output, \u003C25¢\u002Fuser.",[5357,5473,5474],{},[22,5475,5476],{},"\"Frontier AI can be absurdly cheap when you know what you're doing... most of us are spending more than we need to on AI.\"\n(Context: Production example; counters \"AI is too expensive\" narrative.)",[17,5478,434],{"id":433},[334,5480,5481,5484,5487,5490,5493,5496,5499,5502,5505,5508],{},[318,5482,5483],{},"Convert all inputs to markdown: 20x token savings on docs\u002Fimages; use free tools or Claude.",[318,5485,5486],{},"Cap chats at 10-15 turns; separate research from execution for clarity and cost.",[318,5488,5489],{},"Audit plugins\u002Fpreloads weekly: Disable barnacles adding 50k+ tokens\u002Fchat.",[318,5491,5492],{},"Tier models: Opus reasoning, Sonnet execution, Haiku polish—8-10x cheaper same output.",[318,5494,5495],{},"Cache stable context: 90% off repeated inputs; essential for agents\u002Fproduction.",[318,5497,5498],{},"Use cheap search (Perplexity\u002FMCP): 10-50k fewer tokens\u002Fquery, faster results.",[318,5500,5501],{},"Prune system prompts biweekly; trim context as models smarten.",[318,5503,5504],{},"Baseline usage with audits: Turn $10\u002Fday slop into $1\u002Fday efficiency.",[318,5506,5507],{},"Prep for 10x pricier models: Habits today dictate ROI tomorrow.",[318,5509,5510],{},"Build token smarts: $250k\u002Fyear engineer spend is avoidable skill gap.",{"title":465,"searchDepth":466,"depth":466,"links":5512},[5513,5514,5515,5516,5517,5518,5519],{"id":5345,"depth":466,"text":5346},{"id":5364,"depth":466,"text":5365},{"id":5384,"depth":466,"text":5385},{"id":5399,"depth":466,"text":5400},{"id":5420,"depth":466,"text":5421},{"id":5441,"depth":466,"text":5442},{"id":433,"depth":466,"text":434},[476],"My site: https:\u002F\u002Fnatebjones.com\nFull Story w\u002F Prompts: https:\u002F\u002Fnatesnewsletter.substack.com\u002Fp\u002Fyour-claude-sessions-cost-10x-what?r=1z4sm5&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true\n___________________\nWhat's really happening inside your AI costs when Jensen Hwang says engineers will spend $250,000 a year on tokens?\n\nThe common story is that frontier models are expensive — but the reality is that your habits cost more than the models ever will, and most users burn 8-10x what they need to.\n\nIn this video, I share the inside scoop on token efficiency before Mythos pricing hits:\n\n • Why raw PDFs can turn 4,500 words into 100,000 tokens\n • How conversation sprawl compounds waste with every turn\n • What plugin overhead costs you before you type a word\n • Where model mixing drops a $10 session to $1\n\nBuilders who keep burning tokens as a badge of honor will face a reckoning when cutting-edge models cost 10x what Opus costs today — the habits you build now determine whether you scale or stall.\n\nChapters\n00:00 Stop burning tokens and blaming the model\n02:30 A real pipeline that costs less than 25 cents per user\n04:30 Rookie mistake: document ingestion and PDFs\n07:00 Convert to Markdown, always\n09:00 Conversation sprawl and context compression\n11:30 The plugin and connector tax\n14:00 Advanced users have the most expensive mistakes\n16:30 The 8-10x cost reduction breakdown\n19:00 What Mythos pricing will do to your mistakes\n21:00 The stupid button: six questions to audit yourself\n23:30 Five commandments for agent token management\n26:00 Use your tokens well, not wastefully\n\nSubscribe for daily AI strategy and news.\nFor deeper playbooks and analysis: https:\u002F\u002Fnatesnewsletter.substack.com\u002F\n\nListen to this video as a podcast.\n- Spotify: https:\u002F\u002Fopen.spotify.com\u002Fshow\u002F0gkFdjd1wptEKJKLu9LbZ4\n- Apple Podcasts: https:\u002F\u002Fpodcasts.apple.com\u002Fus\u002Fpodcast\u002Fai-news-strategy-daily-with-nate-b-jones\u002Fid1877109372",{},"\u002Fsummaries\u002Fslash-llm-token-costs-10x-by-fixing-6-bad-habits-summary","2026-04-02 14:00:06","2026-04-03 21:11:38",{"title":5335,"description":5521},{"loc":5523},"f932400d9db7252e","AI News & Strategy Daily | Nate B Jones","video","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.youtube.com\u002Fwatch?v=5ztI_dbj6ek","summaries\u002Fslash-llm-token-costs-10x-by-fixing-6-bad-habits-summary",[510,511,513],"Upcoming frontier models like Claude Mythos will cost 10x more—fix habits like raw PDFs, conversation sprawl, and overusing Opus to drop daily costs from $10 to $1 while getting the same output.",[513],"dSzXEEh_GAFVQRPibDgpRAY3aguCpeO8P2aHloulWGU",{"id":5538,"title":5539,"ai":5540,"body":5545,"categories":5671,"created_at":477,"date_modified":477,"description":465,"extension":478,"faq":477,"featured":479,"kicker_label":477,"meta":5672,"navigation":499,"path":5686,"published_at":5687,"question":477,"scraped_at":5687,"seo":5688,"sitemap":5689,"source_id":5690,"source_name":5691,"source_type":506,"source_url":5315,"stem":5692,"tags":5693,"thumbnail_url":477,"tldr":5694,"tweet":477,"unknown_tags":5695,"__hash__":5696},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Fgoogle-s-auto-diagnose-90-accurate-llm-test-failur-summary.md","Google's Auto-Diagnose: 90% Accurate LLM Test Failure Diagnosis",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":5541,"output_tokens":5542,"processing_time_ms":5543,"cost_usd":5544},8531,2677,19109,0.00275385,{"type":14,"value":5546,"toc":5664},[5547,5551,5554,5557,5565,5569,5572,5598,5601,5604,5608,5611,5614,5617,5620,5624,5627,5630,5633,5635],[17,5548,5550],{"id":5549},"integration-test-failures-overwhelm-developers-with-log-chaos","Integration Test Failures Overwhelm Developers with Log Chaos",[22,5552,5553],{},"Diagnosing integration test failures at Google is notoriously painful due to massive, unstructured logs from test drivers and distributed SUT components. A company-wide EngSat survey of 6,059 developers ranked it among the top five complaints. A follow-up Survey-2 with 116 developers confirmed integration failures occur less frequently than unit tests (monthly vs. daily\u002Fweekly) but take far longer to diagnose—often over an hour or a full day (Figure 1b). Median failing tests produce 16 log files and 2,801 lines, with means of 26 files and 11,058 lines in production. Developers start with high-level test driver logs showing generic errors like timeouts, then manually hunt across heterogeneous SUT logs (dynamically named by component, split by levels like .info\u002F.error). Low signal-to-noise buries root causes amid irrelevant warnings, creating high cognitive load. Common workarounds: ping experienced colleagues or infra teams, which doesn't scale.",[22,5555,5556],{},"Why integration over unit tests? Unit tests run early\u002Foften in isolation; integration tests hit later, testing multi-component interactions in hermetic environments (no external deps). A survey of 239 teams showed functional hermetic tests as most common (Figure 2). Failures surface as Critique findings during code review, blocking submission until fixed (Figure 3). Traditional automated diagnosis tools (statistical debugging, spectrum analysis) target unit-level; integration's distributed logs and setups remain unsolved.",[22,5558,5559,5560,5564],{},"\"Diagnosing integration test failures was identified as one of the top five most frequent complaints in a company-wide survey ",[5561,5562,5563],"span",{},"5"," of 6,059 developers.\" (From Section 2.1: Quantifies the scale of developer frustration, justifying LLM focus.)",[17,5566,5568],{"id":5567},"auto-diagnose-leverages-llm-strengths-for-log-synthesis","Auto-Diagnose Leverages LLM Strengths for Log Synthesis",[22,5570,5571],{},"Auto-Diagnose automates diagnosis by feeding all INFO+ logs (test driver + SUT components) into Gemini 2.5 Flash. On failure notification via pub\u002Fsub, logs from data centers\u002Fprocesses\u002Fthreads are timestamp-sorted into one stream (e.g., Listing 1: server-a.info\u002Ferror lines). A meticulously engineered prompt (Figure 7) guides step-by-step reasoning: scan log sections, correlate events, identify root cause, extract top relevant lines, conclude precisely. Key decisions:",[334,5573,5574,5580,5586,5592],{},[318,5575,5576,5579],{},[66,5577,5578],{},"LLM Choice",": Gemini 2.5 Flash for speed\u002Fcost (mean 110k input\u002F6k output tokens per run). Params: temperature=0.1 (deterministic), top_p=0.8 (balanced creativity). No fine-tuning on Google's logs.",[318,5581,5582,5585],{},[66,5583,5584],{},"Prompt Iteration",": Refined via real failures to enforce chain-of-thought, negative constraints (no speculation), strict markdown output with linked log lines.",[318,5587,5588,5591],{},[66,5589,5590],{},"Post-Processing",": Formats as Critique finding (Figure 6) with clickable log links, conclusion, relevant lines.",[318,5593,5594,5597],{},[66,5595,5596],{},"Integration",": Posts to Critique in p50=56s, p90=346s—faster than manual debugging.",[22,5599,5600],{},"Tradeoffs: Relies on complete logs; misses if infra bugs drop them (addressed post-eval). Handles heterogeneity without custom parsing. Vs. alternatives: LLMs excel at summarization where rules-based tools fail on variety.",[22,5602,5603],{},"\"LLMs are highly successful in diagnosing integration test failures due to their capacity to process and summarize complex textual data.\" (Abstract conclusion: Core insight on why LLMs fit this unstructured domain over prior methods.)",[17,5605,5607],{"id":5606},"rigorous-evaluation-proves-high-accuracy-and-adoption","Rigorous Evaluation Proves High Accuracy and Adoption",[22,5609,5610],{},"Manual case study: Ran on 71 failures from 39 teams (Table 1). 3 expert infra devs (5+ years exp) assessed if conclusion\u002Frelevant logs hit root cause; aligned via meeting. Result: 64\u002F71 accurate (90.14%). 7 misses traced to infra bugs—4 test driver logs unsaved on crash, 3 SUT logs—fixed and reported.",[22,5612,5613],{},"Production launch (May 2025): Analyzed 224,782 executions of 52,635 distinct tests across 91,130 code changes by 22,962 authors (Table 2). Feedback buttons: \"Not helpful\" in 5.8% (94.2% neutral\u002Fpositive). Ranked #14\u002F370 Critique tools (top 3.78%) by helpfulness. Interviews praised workflow integration.",[22,5615,5616],{},"Decision chain: Surveys → hermetic functional focus → LLM prompt over rules → Critique embedding. Pivot: Discovered\u002Ffixed log bugs via eval. Non-obvious: 90% accuracy without domain fine-tuning; speed beats human ramp-up.",[22,5618,5619],{},"\"Developers consistently report spending substantially more time diagnosing integration test failures, often more than an hour and sometimes exceeding a day, compared to unit test failures.\" (Section 1: Highlights time savings potential, as Auto-Diagnose posts in \u003C1min.)",[17,5621,5623],{"id":5622},"lessons-on-llm-reliability-and-infra-dependencies","Lessons on LLM Reliability and Infra Dependencies",[22,5625,5626],{},"Failures revealed infra fragility: Crashes dropped logs in 7\u002F71 cases, but this surfaced bugs proactively. Production scale validated robustness on real volume\u002Fvariety. User perception ties to accuracy—high marks despite no hype. Tradeoff: LLM creativity (top_p=0.8) risks hallucination, mitigated by low temp\u002Fstrict prompt.",[22,5628,5629],{},"To replicate: Prioritize hermetic tests; timestamp-join logs; iterate prompts on failures; integrate into review flows. Surprising: LLMs handle distributed log correlation better than expected, contradicting unit-test-only benchmarks.",[22,5631,5632],{},"\"The sheer volume of logs... presents a significant challenge. Developers must manually sift through a multitude of log files, each with its own formatting.\" (Section 2.4: Pinpoints why LLMs win—zero-shot text processing scales where humans don't.)",[17,5634,434],{"id":433},[334,5636,5637,5640,5643,5646,5649,5652,5655,5658,5661],{},[318,5638,5639],{},"Target integration tests: Focus on functional hermetic ones for reproducibility; they're pain points despite lower frequency.",[318,5641,5642],{},"Use off-the-shelf LLMs like Gemini Flash: No fine-tuning needed for log summarization; tune params for determinism (temp=0.1, top_p=0.8).",[318,5644,5645],{},"Engineer prompts rigorously: Step-by-step reasoning + negatives + format constraints; iterate on real failures.",[318,5647,5648],{},"Timestamp-join all logs: Merge multi-source INFO+ into one stream for context.",[318,5650,5651],{},"Integrate into workflows: Post findings to code review (e.g., Critique) in \u003C1min to cut context-switching.",[318,5653,5654],{},"Evaluate with experts: Use 3+ seniors for ground truth; expect 90%+ accuracy if logs complete.",[318,5656,5657],{},"Monitor for infra gaps: Misses often reveal logging bugs—fix them.",[318,5659,5660],{},"Gather production feedback: Buttons + rankings guide iteration; aim for top 5% tool adoption.",[318,5662,5663],{},"Tradeoff honesty: LLMs shine on text but fail sans logs; pair with basics like log saving.",{"title":465,"searchDepth":466,"depth":466,"links":5665},[5666,5667,5668,5669,5670],{"id":5549,"depth":466,"text":5550},{"id":5567,"depth":466,"text":5568},{"id":5606,"depth":466,"text":5607},{"id":5622,"depth":466,"text":5623},{"id":433,"depth":466,"text":434},[],{"content_references":5673,"triage":5684},[5674,5676,5679,5681],{"type":483,"title":5675,"context":486},"Critique",{"type":483,"title":5677,"author":5678,"context":5261},"Gemini 2.5 Flash","Google",{"type":491,"title":5680,"context":5261},"EngSat Survey",{"type":5682,"title":5683,"context":486},"report","Survey-2",{"relevance":495,"novelty":496,"quality":496,"actionability":496,"composite":497,"reasoning":5685},"Category: AI & LLMs. The article discusses a practical application of LLMs in diagnosing integration test failures, addressing a significant pain point for developers. It provides insights into how Auto-Diagnose improves developer productivity by automating log analysis, which is actionable for those looking to implement similar solutions.","\u002Fsummaries\u002Fgoogle-s-auto-diagnose-90-accurate-llm-test-failur-summary","2026-04-19 14:52:49",{"title":5539,"description":465},{"loc":5686},"cda353c403863c01","__oneoff__","summaries\u002Fgoogle-s-auto-diagnose-90-accurate-llm-test-failur-summary",[510,511,513],"Auto-Diagnose uses Gemini to summarize integration test logs in Critique, achieving 90.14% root cause accuracy on 71 failures and helping on 52k+ production tests with 94.2% positive feedback.",[513],"sSt5A3rQ1CyGS4G_XthnDip0J4bsrhHM7WvAASJKDL0"]