[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"summary-pydantic-schemas-fix-llm-output-fragility-summary":3,"summaries-facets-categories":287,"summary-related-pydantic-schemas-fix-llm-output-fragility-summary":4692},{"id":4,"title":5,"ai":6,"body":13,"categories":252,"created_at":254,"date_modified":254,"description":46,"extension":255,"faq":254,"featured":256,"kicker_label":254,"meta":257,"navigation":68,"path":270,"published_at":271,"question":254,"scraped_at":272,"seo":273,"sitemap":274,"source_id":275,"source_name":276,"source_type":277,"source_url":278,"stem":279,"tags":280,"thumbnail_url":254,"tldr":284,"tweet":254,"unknown_tags":285,"__hash__":286},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Fpydantic-schemas-fix-llm-output-fragility-summary.md","Pydantic Schemas Fix LLM Output Fragility",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":9,"output_tokens":10,"processing_time_ms":11,"cost_usd":12},"openrouter","x-ai\u002Fgrok-4.1-fast",8104,2015,14439,0.00212145,{"type":14,"value":15,"toc":246},"minimark",[16,21,25,33,37,40,129,144,147,192,195,199,214,232,235,239,242],[17,18,20],"h2",{"id":19},"overcome-parser-debt-with-4-levels-of-structured-guarantees","Overcome Parser Debt with 4 Levels of Structured Guarantees",[22,23,24],"p",{},"LLM outputs start as unreliable strings—markdown-wrapped JSON, wrong keys like 'movie_title' instead of 'title', strings for integers (e.g., \"2014\"), or prefixed prose—crashing json.loads() or silently corrupting database inserts expecting VARCHAR title, INTEGER year, VARCHAR genre. Naive fixes add 30+ lines of if-statements for stripping, normalizing, and casting, but fail on new edge cases like XML tags or model updates.",[22,26,27,28,32],{},"Advance through levels: (1) Prompt-based hoping yields no guarantees; (2) JSON mode ensures parsable JSON but wrong shapes; (3) JSON Schema mode mandates exact keys, types (string, integer), enums (e.g., ",[29,30,31],"span",{},"\"action\", \"comedy\", \"sci-fi\", \"drama\"","), and no extra properties; (4) strict=True schema enforces during decoding, preventing invalid outputs like string years. For a movie schema {\"title\": string, \"year\": integer (ge=1888, le=2030), \"genre\": enum}, strict mode blocks generation of non-integers, restoring contract between probabilistic LLMs and deterministic apps.",[17,34,36],{"id":35},"pydantic-single-class-for-schema-validation-and-guidance","Pydantic: Single Class for Schema, Validation, and Guidance",[22,38,39],{},"Define structures once in Python classes to auto-generate JSON Schema, validate\u002Fcoerce at boundaries, and guide LLMs via Field descriptions:",[41,42,47],"pre",{"className":43,"code":44,"language":45,"meta":46,"style":46},"language-python shiki shiki-themes github-light github-dark","from pydantic import BaseModel, Field\nfrom enum import Enum\n\nclass Genre(str, Enum):\n    ACTION = \"action\"\n    COMEDY = \"comedy\"\n    SCI_FI = \"sci-fi\"\n    DRAMA = \"drama\"\n\nclass MovieRecommendation(BaseModel):\n    title: str = Field(description=\"Full movie title, without year or parentheses\")\n    year: int = Field(ge=1888, le=2030, description=\"Release year as a 4-digit number\")\n    genre: Genre = Field(description=\"Primary genre - pick exactly one\")\n","python","",[48,49,50,57,63,70,76,82,88,94,100,105,111,117,123],"code",{"__ignoreMap":46},[29,51,54],{"class":52,"line":53},"line",1,[29,55,56],{},"from pydantic import BaseModel, Field\n",[29,58,60],{"class":52,"line":59},2,[29,61,62],{},"from enum import Enum\n",[29,64,66],{"class":52,"line":65},3,[29,67,69],{"emptyLinePlaceholder":68},true,"\n",[29,71,73],{"class":52,"line":72},4,[29,74,75],{},"class Genre(str, Enum):\n",[29,77,79],{"class":52,"line":78},5,[29,80,81],{},"    ACTION = \"action\"\n",[29,83,85],{"class":52,"line":84},6,[29,86,87],{},"    COMEDY = \"comedy\"\n",[29,89,91],{"class":52,"line":90},7,[29,92,93],{},"    SCI_FI = \"sci-fi\"\n",[29,95,97],{"class":52,"line":96},8,[29,98,99],{},"    DRAMA = \"drama\"\n",[29,101,103],{"class":52,"line":102},9,[29,104,69],{"emptyLinePlaceholder":68},[29,106,108],{"class":52,"line":107},10,[29,109,110],{},"class MovieRecommendation(BaseModel):\n",[29,112,114],{"class":52,"line":113},11,[29,115,116],{},"    title: str = Field(description=\"Full movie title, without year or parentheses\")\n",[29,118,120],{"class":52,"line":119},12,[29,121,122],{},"    year: int = Field(ge=1888, le=2030, description=\"Release year as a 4-digit number\")\n",[29,124,126],{"class":52,"line":125},13,[29,127,128],{},"    genre: Genre = Field(description=\"Primary genre - pick exactly one\")\n",[22,130,131,132,135,136,139,140,143],{},"Benefits: ",[48,133,134],{},"model_json_schema()"," outputs full schema with refs, bounds, enums—no manual maintenance. ",[48,137,138],{},"model_validate_json('{\"year\": \"2010\"}')"," coerces string to int (prints 2010 as \u003Cclass 'int'>), rejects invalid genre=\"banana\" or year=99999 with ValidationError before downstream code. ",[48,141,142],{},"model_dump_json()"," enables clean serialization. Descriptions like \"pick exactly one\" improve output quality over bare fields.",[22,145,146],{},"For support tickets:",[41,148,150],{"className":43,"code":149,"language":45,"meta":46,"style":46},"class Priority(str, Enum): LOW=\"low\"; MEDIUM=\"medium\"; HIGH=\"high\"; URGENT=\"urgent\"\nclass SupportTicket(BaseModel):\n    subject: str\n    priority: Priority\n    product: str\n    is_billing_issue: bool\n    customer_sentiment: float = Field(ge=-1.0, le=1.0)\n    action_items: list[str]\n",[48,151,152,157,162,167,172,177,182,187],{"__ignoreMap":46},[29,153,154],{"class":52,"line":53},[29,155,156],{},"class Priority(str, Enum): LOW=\"low\"; MEDIUM=\"medium\"; HIGH=\"high\"; URGENT=\"urgent\"\n",[29,158,159],{"class":52,"line":59},[29,160,161],{},"class SupportTicket(BaseModel):\n",[29,163,164],{"class":52,"line":65},[29,165,166],{},"    subject: str\n",[29,168,169],{"class":52,"line":72},[29,170,171],{},"    priority: Priority\n",[29,173,174],{"class":52,"line":78},[29,175,176],{},"    product: str\n",[29,178,179],{"class":52,"line":84},[29,180,181],{},"    is_billing_issue: bool\n",[29,183,184],{"class":52,"line":90},[29,185,186],{},"    customer_sentiment: float = Field(ge=-1.0, le=1.0)\n",[29,188,189],{"class":52,"line":96},[29,190,191],{},"    action_items: list[str]\n",[22,193,194],{},"Extracts email into validated object for direct DB\u002FAPI use, inferring priority\u002Fsentiment without parsing logic.",[17,196,198],{"id":197},"integrate-natively-or-via-langchain-for-typed-objects","Integrate Natively or via LangChain for Typed Objects",[22,200,201,205,206,209,210,213],{},[202,203,204],"strong",{},"OpenAI SDK (single-provider):"," Pass Pydantic directly—",[48,207,208],{},"client.beta.chat.completions.parse(..., response_format=MovieRecommendation)"," returns ",[48,211,212],{},".parsed"," as validated object, skipping json.loads() entirely.",[22,215,216,219,220,223,224,227,228,231],{},[202,217,218],{},"LangChain (chains\u002Fagents):"," ",[48,221,222],{},"ChatOpenAI().with_structured_output(MovieRecommendation).invoke(prompt)"," yields typed instance. Use ",[48,225,226],{},"include_raw=True"," for observability, ",[48,229,230],{},"method=\"json_schema\", strict=True"," (5-15% latency hit) to enforce at generation.",[22,233,234],{},"Both replace text-to-dict with direct domain objects, enabling composition into pipelines.",[17,236,238],{"id":237},"production-rules-reliability-over-hype","Production Rules: Reliability Over Hype",[22,240,241],{},"Log all ValidationErrors as signals for schema tweaks (e.g., unclear descriptions, tight bounds). Defaults: field descriptions, enums for constraints, numeric ge\u002Fle, flat schemas, strict mode. Retry strict failures with json_object fallback. This schema-first shift turns PoC hacks into systems where LLM output matches app schemas exactly, preventing bugs at DB boundaries.",[243,244,245],"style",{},"html .default .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-default);background: var(--shiki-default-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-default-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-default-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-default-text-decoration);}html .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-default);background: var(--shiki-default-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-default-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-default-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-default-text-decoration);}html .dark .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-dark);background: var(--shiki-dark-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-dark-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-dark-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-dark-text-decoration);}html.dark .shiki span {color: var(--shiki-dark);background: var(--shiki-dark-bg);font-style: var(--shiki-dark-font-style);font-weight: var(--shiki-dark-font-weight);text-decoration: var(--shiki-dark-text-decoration);}",{"title":46,"searchDepth":59,"depth":59,"links":247},[248,249,250,251],{"id":19,"depth":59,"text":20},{"id":35,"depth":59,"text":36},{"id":197,"depth":59,"text":198},{"id":237,"depth":59,"text":238},[253],"AI & LLMs",null,"md",false,{"content_references":258,"triage":267},[259,263,265],{"type":260,"title":261,"context":262},"tool","Pydantic","recommended",{"type":260,"title":264,"context":262},"LangChain",{"type":260,"title":266,"context":262},"OpenAI Python SDK",{"relevance":78,"novelty":72,"quality":72,"actionability":72,"composite":268,"reasoning":269},4.35,"Category: AI & LLMs. The article provides a practical approach to improving LLM output reliability using Pydantic, addressing a specific pain point of developers dealing with fragile JSON outputs. It offers concrete examples of how to implement Pydantic schemas, making it actionable for the audience.","\u002Fsummaries\u002Fpydantic-schemas-fix-llm-output-fragility-summary","2026-04-15 15:01:01","2026-04-16 03:18:53",{"title":5,"description":46},{"loc":270},"4032b4c2b6a73cd8","Towards AI","article","https:\u002F\u002Fpub.towardsai.net\u002Fstructured-output-for-llms-in-production-from-json-loads-to-validated-objects-84e14a2504d0?source=rss----98111c9905da---4","summaries\u002Fpydantic-schemas-fix-llm-output-fragility-summary",[281,45,282,283],"llm","pydantic","langchain","Evolve from brittle json.loads() parsers to Pydantic-validated objects using OpenAI JSON Schema modes and LangChain, enforcing types, keys, and constraints at generation time for production reliability.",[282,283],"rpC8hhzSglqnLZHBjiMywn484TQv4dnpjONG9KYczcY",[288,291,293,296,298,301,304,307,310,312,314,316,318,320,322,324,326,328,330,332,334,336,338,341,343,345,347,349,351,353,355,357,359,361,363,365,367,369,371,373,375,377,379,381,383,386,388,390,392,394,396,398,400,402,404,406,408,410,412,414,416,418,420,422,424,426,428,430,432,434,436,438,440,442,444,446,448,450,452,454,456,458,460,462,464,466,468,470,472,474,476,478,480,482,484,486,488,490,492,494,496,498,500,502,504,506,508,510,512,514,516,518,520,522,524,526,528,530,532,534,536,538,540,542,544,546,548,550,552,554,556,558,560,562,564,566,568,570,572,574,576,578,580,582,584,586,588,590,592,594,596,598,600,602,604,606,608,610,612,614,616,618,620,622,624,626,628,630,632,634,636,638,640,642,644,646,648,651,653,655,657,659,661,663,665,667,669,671,673,675,677,679,681,683,685,687,689,691,693,695,697,699,701,703,705,707,709,711,713,715,717,719,721,723,725,727,729,731,733,735,738,740,742,744,746,748,750,752,754,756,758,760,762,764,766,768,770,772,774,776,778,780,782,784,786,788,790,792,794,796,798,800,802,804,806,808,810,812,814,816,818,820,822,824,826,828,830,832,834,836,838,840,842,844,846,848,850,852,854,856,858,860,862,864,866,868,870,872,874,876,878,880,882,884,886,888,890,892,894,896,898,900,902,904,906,908,910,912,914,916,918,920,922,924,926,928,930,932,934,936,938,940,942,944,946,948,950,952,954,956,958,960,962,964,966,968,970,972,974,976,978,980,982,984,986,988,990,992,994,996,998,1000,1002,1004,1006,1008,1010,1012,1014,1016,1018,1020,1022,1024,1026,1028,1030,1032,1034,1036,1038,1040,1042,1044,1046,1048,1050,1052,1054,1056,1058,1060,1062,1064,1066,1068,1070,1072,1074,1076,1078,1080,1082,1084,1086,1088,1090,1092,1094,1096,1098,1100,1102,1104,1106,1108,1110,1112,1114,1116,1118,1120,1122,1124,1126,1128,1130,1132,1134,1136,1138,1140,1142,1144,1146,1148,1150,1152,1154,1156,1158,1160,1162,1164,1166,1168,1170,1172,1174,1176,1178,1180,1182,1184,1186,1188,1190,1192,1194,1196,1198,1200,1202,1204,1206,1208,1210,1212,1214,1216,1218,1220,1222,1224,1226,1228,1230,1232,1234,1236,1238,1240,1242,1244,1246,1248,1250,1252,1254,1256,1258,1260,1262,1264,1266,1268,1270,1272,1274,1276,1278,1280,1282,1284,1286,1288,1290,1292,1294,1296,1298,1300,1302,1304,1306,1308,1310,1312,1314,1316,1318,1320,1322,1324,1326,1328,1330,1332,1334,1336,1338,1340,1342,1344,1346,1348,1350,1352,1354,1356,1358,1360,1362,1364,1366,1368,1370,1372,1374,1376,1378,1380,1382,1384,1386,1388,1390,1392,1394,1396,1398,1400,1402,1404,1406,1408,1410,1412,1414,1416,1418,1420,1422,1424,1426,1428,1430,1432,1434,1436,1438,1440,1442,1444,1446,1448,1450,1452,1454,1456,1458,1460,1462,1464,1466,1468,1470,1472,1474,1476,1478,1480,1482,1484,1486,1488,1490,1492,1494,1496,1498,1500,1502,1504,1506,1508,1510,1512,1514,1516,1518,1520,1522,1524,1526,1528,1530,1532,1534,1536,1538,1540,1542,1544,1546,1548,1550,1552,1554,1556,1558,1560,1562,1564,1566,1568,1570,1572,1574,1576,1578,1580,1582,1584,1586,1588,1590,1592,1594,1596,1598,1600,1602,1604,1606,1608,1610,1612,1614,1616,1618,1620,1622,1624,1626,1628,1630,1632,1634,1636,1638,1640,1642,1644,1646,1648,1650,1652,1654,1656,1658,1660,1662,1664,1666,1668,1670,1672,1674,1676,1678,1680,1682,1684,1686,1688,1690,1692,1694,1696,1698,1700,1702,1704,1706,1708,1710,1712,1714,1716,1718,1720,1722,1724,1726,1728,1730,1732,1734,1736,1738,1740,1742,1744,1746,1748,1750,1752,1754,1756,1758,1760,1762,1764,1766,1768,1770,1772,1774,1776,1778,1780,1782,1784,1786,1788,1790,1792,1794,1796,1798,1800,1802,1804,1806,1808,1810,1812,1814,1816,1818,1820,1822,1824,1826,1828,1830,1832,1834,1836,1838,1840,1842,1844,1846,1848,1850,1852,1854,1856,1858,1860,1862,1864,1866,1868,1870,1872,1874,1876,1878,1880,1882,1884,1886,1888,1890,1892,1894,1896,1898,1900,1902,1904,1906,1908,1910,1912,1914,1916,1918,1920,1922,1924,1926,1928,1930,1932,1934,1936,1938,1940,1942,1944,1946,1948,1950,1952,1954,1956,1958,1960,1962,1964,1966,1968,1970,1972,1974,1976,1978,1980,1982,1984,1986,1988,1990,1992,1994,1996,1998,2000,2002,2004,2006,2008,2010,2012,2014,2016,2018,2020,2022,2024,2026,2028,2030,2032,2034,2036,2038,2040,2042,2044,2046,2048,2050,2052,2054,2056,2058,2060,2062,2064,2066,2068,2070,2072,2074,2076,2078,2080,2082,2084,2086,2088,2090,2092,2094,2096,2098,2100,2102,2104,2106,2108,2110,2112,2114,2116,2118,2120,2122,2124,2126,2128,2130,2132,2134,2136,2138,2140,2142,2144,2146,2148,2150,2152,2154,2156,2158,2160,2162,2164,2166,2168,2170,2172,2174,2176,2178,2180,2182,2184,2186,2188,2190,2192,2194,2196,2198,2200,2202,2204,2206,2208,2210,2212,2214,2216,2218,2220,2222,2224,2226,2228,2230,2232,2234,2236,2238,2240,2242,2244,2246,2248,2250,2252,2254,2256,2258,2260,2262,2264,2266,2268,2270,2272,2274,2276,2278,2280,2282,2284,2286,2288,2290,2292,2294,2296,2298,2300,2302,2304,2306,2308,2310,2312,2314,2316,2318,2320,2322,2324,2326,2328,2330,2332,2334,2336,2338,2340,2342,2344,2346,2348,2350,2352,2354,2356,2358,2360,2362,2364,2366,2368,2370,2372,2374,2376,2378,2380,2382,2384,2386,2388,2390,2392,2394,2396,2398,2400,2402,2404,2406,2408,2410,2412,2414,2416,2418,2420,2422,2424,2426,2428,2430,2432,2434,2436,2438,2440,2442,2444,2446,2448,2450,2452,2454,2456,2458,2460,2462,2464,2466,2468,2470,2472,2474,2476,2478,2480,2482,2484,2486,2488,2490,2492,2494,2496,2498,2500,2502,2504,2506,2508,2510,2512,2514,2516,2518,2520,2522,2524,2526,2528,2530,2532,2534,2536,2538,2540,2542,2544,2546,2548,2550,2552,2554,2556,2558,2560,2562,2564,2566,2568,2570,2572,2574,2576,2578,2580,2582,2584,2586,2588,2590,2592,2594,2596,2598,2600,2602,2604,2606,2608,2610,2612,2614,2616,2618,2620,2622,2624,2626,2628,2630,2632,2634,2636,2638,2640,2642,2644,2646,2648,2650,2652,2654,2656,2658,2660,2662,2664,2666,2668,2670,2672,2674,2676,2678,2680,2682,2684,2686,2688,2690,2692,2694,2696,2698,2700,2702,2704,2706,2708,2710,2712,2714,2716,2718,2720,2722,2724,2726,2728,2730,2732,2734,2736,2738,2740,2742,2744,2746,2748,2750,2752,2754,2756,2758,2760,2762,2764,2766,2768,2770,2772,2774,2776,2778,2780,2782,2784,2786,2788,2790,2792,2794,2796,2798,2800,2802,2804,2806,2808,2810,2812,2814,2816,2818,2820,2822,2824,2826,2828,2830,2832,2834,2836,2838,2840,2842,2844,2846,2848,2850,2852,2854,2856,2858,2860,2862,2864,2866,2868,2870,2872,2874,2876,2878,2880,2882,2884,2886,2888,2890,2892,2894,2896,2898,2900,2902,2904,2906,2908,2910,2912,2914,2916,2918,2920,2922,2924,2926,2928,2930,2932,2934,2936,2938,2940,2942,2944,2946,2948,2950,2952,2954,2956,2958,2960,2962,2964,2966,2968,2970,2972,2974,2976,2978,2980,2982,2984,2986,2988,2990,2992,2994,2996,2998,3000,3002,3004,3006,3008,3010,3012,3014,3016,3018,3020,3022,3024,3026,3028,3030,3032,3034,3036,3038,3040,3042,3044,3046,3048,3050,3052,3054,3056,3058,3060,3062,3064,3066,3068,3070,3072,3074,3076,3078,3080,3082,3084,3086,3088,3090,3092,3094,3096,3098,3100,3102,3104,3106,3108,3110,3112,3114,3116,3118,3120,3122,3124,3126,3128,3130,3132,3134,3136,3138,3140,3142,3144,3146,3148,3150,3152,3154,3156,3158,3160,3162,3164,3166,3168,3170,3172,3174,3176,3178,3180,3182,3184,3186,3188,3190,3192,3194,3196,3198,3200,3202,3204,3206,3208,3210,3212,3214,3216,3218,3220,3222,3224,3226,3228,3230,3232,3234,3236,3238,3240,3242,3244,3246,3248,3250,3252,3254,3256,3258,3260,3262,3264,3266,3268,3270,3272,3274,3276,3278,3280,3282,3284,3286,3288,3290,3292,3294,3296,3298,3300,3302,3304,3306,3308,3310,3312,3314,3316,3318,3320,3322,3324,3326,3328,3330,3332,3334,3336,3338,3340,3342,3344,3346,3348,3350,3352,3354,3356,3358,3360,3362,3364,3366,3368,3370,3372,3374,3376,3378,3380,3382,3384,3386,3388,3390,3392,3394,3396,3398,3400,3402,3404,3406,3408,3410,3412,3414,3416,3418,3420,3422,3424,3426,3428,3430,3432,3434,3436,3438,3440,3442,3444,3446,3448,3450,3452,3454,3456,3458,3460,3462,3464,3466,3468,3470,3472,3474,3476,3478,3480,3482,3484,3486,3488,3490,3492,3494,3496,3498,3500,3502,3504,3506,3508,3510,3512,3514,3516,3518,3520,3522,3524,3526,3528,3530,3532,3534,3536,3538,3540,3542,3544,3546,3548,3550,3552,3554,3556,3558,3560,3562,3564,3566,3568,3570,3572,3574,3576,3578,3580,3582,3584,3586,3588,3590,3592,3594,3596,3598,3600,3602,3604,3606,3608,3610,3612,3614,3616,3618,3620,3622,3624,3626,3628,3630,3632,3634,3636,3638,3640,3642,3644,3646,3648,3650,3652,3654,3656,3658,3660,3662,3664,3666,3668,3670,3672,3674,3676,3678,3680,3682,3684,3686,3688,3690,3692,3694,3696,3698,3700,3702,3704,3706,3708,3710,3712,3714,3716,3718,3720,3722,3724,3726,3728,3730,3732,3734,3736,3738,3740,3742,3744,3746,3748,3750,3752,3754,3756,3758,3760,3762,3764,3766,3768,3770,3772,3774,3776,3778,3780,3782,3784,3786,3788,3790,3792,3794,3796,3798,3800,3802,3804,3806,3808,3810,3812,3814,3816,3818,3820,3822,3824,3826,3828,3830,3832,3834,3836,3838,3840,3842,3844,3846,3848,3850,3852,3854,3856,3858,3860,3862,3864,3866,3868,3870,3872,3874,3876,3878,3880,3882,3884,3886,3888,3890,3892,3894,3896,3898,3900,3902,3904,3906,3908,3910,3912,3914,3916,3918,3920,3922,3924,3926,3928,3930,3932,3934,3936,3938,3940,3942,3944,3946,3948,3950,3952,3954,3956,3958,3960,3962,3964,3966,3968,3970,3972,3974,3976,3978,3980,3982,3984,3986,3988,3990,3992,3994,3996,3998,4000,4002,4004,4006,4008,4010,4012,4014,4016,4018,4020,4022,4024,4026,4028,4030,4032,4034,4036,4038,4040,4042,4044,4046,4048,4050,4052,4054,4056,4058,4060,4062,4064,4066,4068,4070,4072,4074,4076,4078,4080,4082,4084,4086,4088,4090,4092,4094,4096,4098,4100,4102,4104,4106,4108,4110,4112,4114,4116,4118,4120,4122,4124,4126,4128,4130,4132,4134,4136,4138,4140,4142,4144,4146,4148,4150,4152,4154,4156,4158,4160,4162,4164,4166,4168,4170,4172,4174,4176,4178,4180,4182,4184,4186,4188,4190,4192,4194,4196,4198,4200,4202,4204,4206,4208,4210,4212,4214,4216,4218,4220,4222,4224,4226,4228,4230,4232,4234,4236,4238,4240,4242,4244,4246,4248,4250,4252,4254,4256,4258,4260,4262,4264,4266,4268,4270,4272,4274,4276,4278,4280,4282,4284,4286,4288,4290,4292,4294,4296,4298,4300,4302,4304,4306,4308,4310,4312,4314,4316,4318,4320,4322,4324,4326,4328,4330,4332,4334,4336,4338,4340,4342,4344,4346,4348,4350,4352,4354,4356,4358,4360,4362,4364,4366,4368,4370,4372,4374,4376,4378,4380,4382,4384,4386,4388,4390,4392,4394,4396,4398,4400,4402,4404,4406,4408,4410,4412,4414,4416,4418,4420,4422,4424,4426,4428,4430,4432,4434,4436,4438,4440,4442,4444,4446,4448,4450,4452,4454,4456,4458,4460,4462,4464,4466,4468,4470,4472,4474,4476,4478,4480,4482,4484,4486,4488,4490,4492,4494,4496,4498,4500,4502,4504,4506,4508,4510,4512,4514,4516,4518,4520,4522,4524,4526,4528,4530,4532,4534,4536,4538,4540,4542,4544,4546,4548,4550,4552,4554,4556,4558,4560,4562,4564,4566,4568,4570,4572,4574,4576,4578,4580,4582,4584,4586,4588,4590,4592,4594,4596,4598,4600,4602,4604,4606,4608,4610,4612,4614,4616,4618,4620,4622,4624,4626,4628,4630,4632,4634,4636,4638,4640,4642,4644,4646,4648,4650,4652,4654,4656,4658,4660,4662,4664,4666,4668,4670,4672,4674,4676,4678,4680,4682,4684,4686,4688,4690],{"categories":289},[290],"Business & SaaS",{"categories":292},[290],{"categories":294},[295],"AI News & Trends",{"categories":297},[],{"categories":299},[300],"AI Automation",{"categories":302},[303],"Marketing & Growth",{"categories":305},[306],"Design & Frontend",{"categories":308},[309],"Software Engineering",{"categories":311},[300],{"categories":313},[],{"categories":315},[306],{"categories":317},[306],{"categories":319},[300],{"categories":321},[306],{"categories":323},[306],{"categories":325},[253],{"categories":327},[306],{"categories":329},[306],{"categories":331},[],{"categories":333},[306],{"categories":335},[306],{"categories":337},[253],{"categories":339},[340],"Developer Productivity",{"categories":342},[253],{"categories":344},[253],{"categories":346},[253],{"categories":348},[295],{"categories":350},[253],{"categories":352},[300],{"categories":354},[290],{"categories":356},[295],{"categories":358},[303],{"categories":360},[],{"categories":362},[],{"categories":364},[300],{"categories":366},[300],{"categories":368},[300],{"categories":370},[303],{"categories":372},[253],{"categories":374},[340],{"categories":376},[295],{"categories":378},[],{"categories":380},[],{"categories":382},[],{"categories":384},[385],"Data Science & Visualization",{"categories":387},[],{"categories":389},[300],{"categories":391},[309],{"categories":393},[300],{"categories":395},[300],{"categories":397},[253],{"categories":399},[303],{"categories":401},[300],{"categories":403},[],{"categories":405},[],{"categories":407},[],{"categories":409},[306],{"categories":411},[306],{"categories":413},[300],{"categories":415},[303],{"categories":417},[340],{"categories":419},[306],{"categories":421},[253],{"categories":423},[309],{"categories":425},[253],{"categories":427},[],{"categories":429},[300],{"categories":431},[253],{"categories":433},[340],{"categories":435},[340],{"categories":437},[],{"categories":439},[303],{"categories":441},[290],{"categories":443},[253],{"categories":445},[290],{"categories":447},[290],{"categories":449},[300],{"categories":451},[303],{"categories":453},[300],{"categories":455},[290],{"categories":457},[300],{"categories":459},[306],{"categories":461},[253],{"categories":463},[306],{"categories":465},[253],{"categories":467},[290],{"categories":469},[253],{"categories":471},[303],{"categories":473},[],{"categories":475},[253],{"categories":477},[290],{"categories":479},[],{"categories":481},[295],{"categories":483},[309],{"categories":485},[],{"categories":487},[253],{"categories":489},[306],{"categories":491},[253],{"categories":493},[306],{"categories":495},[],{"categories":497},[300],{"categories":499},[],{"categories":501},[],{"categories":503},[],{"categories":505},[253],{"categories":507},[],{"categories":509},[253],{"categories":511},[253],{"categories":513},[306],{"categories":515},[253],{"categories":517},[340],{"categories":519},[300],{"categories":521},[303],{"categories":523},[340],{"categories":525},[340],{"categories":527},[340],{"categories":529},[303],{"categories":531},[303],{"categories":533},[253],{"categories":535},[253],{"categories":537},[306],{"categories":539},[290],{"categories":541},[306],{"categories":543},[309],{"categories":545},[290],{"categories":547},[290],{"categories":549},[290],{"categories":551},[306],{"categories":553},[],{"categories":555},[],{"categories":557},[253],{"categories":559},[253],{"categories":561},[309],{"categories":563},[253],{"categories":565},[253],{"categories":567},[],{"categories":569},[253],{"categories":571},[253],{"categories":573},[],{"categories":575},[253],{"categories":577},[295],{"categories":579},[295],{"categories":581},[],{"categories":583},[],{"categories":585},[303],{"categories":587},[303],{"categories":589},[309],{"categories":591},[253],{"categories":593},[],{"categories":595},[],{"categories":597},[300],{"categories":599},[253],{"categories":601},[253],{"categories":603},[],{"categories":605},[253,290],{"categories":607},[253],{"categories":609},[],{"categories":611},[253],{"categories":613},[253],{"categories":615},[],{"categories":617},[],{"categories":619},[300],{"categories":621},[253],{"categories":623},[253],{"categories":625},[300],{"categories":627},[253],{"categories":629},[],{"categories":631},[],{"categories":633},[253],{"categories":635},[],{"categories":637},[253],{"categories":639},[253],{"categories":641},[],{"categories":643},[300],{"categories":645},[306],{"categories":647},[],{"categories":649},[300,650],"DevOps & Cloud",{"categories":652},[253],{"categories":654},[300],{"categories":656},[253],{"categories":658},[],{"categories":660},[],{"categories":662},[],{"categories":664},[],{"categories":666},[253],{"categories":668},[300],{"categories":670},[],{"categories":672},[300],{"categories":674},[],{"categories":676},[253],{"categories":678},[],{"categories":680},[],{"categories":682},[],{"categories":684},[],{"categories":686},[300],{"categories":688},[306],{"categories":690},[253],{"categories":692},[303],{"categories":694},[295],{"categories":696},[290],{"categories":698},[340],{"categories":700},[],{"categories":702},[300],{"categories":704},[300],{"categories":706},[253],{"categories":708},[],{"categories":710},[],{"categories":712},[],{"categories":714},[300],{"categories":716},[],{"categories":718},[300],{"categories":720},[300],{"categories":722},[295],{"categories":724},[300],{"categories":726},[253],{"categories":728},[],{"categories":730},[253],{"categories":732},[],{"categories":734},[295],{"categories":736},[300,737],"Product Strategy",{"categories":739},[309],{"categories":741},[650],{"categories":743},[737],{"categories":745},[253],{"categories":747},[300],{"categories":749},[],{"categories":751},[295],{"categories":753},[295],{"categories":755},[300],{"categories":757},[],{"categories":759},[300],{"categories":761},[253],{"categories":763},[253],{"categories":765},[340],{"categories":767},[253],{"categories":769},[],{"categories":771},[253,309],{"categories":773},[295],{"categories":775},[253],{"categories":777},[295],{"categories":779},[300],{"categories":781},[295],{"categories":783},[],{"categories":785},[309],{"categories":787},[290],{"categories":789},[],{"categories":791},[300],{"categories":793},[300],{"categories":795},[300],{"categories":797},[300],{"categories":799},[290],{"categories":801},[306],{"categories":803},[303],{"categories":805},[],{"categories":807},[300],{"categories":809},[],{"categories":811},[295],{"categories":813},[295],{"categories":815},[295],{"categories":817},[300],{"categories":819},[295],{"categories":821},[253],{"categories":823},[340],{"categories":825},[253],{"categories":827},[309],{"categories":829},[253,340],{"categories":831},[340],{"categories":833},[340],{"categories":835},[340],{"categories":837},[340],{"categories":839},[253],{"categories":841},[],{"categories":843},[],{"categories":845},[303],{"categories":847},[],{"categories":849},[253],{"categories":851},[340],{"categories":853},[253],{"categories":855},[306],{"categories":857},[309],{"categories":859},[],{"categories":861},[253],{"categories":863},[340],{"categories":865},[303],{"categories":867},[295],{"categories":869},[309],{"categories":871},[253],{"categories":873},[],{"categories":875},[309],{"categories":877},[306],{"categories":879},[290],{"categories":881},[290],{"categories":883},[],{"categories":885},[306],{"categories":887},[290],{"categories":889},[295],{"categories":891},[340],{"categories":893},[300],{"categories":895},[300],{"categories":897},[253],{"categories":899},[253],{"categories":901},[295],{"categories":903},[295],{"categories":905},[340],{"categories":907},[295],{"categories":909},[],{"categories":911},[737],{"categories":913},[300],{"categories":915},[295],{"categories":917},[295],{"categories":919},[295],{"categories":921},[253],{"categories":923},[300],{"categories":925},[300],{"categories":927},[290],{"categories":929},[290],{"categories":931},[253],{"categories":933},[295],{"categories":935},[],{"categories":937},[253],{"categories":939},[290],{"categories":941},[300],{"categories":943},[300],{"categories":945},[300],{"categories":947},[306],{"categories":949},[300],{"categories":951},[340],{"categories":953},[295],{"categories":955},[295],{"categories":957},[295],{"categories":959},[295],{"categories":961},[295],{"categories":963},[],{"categories":965},[],{"categories":967},[340],{"categories":969},[295],{"categories":971},[295],{"categories":973},[295],{"categories":975},[],{"categories":977},[253],{"categories":979},[],{"categories":981},[],{"categories":983},[306],{"categories":985},[290],{"categories":987},[],{"categories":989},[295],{"categories":991},[300],{"categories":993},[300],{"categories":995},[300],{"categories":997},[303],{"categories":999},[300],{"categories":1001},[],{"categories":1003},[295],{"categories":1005},[295],{"categories":1007},[253],{"categories":1009},[],{"categories":1011},[303],{"categories":1013},[303],{"categories":1015},[253],{"categories":1017},[295],{"categories":1019},[290],{"categories":1021},[309],{"categories":1023},[253],{"categories":1025},[],{"categories":1027},[253],{"categories":1029},[253],{"categories":1031},[309],{"categories":1033},[253],{"categories":1035},[253],{"categories":1037},[253],{"categories":1039},[303],{"categories":1041},[295],{"categories":1043},[253],{"categories":1045},[253],{"categories":1047},[295],{"categories":1049},[300],{"categories":1051},[340],{"categories":1053},[290],{"categories":1055},[253],{"categories":1057},[340],{"categories":1059},[340],{"categories":1061},[],{"categories":1063},[303],{"categories":1065},[295],{"categories":1067},[295],{"categories":1069},[340],{"categories":1071},[300],{"categories":1073},[300],{"categories":1075},[300],{"categories":1077},[300],{"categories":1079},[306],{"categories":1081},[253],{"categories":1083},[253],{"categories":1085},[737],{"categories":1087},[253],{"categories":1089},[253],{"categories":1091},[300],{"categories":1093},[290],{"categories":1095},[303],{"categories":1097},[],{"categories":1099},[290],{"categories":1101},[290],{"categories":1103},[],{"categories":1105},[306],{"categories":1107},[253],{"categories":1109},[],{"categories":1111},[],{"categories":1113},[295],{"categories":1115},[295],{"categories":1117},[295],{"categories":1119},[295],{"categories":1121},[],{"categories":1123},[295],{"categories":1125},[253],{"categories":1127},[253],{"categories":1129},[],{"categories":1131},[295],{"categories":1133},[295],{"categories":1135},[290],{"categories":1137},[253],{"categories":1139},[],{"categories":1141},[],{"categories":1143},[295],{"categories":1145},[295],{"categories":1147},[295],{"categories":1149},[253],{"categories":1151},[295],{"categories":1153},[295],{"categories":1155},[295],{"categories":1157},[295],{"categories":1159},[295],{"categories":1161},[],{"categories":1163},[300],{"categories":1165},[253],{"categories":1167},[303],{"categories":1169},[290],{"categories":1171},[300],{"categories":1173},[253],{"categories":1175},[],{"categories":1177},[303],{"categories":1179},[295],{"categories":1181},[295],{"categories":1183},[295],{"categories":1185},[295],{"categories":1187},[340],{"categories":1189},[309],{"categories":1191},[],{"categories":1193},[253],{"categories":1195},[300],{"categories":1197},[300],{"categories":1199},[300],{"categories":1201},[650],{"categories":1203},[300],{"categories":1205},[253],{"categories":1207},[253],{"categories":1209},[309],{"categories":1211},[650],{"categories":1213},[385],{"categories":1215},[253],{"categories":1217},[385],{"categories":1219},[],{"categories":1221},[303],{"categories":1223},[303],{"categories":1225},[306],{"categories":1227},[650],{"categories":1229},[300],{"categories":1231},[253],{"categories":1233},[253],{"categories":1235},[300],{"categories":1237},[300],{"categories":1239},[300],{"categories":1241},[340],{"categories":1243},[340],{"categories":1245},[300],{"categories":1247},[300],{"categories":1249},[],{"categories":1251},[300],{"categories":1253},[300],{"categories":1255},[253],{"categories":1257},[385],{"categories":1259},[300],{"categories":1261},[300],{"categories":1263},[300],{"categories":1265},[300],{"categories":1267},[290],{"categories":1269},[306],{"categories":1271},[295],{"categories":1273},[309],{"categories":1275},[650],{"categories":1277},[309],{"categories":1279},[385],{"categories":1281},[],{"categories":1283},[309],{"categories":1285},[],{"categories":1287},[],{"categories":1289},[309],{"categories":1291},[253],{"categories":1293},[],{"categories":1295},[],{"categories":1297},[],{"categories":1299},[290],{"categories":1301},[],{"categories":1303},[],{"categories":1305},[385],{"categories":1307},[253],{"categories":1309},[650],{"categories":1311},[253],{"categories":1313},[],{"categories":1315},[300],{"categories":1317},[340],{"categories":1319},[340],{"categories":1321},[303],{"categories":1323},[303],{"categories":1325},[303],{"categories":1327},[650],{"categories":1329},[309],{"categories":1331},[300],{"categories":1333},[290],{"categories":1335},[290],{"categories":1337},[309],{"categories":1339},[306],{"categories":1341},[385],{"categories":1343},[306],{"categories":1345},[],{"categories":1347},[253],{"categories":1349},[300],{"categories":1351},[300],{"categories":1353},[340],{"categories":1355},[300],{"categories":1357},[300],{"categories":1359},[306],{"categories":1361},[306],{"categories":1363},[300],{"categories":1365},[650],{"categories":1367},[253],{"categories":1369},[],{"categories":1371},[303],{"categories":1373},[300],{"categories":1375},[290],{"categories":1377},[300],{"categories":1379},[300],{"categories":1381},[],{"categories":1383},[253],{"categories":1385},[300],{"categories":1387},[300],{"categories":1389},[340],{"categories":1391},[300],{"categories":1393},[253],{"categories":1395},[],{"categories":1397},[300],{"categories":1399},[],{"categories":1401},[306],{"categories":1403},[340],{"categories":1405},[253],{"categories":1407},[309],{"categories":1409},[306],{"categories":1411},[340],{"categories":1413},[385],{"categories":1415},[340],{"categories":1417},[],{"categories":1419},[253],{"categories":1421},[253],{"categories":1423},[737],{"categories":1425},[309],{"categories":1427},[253,300],{"categories":1429},[300],{"categories":1431},[253],{"categories":1433},[300],{"categories":1435},[300,309],{"categories":1437},[300],{"categories":1439},[253],{"categories":1441},[],{"categories":1443},[340],{"categories":1445},[253],{"categories":1447},[300],{"categories":1449},[253],{"categories":1451},[],{"categories":1453},[309],{"categories":1455},[290],{"categories":1457},[300],{"categories":1459},[],{"categories":1461},[385],{"categories":1463},[309],{"categories":1465},[300],{"categories":1467},[309],{"categories":1469},[],{"categories":1471},[300],{"categories":1473},[],{"categories":1475},[300],{"categories":1477},[],{"categories":1479},[],{"categories":1481},[306],{"categories":1483},[340],{"categories":1485},[253],{"categories":1487},[300],{"categories":1489},[],{"categories":1491},[300],{"categories":1493},[309],{"categories":1495},[253],{"categories":1497},[253],{"categories":1499},[309],{"categories":1501},[309],{"categories":1503},[340],{"categories":1505},[290],{"categories":1507},[],{"categories":1509},[253],{"categories":1511},[253],{"categories":1513},[253],{"categories":1515},[300],{"categories":1517},[253],{"categories":1519},[],{"categories":1521},[306],{"categories":1523},[253],{"categories":1525},[300],{"categories":1527},[],{"categories":1529},[253],{"categories":1531},[],{"categories":1533},[253],{"categories":1535},[],{"categories":1537},[],{"categories":1539},[],{"categories":1541},[253],{"categories":1543},[253],{"categories":1545},[253],{"categories":1547},[253],{"categories":1549},[],{"categories":1551},[253],{"categories":1553},[253],{"categories":1555},[253],{"categories":1557},[],{"categories":1559},[253],{"categories":1561},[],{"categories":1563},[303],{"categories":1565},[253],{"categories":1567},[],{"categories":1569},[],{"categories":1571},[],{"categories":1573},[253],{"categories":1575},[295],{"categories":1577},[295],{"categories":1579},[],{"categories":1581},[300],{"categories":1583},[253],{"categories":1585},[],{"categories":1587},[253],{"categories":1589},[253],{"categories":1591},[295],{"categories":1593},[],{"categories":1595},[253],{"categories":1597},[295],{"categories":1599},[300],{"categories":1601},[253],{"categories":1603},[],{"categories":1605},[],{"categories":1607},[],{"categories":1609},[300],{"categories":1611},[300],{"categories":1613},[300],{"categories":1615},[300],{"categories":1617},[253],{"categories":1619},[306],{"categories":1621},[306],{"categories":1623},[300],{"categories":1625},[300],{"categories":1627},[340],{"categories":1629},[737],{"categories":1631},[340],{"categories":1633},[340],{"categories":1635},[253],{"categories":1637},[300],{"categories":1639},[253],{"categories":1641},[340],{"categories":1643},[253],{"categories":1645},[300],{"categories":1647},[300],{"categories":1649},[300],{"categories":1651},[300],{"categories":1653},[300],{"categories":1655},[253],{"categories":1657},[340],{"categories":1659},[340],{"categories":1661},[303],{"categories":1663},[300],{"categories":1665},[],{"categories":1667},[300],{"categories":1669},[],{"categories":1671},[295],{"categories":1673},[253],{"categories":1675},[],{"categories":1677},[290],{"categories":1679},[306],{"categories":1681},[306],{"categories":1683},[300],{"categories":1685},[300],{"categories":1687},[253],{"categories":1689},[253],{"categories":1691},[295],{"categories":1693},[295],{"categories":1695},[650],{"categories":1697},[300],{"categories":1699},[295],{"categories":1701},[],{"categories":1703},[253],{"categories":1705},[300],{"categories":1707},[300],{"categories":1709},[300],{"categories":1711},[300],{"categories":1713},[253],{"categories":1715},[253],{"categories":1717},[253],{"categories":1719},[253],{"categories":1721},[300],{"categories":1723},[300],{"categories":1725},[300],{"categories":1727},[300],{"categories":1729},[],{"categories":1731},[306],{"categories":1733},[253],{"categories":1735},[253],{"categories":1737},[253],{"categories":1739},[],{"categories":1741},[303],{"categories":1743},[],{"categories":1745},[340],{"categories":1747},[],{"categories":1749},[300],{"categories":1751},[340],{"categories":1753},[306],{"categories":1755},[340],{"categories":1757},[],{"categories":1759},[340],{"categories":1761},[340],{"categories":1763},[],{"categories":1765},[306],{"categories":1767},[300],{"categories":1769},[300],{"categories":1771},[340],{"categories":1773},[253],{"categories":1775},[253],{"categories":1777},[],{"categories":1779},[295],{"categories":1781},[],{"categories":1783},[303],{"categories":1785},[],{"categories":1787},[306],{"categories":1789},[295],{"categories":1791},[306],{"categories":1793},[306],{"categories":1795},[306],{"categories":1797},[306],{"categories":1799},[306],{"categories":1801},[306],{"categories":1803},[306],{"categories":1805},[306],{"categories":1807},[306],{"categories":1809},[306],{"categories":1811},[],{"categories":1813},[300],{"categories":1815},[306],{"categories":1817},[253],{"categories":1819},[253],{"categories":1821},[306],{"categories":1823},[306],{"categories":1825},[306],{"categories":1827},[306],{"categories":1829},[306],{"categories":1831},[306],{"categories":1833},[306],{"categories":1835},[253,306],{"categories":1837},[306],{"categories":1839},[306],{"categories":1841},[306],{"categories":1843},[306],{"categories":1845},[],{"categories":1847},[306],{"categories":1849},[306],{"categories":1851},[306],{"categories":1853},[306],{"categories":1855},[306],{"categories":1857},[306],{"categories":1859},[306],{"categories":1861},[306],{"categories":1863},[306],{"categories":1865},[306,253],{"categories":1867},[306],{"categories":1869},[306],{"categories":1871},[],{"categories":1873},[295],{"categories":1875},[],{"categories":1877},[253],{"categories":1879},[],{"categories":1881},[300],{"categories":1883},[650],{"categories":1885},[737],{"categories":1887},[300],{"categories":1889},[300],{"categories":1891},[],{"categories":1893},[300],{"categories":1895},[],{"categories":1897},[300],{"categories":1899},[],{"categories":1901},[],{"categories":1903},[253],{"categories":1905},[253],{"categories":1907},[253],{"categories":1909},[295],{"categories":1911},[295],{"categories":1913},[295],{"categories":1915},[295],{"categories":1917},[],{"categories":1919},[295],{"categories":1921},[],{"categories":1923},[295],{"categories":1925},[253],{"categories":1927},[295],{"categories":1929},[295],{"categories":1931},[295],{"categories":1933},[295],{"categories":1935},[253],{"categories":1937},[295],{"categories":1939},[300],{"categories":1941},[],{"categories":1943},[300],{"categories":1945},[295],{"categories":1947},[253],{"categories":1949},[295],{"categories":1951},[295],{"categories":1953},[295],{"categories":1955},[253],{"categories":1957},[253],{"categories":1959},[253],{"categories":1961},[],{"categories":1963},[],{"categories":1965},[253],{"categories":1967},[295],{"categories":1969},[],{"categories":1971},[253],{"categories":1973},[300],{"categories":1975},[253],{"categories":1977},[300],{"categories":1979},[300],{"categories":1981},[253],{"categories":1983},[],{"categories":1985},[],{"categories":1987},[300],{"categories":1989},[300],{"categories":1991},[300],{"categories":1993},[300],{"categories":1995},[300],{"categories":1997},[300],{"categories":1999},[300],{"categories":2001},[300],{"categories":2003},[],{"categories":2005},[300],{"categories":2007},[300],{"categories":2009},[300],{"categories":2011},[253],{"categories":2013},[253],{"categories":2015},[253],{"categories":2017},[295],{"categories":2019},[253],{"categories":2021},[253],{"categories":2023},[253],{"categories":2025},[300],{"categories":2027},[303],{"categories":2029},[303],{"categories":2031},[303],{"categories":2033},[300],{"categories":2035},[],{"categories":2037},[253],{"categories":2039},[],{"categories":2041},[],{"categories":2043},[253],{"categories":2045},[],{"categories":2047},[300],{"categories":2049},[306],{"categories":2051},[340],{"categories":2053},[385],{"categories":2055},[253],{"categories":2057},[300],{"categories":2059},[306],{"categories":2061},[],{"categories":2063},[300],{"categories":2065},[303,290],{"categories":2067},[300],{"categories":2069},[300],{"categories":2071},[650],{"categories":2073},[309],{"categories":2075},[303],{"categories":2077},[340],{"categories":2079},[253],{"categories":2081},[],{"categories":2083},[253],{"categories":2085},[],{"categories":2087},[253],{"categories":2089},[253],{"categories":2091},[300],{"categories":2093},[],{"categories":2095},[253],{"categories":2097},[300],{"categories":2099},[253],{"categories":2101},[340],{"categories":2103},[300],{"categories":2105},[253],{"categories":2107},[253,340],{"categories":2109},[340],{"categories":2111},[],{"categories":2113},[253],{"categories":2115},[253],{"categories":2117},[253],{"categories":2119},[],{"categories":2121},[],{"categories":2123},[300],{"categories":2125},[303],{"categories":2127},[295],{"categories":2129},[300],{"categories":2131},[253],{"categories":2133},[295],{"categories":2135},[],{"categories":2137},[340],{"categories":2139},[295],{"categories":2141},[],{"categories":2143},[385],{"categories":2145},[303],{"categories":2147},[290],{"categories":2149},[295],{"categories":2151},[253],{"categories":2153},[300],{"categories":2155},[253],{"categories":2157},[300],{"categories":2159},[300],{"categories":2161},[295],{"categories":2163},[340],{"categories":2165},[306],{"categories":2167},[290],{"categories":2169},[253],{"categories":2171},[253],{"categories":2173},[],{"categories":2175},[],{"categories":2177},[253],{"categories":2179},[],{"categories":2181},[253],{"categories":2183},[295],{"categories":2185},[],{"categories":2187},[300],{"categories":2189},[340],{"categories":2191},[295],{"categories":2193},[340],{"categories":2195},[300],{"categories":2197},[253],{"categories":2199},[],{"categories":2201},[300],{"categories":2203},[300],{"categories":2205},[306],{"categories":2207},[300],{"categories":2209},[306],{"categories":2211},[300],{"categories":2213},[300],{"categories":2215},[306],{"categories":2217},[],{"categories":2219},[],{"categories":2221},[306],{"categories":2223},[306],{"categories":2225},[306],{"categories":2227},[309],{"categories":2229},[340],{"categories":2231},[340],{"categories":2233},[300],{"categories":2235},[295],{"categories":2237},[340],{"categories":2239},[340],{"categories":2241},[303],{"categories":2243},[306],{"categories":2245},[300],{"categories":2247},[300],{"categories":2249},[253],{"categories":2251},[340],{"categories":2253},[253],{"categories":2255},[],{"categories":2257},[650],{"categories":2259},[737],{"categories":2261},[],{"categories":2263},[],{"categories":2265},[300],{"categories":2267},[295],{"categories":2269},[303],{"categories":2271},[303],{"categories":2273},[385],{"categories":2275},[306],{"categories":2277},[385],{"categories":2279},[385],{"categories":2281},[300],{"categories":2283},[],{"categories":2285},[],{"categories":2287},[385],{"categories":2289},[309],{"categories":2291},[253],{"categories":2293},[309],{"categories":2295},[385],{"categories":2297},[309],{"categories":2299},[385],{"categories":2301},[290],{"categories":2303},[309],{"categories":2305},[340],{"categories":2307},[253],{"categories":2309},[],{"categories":2311},[385],{"categories":2313},[650],{"categories":2315},[],{"categories":2317},[253],{"categories":2319},[253],{"categories":2321},[],{"categories":2323},[],{"categories":2325},[253],{"categories":2327},[253],{"categories":2329},[295],{"categories":2331},[253],{"categories":2333},[],{"categories":2335},[295],{"categories":2337},[],{"categories":2339},[],{"categories":2341},[295],{"categories":2343},[295],{"categories":2345},[253],{"categories":2347},[253],{"categories":2349},[253],{"categories":2351},[253],{"categories":2353},[253],{"categories":2355},[253],{"categories":2357},[303],{"categories":2359},[],{"categories":2361},[253],{"categories":2363},[],{"categories":2365},[],{"categories":2367},[300],{"categories":2369},[340],{"categories":2371},[],{"categories":2373},[650],{"categories":2375},[253,650],{"categories":2377},[253],{"categories":2379},[],{"categories":2381},[306],{"categories":2383},[306],{"categories":2385},[306],{"categories":2387},[306],{"categories":2389},[306],{"categories":2391},[],{"categories":2393},[],{"categories":2395},[],{"categories":2397},[309],{"categories":2399},[300],{"categories":2401},[290],{"categories":2403},[309],{"categories":2405},[340],{"categories":2407},[306],{"categories":2409},[],{"categories":2411},[303],{"categories":2413},[737],{"categories":2415},[385],{"categories":2417},[385],{"categories":2419},[385],{"categories":2421},[340],{"categories":2423},[737],{"categories":2425},[340],{"categories":2427},[],{"categories":2429},[290],{"categories":2431},[309],{"categories":2433},[253],{"categories":2435},[306],{"categories":2437},[303],{"categories":2439},[309],{"categories":2441},[303],{"categories":2443},[253],{"categories":2445},[306],{"categories":2447},[309],{"categories":2449},[650],{"categories":2451},[253],{"categories":2453},[295],{"categories":2455},[309],{"categories":2457},[],{"categories":2459},[253],{"categories":2461},[309],{"categories":2463},[309],{"categories":2465},[300],{"categories":2467},[],{"categories":2469},[303],{"categories":2471},[303],{"categories":2473},[303],{"categories":2475},[300],{"categories":2477},[253],{"categories":2479},[],{"categories":2481},[290],{"categories":2483},[340],{"categories":2485},[340],{"categories":2487},[385],{"categories":2489},[290],{"categories":2491},[295],{"categories":2493},[385],{"categories":2495},[],{"categories":2497},[295],{"categories":2499},[295],{"categories":2501},[295],{"categories":2503},[253],{"categories":2505},[290],{"categories":2507},[253],{"categories":2509},[],{"categories":2511},[],{"categories":2513},[],{"categories":2515},[309],{"categories":2517},[300],{"categories":2519},[],{"categories":2521},[340],{"categories":2523},[306],{"categories":2525},[],{"categories":2527},[303],{"categories":2529},[],{"categories":2531},[306],{"categories":2533},[253],{"categories":2535},[340],{"categories":2537},[290],{"categories":2539},[],{"categories":2541},[306],{"categories":2543},[306],{"categories":2545},[253],{"categories":2547},[],{"categories":2549},[],{"categories":2551},[309],{"categories":2553},[253],{"categories":2555},[],{"categories":2557},[300],{"categories":2559},[253],{"categories":2561},[],{"categories":2563},[309],{"categories":2565},[300],{"categories":2567},[253],{"categories":2569},[385],{"categories":2571},[253],{"categories":2573},[],{"categories":2575},[385],{"categories":2577},[253],{"categories":2579},[309],{"categories":2581},[253],{"categories":2583},[385],{"categories":2585},[300],{"categories":2587},[253],{"categories":2589},[253],{"categories":2591},[253,300],{"categories":2593},[300],{"categories":2595},[300],{"categories":2597},[300],{"categories":2599},[306],{"categories":2601},[340],{"categories":2603},[253],{"categories":2605},[340],{"categories":2607},[306],{"categories":2609},[253],{"categories":2611},[],{"categories":2613},[],{"categories":2615},[253],{"categories":2617},[253],{"categories":2619},[253],{"categories":2621},[300],{"categories":2623},[253],{"categories":2625},[],{"categories":2627},[253],{"categories":2629},[253],{"categories":2631},[300],{"categories":2633},[300],{"categories":2635},[253],{"categories":2637},[253],{"categories":2639},[],{"categories":2641},[253],{"categories":2643},[],{"categories":2645},[253],{"categories":2647},[253],{"categories":2649},[253],{"categories":2651},[253],{"categories":2653},[253],{"categories":2655},[253],{"categories":2657},[253],{"categories":2659},[],{"categories":2661},[253],{"categories":2663},[295],{"categories":2665},[295],{"categories":2667},[],{"categories":2669},[],{"categories":2671},[253],{"categories":2673},[],{"categories":2675},[253],{"categories":2677},[253,650],{"categories":2679},[],{"categories":2681},[295],{"categories":2683},[],{"categories":2685},[253],{"categories":2687},[],{"categories":2689},[],{"categories":2691},[],{"categories":2693},[253],{"categories":2695},[],{"categories":2697},[253],{"categories":2699},[],{"categories":2701},[253],{"categories":2703},[253],{"categories":2705},[],{"categories":2707},[],{"categories":2709},[253,650],{"categories":2711},[650,253],{"categories":2713},[295],{"categories":2715},[],{"categories":2717},[253],{"categories":2719},[],{"categories":2721},[253],{"categories":2723},[253],{"categories":2725},[],{"categories":2727},[295],{"categories":2729},[253,290],{"categories":2731},[295],{"categories":2733},[309],{"categories":2735},[],{"categories":2737},[300],{"categories":2739},[253],{"categories":2741},[303],{"categories":2743},[253],{"categories":2745},[340],{"categories":2747},[340],{"categories":2749},[650],{"categories":2751},[295],{"categories":2753},[253],{"categories":2755},[650],{"categories":2757},[309],{"categories":2759},[253],{"categories":2761},[340],{"categories":2763},[],{"categories":2765},[253],{"categories":2767},[],{"categories":2769},[],{"categories":2771},[253],{"categories":2773},[],{"categories":2775},[253],{"categories":2777},[309],{"categories":2779},[290],{"categories":2781},[340],{"categories":2783},[303],{"categories":2785},[300],{"categories":2787},[340],{"categories":2789},[],{"categories":2791},[303],{"categories":2793},[],{"categories":2795},[],{"categories":2797},[253],{"categories":2799},[295],{"categories":2801},[303],{"categories":2803},[],{"categories":2805},[253],{"categories":2807},[295],{"categories":2809},[295],{"categories":2811},[303],{"categories":2813},[295],{"categories":2815},[253],{"categories":2817},[295],{"categories":2819},[253],{"categories":2821},[],{"categories":2823},[253],{"categories":2825},[253],{"categories":2827},[253],{"categories":2829},[295],{"categories":2831},[],{"categories":2833},[],{"categories":2835},[306],{"categories":2837},[295],{"categories":2839},[],{"categories":2841},[253],{"categories":2843},[253],{"categories":2845},[253],{"categories":2847},[253],{"categories":2849},[253],{"categories":2851},[253],{"categories":2853},[253],{"categories":2855},[253],{"categories":2857},[253],{"categories":2859},[303],{"categories":2861},[253,306],{"categories":2863},[295],{"categories":2865},[295],{"categories":2867},[253],{"categories":2869},[309],{"categories":2871},[385],{"categories":2873},[253],{"categories":2875},[253],{"categories":2877},[],{"categories":2879},[],{"categories":2881},[253],{"categories":2883},[253],{"categories":2885},[],{"categories":2887},[306],{"categories":2889},[306],{"categories":2891},[340],{"categories":2893},[253],{"categories":2895},[340],{"categories":2897},[253],{"categories":2899},[253],{"categories":2901},[],{"categories":2903},[253],{"categories":2905},[],{"categories":2907},[],{"categories":2909},[253],{"categories":2911},[],{"categories":2913},[],{"categories":2915},[295],{"categories":2917},[],{"categories":2919},[253],{"categories":2921},[253],{"categories":2923},[253],{"categories":2925},[],{"categories":2927},[253],{"categories":2929},[295],{"categories":2931},[737],{"categories":2933},[300],{"categories":2935},[253],{"categories":2937},[],{"categories":2939},[300],{"categories":2941},[253],{"categories":2943},[],{"categories":2945},[253],{"categories":2947},[],{"categories":2949},[300],{"categories":2951},[],{"categories":2953},[],{"categories":2955},[300],{"categories":2957},[300],{"categories":2959},[300],{"categories":2961},[253],{"categories":2963},[],{"categories":2965},[300],{"categories":2967},[300],{"categories":2969},[],{"categories":2971},[],{"categories":2973},[300],{"categories":2975},[253],{"categories":2977},[295],{"categories":2979},[737],{"categories":2981},[303],{"categories":2983},[],{"categories":2985},[306],{"categories":2987},[253],{"categories":2989},[253],{"categories":2991},[290],{"categories":2993},[295],{"categories":2995},[295],{"categories":2997},[295],{"categories":2999},[295],{"categories":3001},[],{"categories":3003},[300],{"categories":3005},[300],{"categories":3007},[300],{"categories":3009},[300],{"categories":3011},[340],{"categories":3013},[253],{"categories":3015},[290],{"categories":3017},[],{"categories":3019},[340],{"categories":3021},[300],{"categories":3023},[306],{"categories":3025},[306],{"categories":3027},[306],{"categories":3029},[306],{"categories":3031},[306],{"categories":3033},[306],{"categories":3035},[253,290],{"categories":3037},[300],{"categories":3039},[290],{"categories":3041},[295],{"categories":3043},[295],{"categories":3045},[340],{"categories":3047},[],{"categories":3049},[],{"categories":3051},[303],{"categories":3053},[],{"categories":3055},[253],{"categories":3057},[303],{"categories":3059},[253],{"categories":3061},[309],{"categories":3063},[300],{"categories":3065},[290],{"categories":3067},[300],{"categories":3069},[309],{"categories":3071},[340],{"categories":3073},[300],{"categories":3075},[],{"categories":3077},[340],{"categories":3079},[],{"categories":3081},[],{"categories":3083},[300],{"categories":3085},[300],{"categories":3087},[300],{"categories":3089},[253],{"categories":3091},[253],{"categories":3093},[253],{"categories":3095},[253],{"categories":3097},[253],{"categories":3099},[],{"categories":3101},[650],{"categories":3103},[253],{"categories":3105},[],{"categories":3107},[],{"categories":3109},[],{"categories":3111},[340],{"categories":3113},[],{"categories":3115},[253],{"categories":3117},[],{"categories":3119},[295],{"categories":3121},[253],{"categories":3123},[295],{"categories":3125},[253],{"categories":3127},[300],{"categories":3129},[],{"categories":3131},[253],{"categories":3133},[253],{"categories":3135},[],{"categories":3137},[385],{"categories":3139},[385],{"categories":3141},[309],{"categories":3143},[306],{"categories":3145},[],{"categories":3147},[253],{"categories":3149},[300],{"categories":3151},[],{"categories":3153},[],{"categories":3155},[253],{"categories":3157},[309],{"categories":3159},[300],{"categories":3161},[290],{"categories":3163},[340,309],{"categories":3165},[309],{"categories":3167},[253],{"categories":3169},[300],{"categories":3171},[],{"categories":3173},[],{"categories":3175},[],{"categories":3177},[],{"categories":3179},[],{"categories":3181},[],{"categories":3183},[253],{"categories":3185},[],{"categories":3187},[],{"categories":3189},[253],{"categories":3191},[],{"categories":3193},[],{"categories":3195},[],{"categories":3197},[253],{"categories":3199},[295],{"categories":3201},[],{"categories":3203},[],{"categories":3205},[],{"categories":3207},[253],{"categories":3209},[],{"categories":3211},[253],{"categories":3213},[253],{"categories":3215},[],{"categories":3217},[253],{"categories":3219},[309],{"categories":3221},[],{"categories":3223},[340],{"categories":3225},[340],{"categories":3227},[],{"categories":3229},[303],{"categories":3231},[],{"categories":3233},[],{"categories":3235},[],{"categories":3237},[306],{"categories":3239},[295],{"categories":3241},[300],{"categories":3243},[253],{"categories":3245},[290],{"categories":3247},[253],{"categories":3249},[],{"categories":3251},[],{"categories":3253},[290],{"categories":3255},[303],{"categories":3257},[300],{"categories":3259},[],{"categories":3261},[650],{"categories":3263},[],{"categories":3265},[303],{"categories":3267},[253],{"categories":3269},[253],{"categories":3271},[303],{"categories":3273},[253],{"categories":3275},[306],{"categories":3277},[300],{"categories":3279},[253],{"categories":3281},[300],{"categories":3283},[253],{"categories":3285},[300],{"categories":3287},[340],{"categories":3289},[340],{"categories":3291},[306],{"categories":3293},[],{"categories":3295},[253],{"categories":3297},[253],{"categories":3299},[303],{"categories":3301},[737],{"categories":3303},[340],{"categories":3305},[295],{"categories":3307},[253],{"categories":3309},[295],{"categories":3311},[253],{"categories":3313},[253],{"categories":3315},[],{"categories":3317},[253],{"categories":3319},[],{"categories":3321},[253],{"categories":3323},[303],{"categories":3325},[253],{"categories":3327},[253],{"categories":3329},[253],{"categories":3331},[],{"categories":3333},[253],{"categories":3335},[253],{"categories":3337},[737],{"categories":3339},[],{"categories":3341},[295],{"categories":3343},[650],{"categories":3345},[309],{"categories":3347},[],{"categories":3349},[385],{"categories":3351},[],{"categories":3353},[],{"categories":3355},[295],{"categories":3357},[253],{"categories":3359},[],{"categories":3361},[253],{"categories":3363},[253],{"categories":3365},[300],{"categories":3367},[253],{"categories":3369},[295],{"categories":3371},[295],{"categories":3373},[306],{"categories":3375},[306],{"categories":3377},[306],{"categories":3379},[253],{"categories":3381},[385],{"categories":3383},[295],{"categories":3385},[340],{"categories":3387},[],{"categories":3389},[306],{"categories":3391},[306],{"categories":3393},[650],{"categories":3395},[306],{"categories":3397},[306],{"categories":3399},[300],{"categories":3401},[295],{"categories":3403},[650],{"categories":3405},[253],{"categories":3407},[253],{"categories":3409},[253],{"categories":3411},[253],{"categories":3413},[],{"categories":3415},[300],{"categories":3417},[253],{"categories":3419},[306],{"categories":3421},[],{"categories":3423},[],{"categories":3425},[295],{"categories":3427},[],{"categories":3429},[300],{"categories":3431},[300],{"categories":3433},[300],{"categories":3435},[300],{"categories":3437},[300],{"categories":3439},[300],{"categories":3441},[300],{"categories":3443},[300],{"categories":3445},[],{"categories":3447},[],{"categories":3449},[253],{"categories":3451},[],{"categories":3453},[300],{"categories":3455},[340],{"categories":3457},[340],{"categories":3459},[385],{"categories":3461},[290],{"categories":3463},[],{"categories":3465},[],{"categories":3467},[],{"categories":3469},[306],{"categories":3471},[253],{"categories":3473},[],{"categories":3475},[290],{"categories":3477},[290],{"categories":3479},[306],{"categories":3481},[340],{"categories":3483},[385],{"categories":3485},[306],{"categories":3487},[306],{"categories":3489},[],{"categories":3491},[300],{"categories":3493},[290],{"categories":3495},[290],{"categories":3497},[253],{"categories":3499},[300],{"categories":3501},[309],{"categories":3503},[306],{"categories":3505},[],{"categories":3507},[303],{"categories":3509},[385],{"categories":3511},[295],{"categories":3513},[295],{"categories":3515},[295],{"categories":3517},[650],{"categories":3519},[],{"categories":3521},[300],{"categories":3523},[],{"categories":3525},[300],{"categories":3527},[300],{"categories":3529},[253],{"categories":3531},[253],{"categories":3533},[309],{"categories":3535},[300],{"categories":3537},[309],{"categories":3539},[],{"categories":3541},[300],{"categories":3543},[306],{"categories":3545},[306],{"categories":3547},[306],{"categories":3549},[253],{"categories":3551},[300],{"categories":3553},[253],{"categories":3555},[290],{"categories":3557},[295],{"categories":3559},[306],{"categories":3561},[295],{"categories":3563},[253],{"categories":3565},[],{"categories":3567},[295],{"categories":3569},[300],{"categories":3571},[295],{"categories":3573},[295],{"categories":3575},[295],{"categories":3577},[295],{"categories":3579},[],{"categories":3581},[],{"categories":3583},[295],{"categories":3585},[295],{"categories":3587},[],{"categories":3589},[295],{"categories":3591},[295],{"categories":3593},[253],{"categories":3595},[253],{"categories":3597},[295],{"categories":3599},[295],{"categories":3601},[253],{"categories":3603},[],{"categories":3605},[253],{"categories":3607},[300],{"categories":3609},[253],{"categories":3611},[253],{"categories":3613},[],{"categories":3615},[253],{"categories":3617},[253],{"categories":3619},[253],{"categories":3621},[295],{"categories":3623},[],{"categories":3625},[],{"categories":3627},[],{"categories":3629},[],{"categories":3631},[253],{"categories":3633},[253],{"categories":3635},[],{"categories":3637},[303],{"categories":3639},[295],{"categories":3641},[],{"categories":3643},[],{"categories":3645},[],{"categories":3647},[],{"categories":3649},[],{"categories":3651},[253],{"categories":3653},[],{"categories":3655},[],{"categories":3657},[253],{"categories":3659},[],{"categories":3661},[300],{"categories":3663},[300],{"categories":3665},[300],{"categories":3667},[290],{"categories":3669},[],{"categories":3671},[303],{"categories":3673},[309],{"categories":3675},[309],{"categories":3677},[650],{"categories":3679},[295],{"categories":3681},[],{"categories":3683},[253],{"categories":3685},[253],{"categories":3687},[290],{"categories":3689},[],{"categories":3691},[290],{"categories":3693},[],{"categories":3695},[],{"categories":3697},[],{"categories":3699},[309],{"categories":3701},[300],{"categories":3703},[300],{"categories":3705},[300],{"categories":3707},[300],{"categories":3709},[300],{"categories":3711},[],{"categories":3713},[295],{"categories":3715},[253],{"categories":3717},[253],{"categories":3719},[253],{"categories":3721},[],{"categories":3723},[290],{"categories":3725},[],{"categories":3727},[306],{"categories":3729},[385],{"categories":3731},[306],{"categories":3733},[],{"categories":3735},[],{"categories":3737},[253],{"categories":3739},[300],{"categories":3741},[],{"categories":3743},[253],{"categories":3745},[253],{"categories":3747},[253],{"categories":3749},[300],{"categories":3751},[300],{"categories":3753},[253],{"categories":3755},[385],{"categories":3757},[300],{"categories":3759},[],{"categories":3761},[253],{"categories":3763},[],{"categories":3765},[737],{"categories":3767},[309],{"categories":3769},[385],{"categories":3771},[309],{"categories":3773},[650],{"categories":3775},[253],{"categories":3777},[309],{"categories":3779},[295],{"categories":3781},[650],{"categories":3783},[309],{"categories":3785},[306],{"categories":3787},[306],{"categories":3789},[],{"categories":3791},[309],{"categories":3793},[],{"categories":3795},[340],{"categories":3797},[309],{"categories":3799},[],{"categories":3801},[385],{"categories":3803},[385],{"categories":3805},[737],{"categories":3807},[],{"categories":3809},[253],{"categories":3811},[309],{"categories":3813},[650],{"categories":3815},[300],{"categories":3817},[300],{"categories":3819},[385],{"categories":3821},[253],{"categories":3823},[340],{"categories":3825},[253],{"categories":3827},[],{"categories":3829},[],{"categories":3831},[],{"categories":3833},[303],{"categories":3835},[253],{"categories":3837},[306],{"categories":3839},[309],{"categories":3841},[309],{"categories":3843},[253],{"categories":3845},[303],{"categories":3847},[340],{"categories":3849},[253],{"categories":3851},[309],{"categories":3853},[253],{"categories":3855},[309],{"categories":3857},[340],{"categories":3859},[340],{"categories":3861},[300],{"categories":3863},[340],{"categories":3865},[309],{"categories":3867},[290],{"categories":3869},[309],{"categories":3871},[309],{"categories":3873},[309],{"categories":3875},[309],{"categories":3877},[],{"categories":3879},[295],{"categories":3881},[],{"categories":3883},[385],{"categories":3885},[253],{"categories":3887},[253],{"categories":3889},[],{"categories":3891},[],{"categories":3893},[],{"categories":3895},[253],{"categories":3897},[295],{"categories":3899},[253],{"categories":3901},[253],{"categories":3903},[],{"categories":3905},[253],{"categories":3907},[306],{"categories":3909},[253],{"categories":3911},[253],{"categories":3913},[253],{"categories":3915},[],{"categories":3917},[],{"categories":3919},[],{"categories":3921},[650],{"categories":3923},[650],{"categories":3925},[290],{"categories":3927},[300],{"categories":3929},[290,303],{"categories":3931},[253],{"categories":3933},[295],{"categories":3935},[],{"categories":3937},[306],{"categories":3939},[385],{"categories":3941},[253],{"categories":3943},[309],{"categories":3945},[253],{"categories":3947},[],{"categories":3949},[385],{"categories":3951},[650],{"categories":3953},[300],{"categories":3955},[290],{"categories":3957},[650],{"categories":3959},[300],{"categories":3961},[340],{"categories":3963},[300],{"categories":3965},[340],{"categories":3967},[253],{"categories":3969},[340],{"categories":3971},[340],{"categories":3973},[309],{"categories":3975},[385],{"categories":3977},[253],{"categories":3979},[303],{"categories":3981},[],{"categories":3983},[253],{"categories":3985},[306],{"categories":3987},[385],{"categories":3989},[290],{"categories":3991},[253],{"categories":3993},[385],{"categories":3995},[340],{"categories":3997},[253],{"categories":3999},[253],{"categories":4001},[385],{"categories":4003},[253],{"categories":4005},[340],{"categories":4007},[253],{"categories":4009},[],{"categories":4011},[253],{"categories":4013},[253],{"categories":4015},[253],{"categories":4017},[253],{"categories":4019},[],{"categories":4021},[300],{"categories":4023},[650],{"categories":4025},[],{"categories":4027},[],{"categories":4029},[253],{"categories":4031},[290],{"categories":4033},[303],{"categories":4035},[290],{"categories":4037},[290],{"categories":4039},[300],{"categories":4041},[],{"categories":4043},[253],{"categories":4045},[295],{"categories":4047},[253],{"categories":4049},[253],{"categories":4051},[],{"categories":4053},[300],{"categories":4055},[295],{"categories":4057},[253,650],{"categories":4059},[300,650],{"categories":4061},[650],{"categories":4063},[253],{"categories":4065},[300],{"categories":4067},[300],{"categories":4069},[309],{"categories":4071},[309],{"categories":4073},[309],{"categories":4075},[253],{"categories":4077},[306],{"categories":4079},[300],{"categories":4081},[],{"categories":4083},[650],{"categories":4085},[],{"categories":4087},[650],{"categories":4089},[650],{"categories":4091},[290],{"categories":4093},[300],{"categories":4095},[],{"categories":4097},[650],{"categories":4099},[253],{"categories":4101},[295],{"categories":4103},[253],{"categories":4105},[306],{"categories":4107},[309],{"categories":4109},[309],{"categories":4111},[309],{"categories":4113},[650],{"categories":4115},[],{"categories":4117},[],{"categories":4119},[],{"categories":4121},[253],{"categories":4123},[309],{"categories":4125},[253],{"categories":4127},[309],{"categories":4129},[650],{"categories":4131},[650],{"categories":4133},[253],{"categories":4135},[300],{"categories":4137},[],{"categories":4139},[253],{"categories":4141},[253],{"categories":4143},[253],{"categories":4145},[],{"categories":4147},[],{"categories":4149},[650],{"categories":4151},[650],{"categories":4153},[253,650],{"categories":4155},[300],{"categories":4157},[300],{"categories":4159},[300],{"categories":4161},[300],{"categories":4163},[300],{"categories":4165},[300],{"categories":4167},[],{"categories":4169},[309],{"categories":4171},[253],{"categories":4173},[309],{"categories":4175},[303],{"categories":4177},[253],{"categories":4179},[737],{"categories":4181},[737],{"categories":4183},[300],{"categories":4185},[309],{"categories":4187},[],{"categories":4189},[300],{"categories":4191},[253],{"categories":4193},[],{"categories":4195},[306],{"categories":4197},[],{"categories":4199},[253],{"categories":4201},[300],{"categories":4203},[295],{"categories":4205},[253],{"categories":4207},[],{"categories":4209},[],{"categories":4211},[306],{"categories":4213},[306],{"categories":4215},[340],{"categories":4217},[306],{"categories":4219},[300],{"categories":4221},[],{"categories":4223},[300],{"categories":4225},[295],{"categories":4227},[253],{"categories":4229},[253],{"categories":4231},[],{"categories":4233},[253],{"categories":4235},[340],{"categories":4237},[253],{"categories":4239},[],{"categories":4241},[385],{"categories":4243},[309],{"categories":4245},[309],{"categories":4247},[290],{"categories":4249},[290],{"categories":4251},[290],{"categories":4253},[300],{"categories":4255},[290],{"categories":4257},[300],{"categories":4259},[650],{"categories":4261},[737],{"categories":4263},[295],{"categories":4265},[295],{"categories":4267},[295],{"categories":4269},[650],{"categories":4271},[295,290],{"categories":4273},[385],{"categories":4275},[300],{"categories":4277},[],{"categories":4279},[253],{"categories":4281},[],{"categories":4283},[309],{"categories":4285},[385],{"categories":4287},[306],{"categories":4289},[309],{"categories":4291},[340],{"categories":4293},[],{"categories":4295},[300],{"categories":4297},[],{"categories":4299},[737],{"categories":4301},[],{"categories":4303},[306],{"categories":4305},[306],{"categories":4307},[385],{"categories":4309},[],{"categories":4311},[253],{"categories":4313},[385],{"categories":4315},[],{"categories":4317},[253],{"categories":4319},[253],{"categories":4321},[],{"categories":4323},[340],{"categories":4325},[253],{"categories":4327},[],{"categories":4329},[253],{"categories":4331},[],{"categories":4333},[],{"categories":4335},[300],{"categories":4337},[300],{"categories":4339},[],{"categories":4341},[309],{"categories":4343},[309],{"categories":4345},[309],{"categories":4347},[253,300],{"categories":4349},[300],{"categories":4351},[300],{"categories":4353},[300],{"categories":4355},[385],{"categories":4357},[385],{"categories":4359},[],{"categories":4361},[295],{"categories":4363},[253],{"categories":4365},[385],{"categories":4367},[385],{"categories":4369},[295],{"categories":4371},[290],{"categories":4373},[300],{"categories":4375},[309],{"categories":4377},[253],{"categories":4379},[253],{"categories":4381},[300],{"categories":4383},[309],{"categories":4385},[300],{"categories":4387},[253],{"categories":4389},[303],{"categories":4391},[],{"categories":4393},[253],{"categories":4395},[],{"categories":4397},[253],{"categories":4399},[253],{"categories":4401},[309],{"categories":4403},[],{"categories":4405},[385],{"categories":4407},[253],{"categories":4409},[300],{"categories":4411},[300],{"categories":4413},[309],{"categories":4415},[340],{"categories":4417},[340],{"categories":4419},[295],{"categories":4421},[253],{"categories":4423},[300],{"categories":4425},[],{"categories":4427},[300],{"categories":4429},[253],{"categories":4431},[295],{"categories":4433},[253],{"categories":4435},[253],{"categories":4437},[253],{"categories":4439},[300],{"categories":4441},[385],{"categories":4443},[253],{"categories":4445},[306],{"categories":4447},[253],{"categories":4449},[253],{"categories":4451},[253],{"categories":4453},[253],{"categories":4455},[],{"categories":4457},[253],{"categories":4459},[385],{"categories":4461},[306],{"categories":4463},[253],{"categories":4465},[306],{"categories":4467},[],{"categories":4469},[],{"categories":4471},[],{"categories":4473},[253],{"categories":4475},[],{"categories":4477},[],{"categories":4479},[],{"categories":4481},[],{"categories":4483},[300],{"categories":4485},[340],{"categories":4487},[300],{"categories":4489},[300],{"categories":4491},[309],{"categories":4493},[290],{"categories":4495},[253],{"categories":4497},[253],{"categories":4499},[253],{"categories":4501},[290],{"categories":4503},[340],{"categories":4505},[],{"categories":4507},[385],{"categories":4509},[303],{"categories":4511},[253],{"categories":4513},[306],{"categories":4515},[340],{"categories":4517},[340],{"categories":4519},[737],{"categories":4521},[300],{"categories":4523},[253],{"categories":4525},[253],{"categories":4527},[340],{"categories":4529},[253],{"categories":4531},[],{"categories":4533},[],{"categories":4535},[650],{"categories":4537},[306],{"categories":4539},[340],{"categories":4541},[253],{"categories":4543},[295],{"categories":4545},[340],{"categories":4547},[290],{"categories":4549},[300],{"categories":4551},[300],{"categories":4553},[295],{"categories":4555},[253],{"categories":4557},[],{"categories":4559},[],{"categories":4561},[],{"categories":4563},[253],{"categories":4565},[],{"categories":4567},[295],{"categories":4569},[],{"categories":4571},[253],{"categories":4573},[],{"categories":4575},[295],{"categories":4577},[300],{"categories":4579},[253],{"categories":4581},[650],{"categories":4583},[253],{"categories":4585},[340],{"categories":4587},[253],{"categories":4589},[340],{"categories":4591},[340],{"categories":4593},[],{"categories":4595},[],{"categories":4597},[340],{"categories":4599},[340],{"categories":4601},[340],{"categories":4603},[],{"categories":4605},[340],{"categories":4607},[300],{"categories":4609},[300],{"categories":4611},[],{"categories":4613},[253],{"categories":4615},[303],{"categories":4617},[385],{"categories":4619},[253],{"categories":4621},[],{"categories":4623},[340],{"categories":4625},[253],{"categories":4627},[737],{"categories":4629},[340],{"categories":4631},[340],{"categories":4633},[303],{"categories":4635},[309],{"categories":4637},[309],{"categories":4639},[],{"categories":4641},[309],{"categories":4643},[253],{"categories":4645},[],{"categories":4647},[],{"categories":4649},[300],{"categories":4651},[],{"categories":4653},[300],{"categories":4655},[300],{"categories":4657},[295],{"categories":4659},[253],{"categories":4661},[295],{"categories":4663},[340],{"categories":4665},[295],{"categories":4667},[309],{"categories":4669},[309],{"categories":4671},[309],{"categories":4673},[295],{"categories":4675},[253],{"categories":4677},[300],{"categories":4679},[650],{"categories":4681},[290],{"categories":4683},[650],{"categories":4685},[650],{"categories":4687},[309],{"categories":4689},[650],{"categories":4691},[650],[4693,4792,5178,5288],{"id":4694,"title":4695,"ai":4696,"body":4701,"categories":4778,"created_at":254,"date_modified":254,"description":46,"extension":255,"faq":254,"featured":256,"kicker_label":254,"meta":4779,"navigation":68,"path":4780,"published_at":4781,"question":254,"scraped_at":254,"seo":4782,"sitemap":4783,"source_id":4784,"source_name":4785,"source_type":277,"source_url":4786,"stem":4787,"tags":4788,"thumbnail_url":254,"tldr":4789,"tweet":254,"unknown_tags":4790,"__hash__":4791},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Fllm-inference-fast-prefill-slow-decode-summary.md","LLM Inference: Fast Prefill, Slow Decode",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":4697,"output_tokens":4698,"processing_time_ms":4699,"cost_usd":4700},8881,1549,17518,0.00208375,{"type":14,"value":4702,"toc":4772},[4703,4707,4718,4725,4729,4732,4735,4739,4742,4745,4749],[17,4704,4706],{"id":4705},"core-phases-of-llm-inference","Core Phases of LLM Inference",[22,4708,4709,4710,4713,4714,4717],{},"LLM inference divides into two distinct stages: ",[202,4711,4712],{},"prefill"," (processing the input prompt) and ",[202,4715,4716],{},"decode"," (generating output tokens). Prefill runs all input tokens in parallel on the GPU, achieving 0.55-2.98 ms per token (e.g., 219 tokens in ~120-167 ms, or 1378 tokens\u002Fsec). Decode processes one token at a time sequentially, taking ~38-42 ms per token (e.g., 199 tokens in ~7800-8400 ms, or 23-25 tokens\u002Fsec). This explains why prompts process 5-50x faster per token than generation, even at equal lengths—parallelism in prefill fully utilizes GPU compute, while decode cannot.",[22,4719,4720,4721,4724],{},"Using Phi-3 Mini (3.8B parameters, FP16 weights, 4k context) on a T4 GPU (16GB VRAM, all layers offloaded via ",[48,4722,4723],{},"n_gpu_layers=-1","), load time is consistently 677 ms. Resetting the model each run avoids KV cache interference for clean measurements.",[17,4726,4728],{"id":4727},"prompt-length-slows-generation-via-kv-cache-overhead","Prompt Length Slows Generation via KV Cache Overhead",[22,4730,4731],{},"Larger prompts increase total prefill time linearly (e.g., 3567 tokens: 2689 ms total, 0.75 ms\u002Ftoken) but hit peak efficiency around 400 tokens (0.57 ms\u002Ftoken at 404 tokens, up to 1309 tokens\u002Fsec). Shorter prompts (\u003C111 tokens) underutilize GPU, with per-token time dropping as batch size grows to ~400 before slightly rising.",[22,4733,4734],{},"Critically, longer prompts tax decode: fixed 199 output tokens take 7.05s (111 input, 28 tokens\u002Fsec) to 9.93s (3567 input, 20 tokens\u002Fsec). This ~40% slowdown stems from larger KV cache updates during sequential generation, proving input context directly impacts output speed despite identical generation length.",[17,4736,4738],{"id":4737},"output-length-drives-linear-costs-minimal-per-token-variance","Output Length Drives Linear Costs, Minimal Per-Token Variance",[22,4740,4741],{},"Fixed minimal prompt yields linear decode scaling: 50 tokens ~1.6s total, 1500 tokens ~50s total. Per-token time stays stable at 33-36 ms (e.g., 32.91 ms at 50 tokens to 35.84 ms at 1500, +8.9%), with minor degradation from growing KV cache. Multiple runs (10-20) confirm convergence to 40-42 ms\u002Ftoken, dismissing initial variances from GPU warmup or noise—always average repeats for reliability.",[22,4743,4744],{},"Prefill remains constant regardless of output size (e.g., ~90 ms for 111-token prompt across all tests), isolating it from generation.",[17,4746,4748],{"id":4747},"optimization-insights-from-phase-trade-offs","Optimization Insights from Phase Trade-offs",[22,4750,4751,4752,4755,4756,4759,4760,4763,4764,4767,4768,4771],{},"To minimize latency, keep prompts concise yet batch-sized for GPU saturation (~400 tokens). Long contexts incur 'tax' on both phases: prefill grows linearly, decode slows via cache. Generation dominates time for longer outputs (e.g., 7571 ms decode vs 48 ms prefill in first test). Use tools like ",[48,4753,4754],{},"llama_cpp"," for verbose perf logs (",[48,4757,4758],{},"llama_perf_context_print",") to profile: track ",[48,4761,4762],{},"prompt eval time",", ",[48,4765,4766],{},"eval time",", tokens\u002Fsec, and ",[48,4769,4770],{},"graphs reused"," (KV cache hits). These mechanics enable better model selection, quantization, and prompt engineering for production AI pipelines.",{"title":46,"searchDepth":59,"depth":59,"links":4773},[4774,4775,4776,4777],{"id":4705,"depth":59,"text":4706},{"id":4727,"depth":59,"text":4728},{"id":4737,"depth":59,"text":4738},{"id":4747,"depth":59,"text":4748},[],{},"\u002Fsummaries\u002Fllm-inference-fast-prefill-slow-decode-summary","2026-04-08 21:21:18",{"title":4695,"description":46},{"loc":4780},"7aecdbcfe660bdfe","Level Up Coding","https:\u002F\u002Funknown","summaries\u002Fllm-inference-fast-prefill-slow-decode-summary",[281,45],"LLM generation splits into parallel prefill (prompt processing at ~0.5-3 ms\u002Ftoken) and sequential decode (output at ~40 ms\u002Ftoken), making prompts up to 50x faster per token than generation.",[],"LwqCWPE2cp6VEIreznjpNk02gzr9acpc2Gu9jQuMx8A",{"id":4793,"title":4794,"ai":4795,"body":4800,"categories":5143,"created_at":254,"date_modified":254,"description":46,"extension":255,"faq":254,"featured":256,"kicker_label":254,"meta":5144,"navigation":68,"path":5164,"published_at":5165,"question":254,"scraped_at":5166,"seo":5167,"sitemap":5168,"source_id":5169,"source_name":5170,"source_type":277,"source_url":5171,"stem":5172,"tags":5173,"thumbnail_url":254,"tldr":5175,"tweet":254,"unknown_tags":5176,"__hash__":5177},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Ftrain-gpt-2-llm-from-scratch-on-laptop-summary.md","Train GPT-2 LLM from Scratch on Laptop",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":4796,"output_tokens":4797,"processing_time_ms":4798,"cost_usd":4799},8437,3044,42622,0.0031869,{"type":14,"value":4801,"toc":5135},[4802,4806,4809,4812,4818,4829,4833,4836,4839,4880,4883,4888,4891,4894,4898,4901,4904,4943,4946,4970,4973,5008,5011,5016,5019,5023,5026,5028,5053,5056,5061,5064,5070,5074,5077,5080,5091,5094,5099,5103],[17,4803,4805],{"id":4804},"why-local-llm-training-reveals-core-mechanics","Why Local LLM Training Reveals Core Mechanics",[22,4807,4808],{},"Training an LLM from scratch locally demystifies the process, showing 80% of what big labs do without cloud-scale resources. Angelos Perivolaropoulos, who leads speech-to-text at ElevenLabs (creators of top benchmark model Scribe v2), emphasizes starting with basics: no pre-trained weights, pure PyTorch. This tiny GPT-2 variant (vocab=65 chars, context=256, 6 layers) trains fast on laptops, exposing tokenizer choices, architecture blocks, and training loops as the real differentiators between models like GPT-3 vs. GPT-4.",[22,4810,4811],{},"Key principle: Focus on bi-grams (token pairs). Small vocab (65) yields ~4k bi-grams, coverable by Shakespeare dataset; larger (50k like GPT-2) needs trillions of tokens to converge. \"If you have a model with 200,000 tokens, you need 200,000 tokens squared at least data to train from scratch.\"",[4813,4814,4815],"blockquote",{},[22,4816,4817],{},"\"We're going to work purely on torch... this is like 80% of the way there to create a model from scratch.\"",[22,4819,4820,4821,4824,4825,4828],{},"Prerequisites: Python 3.12, 16GB RAM (scales down), MPS\u002FCUDA\u002FCPU support. Use UV for env: ",[48,4822,4823],{},"uv sync",". Colab alternative: ",[48,4826,4827],{},"!pip install torch numpy datasets tiktoken",". Dataset: Shakespeare (tiny text corpus, downloadable via repo).",[17,4830,4832],{"id":4831},"tokenizer-character-level-for-tiny-models","Tokenizer: Character-Level for Tiny Models",[22,4834,4835],{},"Start here – LLMs process vectors, not text. Character-level tokenizer maps 65 chars (A-Z, a-z, punctuation, space, newline) to integers via simple dict\u002Fenumerate. Converts strings to int tensors; embedding layer maps to vectors (dim=384).",[22,4837,4838],{},"Steps:",[4840,4841,4842,4850,4867,4877],"ol",{},[4843,4844,4845,4846,4849],"li",{},"Load data: ",[48,4847,4848],{},"text = open('input.txt', 'r').read()"," (Shakespeare).",[4843,4851,4852,4853,4856,4857,4856,4860,4856,4863,4866],{},"Build vocab: ",[48,4854,4855],{},"chars = sorted(list(set(text)))","; ",[48,4858,4859],{},"stoi = {ch:i for i,ch in enumerate(chars)}",[48,4861,4862],{},"itos = {i:ch for i,ch in enumerate(chars)}",[48,4864,4865],{},"vocab_size = len(chars)",".",[4843,4868,4869,4870,4873,4874,4866],{},"Encode: ",[48,4871,4872],{},"def encode(s): return [stoi[c] for c in s]","; batch via ",[48,4875,4876],{},"torch.tensor",[4843,4878,4879],{},"Decode: Reverse for output.",[22,4881,4882],{},"Trade-off: Low vocab trains fast on small data but poor scaling – model struggles with long-range correlations (e.g., 'sky' + 'is' + 'bl' vs. semantic tokens). For code: Falls to chars for rare vars; BPE (train on data patterns like 'for', 'enumerate') better for prod but needs massive data.",[4813,4884,4885],{},[22,4886,4887],{},"\"Character level because it's much easier to train... 65*65 = 4,225 possible bi-grams... our dataset should include all bi-grams multiple times.\"",[22,4889,4890],{},"Common mistake: Using full GPT-2 vocab (50k) – embedding table alone ~19M params (3x model size), won't converge. Future-proof: Train BPE tokenizer on your corpus for real LLMs.",[22,4892,4893],{},"Quality check: Ensure all bi-grams covered; test encode\u002Fdecode round-trip.",[17,4895,4897],{"id":4896},"causal-transformer-stack-simple-blocks","Causal Transformer: Stack Simple Blocks",[22,4899,4900],{},"GPT-2 base: Decoder-only, causal self-attention. Don't need PhD-level math – implement blocks, learn why via experimentation.",[22,4902,4903],{},"Core blocks (per layer):",[4905,4906,4907,4917,4923,4933],"ul",{},[4843,4908,4909,4912,4913,4916],{},[202,4910,4911],{},"Multi-head self-attention",": Computes token relationships (QKV matrices). Causal mask prevents future peeking: ",[48,4914,4915],{},"mask = torch.tril(torch.ones(block_size, block_size))",". Heads (e.g., n_head=6) parallelize; concat + proj.",[4843,4918,4919,4922],{},[202,4920,4921],{},"MLP\u002FFeed-forward",": Processes attended features into logits.",[4843,4924,4925,4928,4929,4932],{},[202,4926,4927],{},"Residuals",": Add input to output (",[48,4930,4931],{},"x + sublayer(x)",") – gradients flow directly, stabilizes deep stacks.",[4843,4934,4935,4938,4939,4942],{},[202,4936,4937],{},"LayerNorm",": Normalizes activations pre-sublayer (",[48,4940,4941],{},"ln(x) * sublayer(ln(x)) + x","); prevents exploding\u002Fvanishing.",[22,4944,4945],{},"Model params:",[4905,4947,4948,4954,4959,4964],{},[4843,4949,4950,4953],{},[48,4951,4952],{},"n_embd=384"," (embed dim)",[4843,4955,4956],{},[48,4957,4958],{},"n_head=6",[4843,4960,4961],{},[48,4962,4963],{},"n_layer=6",[4843,4965,4966,4969],{},[48,4967,4968],{},"block_size=256"," (context)",[22,4971,4972],{},"Implementation skeleton (PyTorch nn.Module):",[4840,4974,4975,4981,4987,4994,5005],{},[4843,4976,4977,4978,4866],{},"Embed: ",[48,4979,4980],{},"self.tok_emb = nn.Embedding(vocab_size, n_embd)",[4843,4982,4983,4984,4866],{},"Pos embed: ",[48,4985,4986],{},"self.position_embedding_table = nn.Embedding(block_size, n_embd)",[4843,4988,4989,4990,4993],{},"Layers: Stack ",[48,4991,4992],{},"TransformerBlock"," (attention + MLP + norms).",[4843,4995,4996,4997,5000,5001,5004],{},"Final: ",[48,4998,4999],{},"ln_f = LayerNorm(n_embd)"," → ",[48,5002,5003],{},"lm_head = nn.Linear(n_embd, vocab_size)"," (no bias, tie to embed? Optional).",[4843,5006,5007],{},"Forward: Add pos embeds, loop layers, project logits.",[22,5009,5010],{},"Principle: Stack identical layers; residuals\u002Fnorms enable scaling depth. Big labs optimize attention for 1M+ context (e.g., avoid O(n²) blowup) but base works.",[4813,5012,5013],{},[22,5014,5015],{},"\"Attention is what makes transformers different... they can attend to previous tokens and understand relationships.\"",[22,5017,5018],{},"Mistake: No causal mask → cheats by seeing future. Test: Forward pass on sample, check shapes (batch, seq, vocab).",[17,5020,5022],{"id":5021},"training-loop-where-performance-wins","Training Loop: Where Performance Wins",[22,5024,5025],{},"Pre-training core: Next-token prediction (cross-entropy loss). Smarter loops separate GPT-3\u002F4 (e.g., Gemini 3 → 3.1 doubles benchmarks via tuning).",[22,5027,4838],{},[4840,5029,5030,5037,5040,5046],{},[4843,5031,5032,5033,5036],{},"Data: Split train\u002Fval; generate batches ",[48,5034,5035],{},"get_batch('train')"," → (B,T) ints.",[4843,5038,5039],{},"Optimize: AdamW, lr=1e-3 (warmup? Basic: constant).",[4843,5041,5042,5043,4866],{},"Loop: ",[48,5044,5045],{},"for i in range(max_iters): xb,yb = get_batch(); logits,p = model(xb); loss = F.cross_entropy(logits.view(-1,vocab_size), yb.view(-1)); optimizer.zero_grad(); loss.backward(); optimizer.step()",[4843,5047,5048,5049,5052],{},"Eval: Perplexity on val (",[48,5050,5051],{},"torch.exp(loss)",").",[22,5054,5055],{},"Batch size: 4-64 (RAM-limited); steps: 5k+ for convergence. Estimate iters: dataset_tokens \u002F (batch * block_size).",[4813,5057,5058],{},[22,5059,5060],{},"\"The training loop is generally the most important part... what you use with the same base model makes the big difference.\"",[22,5062,5063],{},"Trade-off: Small context (256) fast but forgets long deps; crank on bigger GPU.",[22,5065,5066,5067,4866],{},"Inference: Simple ",[48,5068,5069],{},"while True: generate next token via top-k\u002F1 sample",[17,5071,5073],{"id":5072},"hardware-trade-offs-and-extensions","Hardware Trade-offs and Extensions",[22,5075,5076],{},"Local constraints force smart choices: 16GB RAM → tiny model (millions params). Colab GPUs free for this scale.",[22,5078,5079],{},"Scaling path:",[4905,5081,5082,5085,5088],{},[4843,5083,5084],{},"Bigger data\u002FGPU: BPE tokenizer, 16k context.",[4843,5086,5087],{},"Week-long train: Proper LLM.",[4843,5089,5090],{},"Compete: Optimize loss faster.",[22,5092,5093],{},"No deep theory needed initially: \"I had no clue how transformers worked... you learn as you push through.\"",[4813,5095,5096],{},[22,5097,5098],{},"\"Transformers have been commoditized... optimizations on the base idea.\"",[17,5100,5102],{"id":5101},"key-takeaways","Key Takeaways",[4905,5104,5105,5108,5111,5114,5120,5123,5126,5129,5132],{},[4843,5106,5107],{},"Use character-level tokenizer (65 vocab) for tiny local LLMs; covers bi-grams with small data like Shakespeare.",[4843,5109,5110],{},"Implement causal transformer via 4 blocks: attention (masked), MLP, residual, LayerNorm – stack 6 layers.",[4843,5112,5113],{},"Training: Next-token CE loss, AdamW; monitor val perplexity; 5k iters suffices.",[4843,5115,5116,5117,5119],{},"Start with ",[48,5118,4823],{},"; test on Colab if no GPU\u002FRAM.",[4843,5121,5122],{},"Trade-off explicitly: Char tok fast\u002Fcheap but unscalable; BPE for prod needs data.",[4843,5124,5125],{},"Fork repo, beat baseline loss – extend to code tokenizer or longer context.",[4843,5127,5128],{},"Embeddings dominate small models; GPT-2 vocab would 3x size.",[4843,5130,5131],{},"Residuals\u002FLayerNorm stabilize; causal mask essential.",[4843,5133,5134],{},"Bi-grams rule data needs: vocab² minimum tokens.",{"title":46,"searchDepth":59,"depth":59,"links":5136},[5137,5138,5139,5140,5141,5142],{"id":4804,"depth":59,"text":4805},{"id":4831,"depth":59,"text":4832},{"id":4896,"depth":59,"text":4897},{"id":5021,"depth":59,"text":5022},{"id":5072,"depth":59,"text":5073},{"id":5101,"depth":59,"text":5102},[253],{"content_references":5145,"triage":5161},[5146,5151,5154,5156,5158],{"type":5147,"title":5148,"author":5149,"context":5150},"other","nanoGPT","Andrej Karpathy","mentioned",{"type":5152,"title":5153,"context":5150},"dataset","Shakespeare",{"type":260,"title":5155,"context":262},"UV",{"type":260,"title":5157,"context":5150},"tiktoken",{"type":260,"title":5159,"author":5160,"context":5150},"Scribe v2","ElevenLabs",{"relevance":78,"novelty":72,"quality":72,"actionability":78,"composite":5162,"reasoning":5163},4.55,"Category: AI & LLMs. This article provides a hands-on workshop for training a GPT-2 model from scratch, which directly addresses the audience's need for practical applications in AI engineering. It includes specific steps and code snippets for building a tokenizer and training loop, making it immediately actionable for developers.","\u002Fsummaries\u002Ftrain-gpt-2-llm-from-scratch-on-laptop-summary","2026-05-04 18:30:06","2026-05-05 16:04:36",{"title":4794,"description":46},{"loc":5164},"45eb198f2256f249","AI Engineer","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.youtube.com\u002Fwatch?v=UsB70Tf5zcE","summaries\u002Ftrain-gpt-2-llm-from-scratch-on-laptop-summary",[281,45,5174],"coding","Hands-on workshop: Build tokenizer, causal transformer, training loop in PyTorch to train tiny GPT-2 on Shakespeare locally (16GB RAM) or Colab – reveals core engineering without cloud.",[],"fnb1ky0ivyNYveL72mlCDxwOZtDjSONpf73eJF6eHgI",{"id":5179,"title":5180,"ai":5181,"body":5186,"categories":5267,"created_at":254,"date_modified":254,"description":46,"extension":255,"faq":254,"featured":256,"kicker_label":254,"meta":5268,"navigation":68,"path":5274,"published_at":5275,"question":254,"scraped_at":5276,"seo":5277,"sitemap":5278,"source_id":5279,"source_name":5280,"source_type":277,"source_url":5281,"stem":5282,"tags":5283,"thumbnail_url":254,"tldr":5285,"tweet":254,"unknown_tags":5286,"__hash__":5287},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Ffix-tokenization-drift-by-matching-sft-token-patte-summary.md","Fix Tokenization Drift by Matching SFT Token Patterns",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":5182,"output_tokens":5183,"processing_time_ms":5184,"cost_usd":5185},9688,1789,16407,0.0028096,{"type":14,"value":5187,"toc":5262},[5188,5192,5203,5206,5210,5213,5216,5220,5223,5249,5252],[17,5189,5191],{"id":5190},"leading-spaces-and-formatting-create-entirely-new-token-sequences","Leading Spaces and Formatting Create Entirely New Token Sequences",[22,5193,5194,5195,5198,5199,5202],{},"Tokenization drift occurs when subtle changes like adding a leading space alter token IDs and sequence lengths, pushing inputs outside the model's trained distribution. Using GPT-2 tokenizer (vocab size 50,257, same BPE as GPT-4\u002FLLaMA\u002FMistral), test pairs like \" classify\" vs \"classify\": space version gets single token ",[29,5196,5197],{},"36509",", no-space splits to ",[29,5200,5201],{},"4871, 1958",". All 7 tested words (classify, answer, positive, negative, sentiment, output, label) produce different IDs—deltas range from \u003C100 (low risk, e.g., label) to >500 (high risk, e.g., classify at 31,638 delta). This changes attention computation since sequence lengths differ, making \"apple\" and \" apple\" as distinct to the model as unrelated words.",[22,5204,5205],{},"SFT models learn specific structures (newlines, colons, prefixes). Deviations like removing newlines drop Jaccard overlap with canonical SFT template (\"Below is a customer review. Classify the sentiment.\\n\\nReview: {review}\\n\\nSentiment:\") to 80%; no leading space on \"Review\" to 85%; colon-to-dash to 70%; rewording instruction to 50%. Lower overlap signals higher OOD risk: >80% low risk, 60-80% medium, \u003C60% high, correlating to accuracy drops.",[17,5207,5209],{"id":5208},"jaccard-overlap-quantifies-ood-risk-from-prompt-variants","Jaccard Overlap Quantifies OOD Risk from Prompt Variants",[22,5211,5212],{},"Canonical SFT overlap is 100%. Variants show: no newlines 80% (medium risk), missing space 85% (low), dash instead of colon 70% (medium), reworded (\"Determine the sentiment... Answer:\") 50% (high). On sample \"The product exceeded all my expectations. Highly recommend!\", these shifts mean the model processes unfamiliar token space, leading to unpredictable outputs despite unchanged logic or data.",[22,5214,5215],{},"Visual deltas confirm: high-ID gaps (>500) for most words indicate severe drift. Thresholds guide safety—stay above 80% overlap to mimic training distribution, avoiding degradation without retraining.",[17,5217,5219],{"id":5218},"apo-loop-auto-selects-high-overlap-prompts-for-stable-performance","APO Loop Auto-Selects High-Overlap Prompts for Stable Performance",[22,5221,5222],{},"Implement Automated Prompt Optimization on 8-sample validation set (balanced positive\u002Fnegative\u002Fneutral reviews). Test 5 candidates:",[4905,5224,5225,5228,5231,5234,5246],{},[4843,5226,5227],{},"A (no formatting: \"Classify: {review} Answer:\");",[4843,5229,5230],{},"B (minimal: \"Review: {review}\\nSentiment:\");",[4843,5232,5233],{},"C (SFT-aligned: full template with newlines\u002Fcolons);",[4843,5235,5236,5237,5241,5242],{},"D (XML: \"",[5238,5239,5240],"review",{},"{review}","\\n",[5243,5244,5245],"sentiment",{},"\");",[4843,5247,5248],{},"E (full instruction: \"You are a sentiment classifier... Output...\").",[22,5250,5251],{},"Simulate accuracy: base 85%, scaled by overlap factor (0.5 + 0.5*Jaccard) minus OOD penalty (e.g., 0.18 for A, 0.02 for C), clipped 40-95%, plus noise. Results: A 38%, B 50%, C 88%, D 63%, E 75%. APO picks C (\"Variant C -- SFT-aligned\") at 88% accuracy—33% better than worst, proving closest SFT match wins.",[22,5253,5254,5255,5261],{},"In production, replace simulation with real model evals on validation data. Full code: ",[5256,5257,5258],"a",{"href":5258,"rel":5259},"https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002FMarktechpost\u002FAI-Agents-Projects-Tutorials\u002Fblob\u002Fmain\u002FNLP\u002FTokenization_Drift.ipynb",[5260],"nofollow",". This keeps prompts in-distribution, stabilizing performance across pipeline changes.",{"title":46,"searchDepth":59,"depth":59,"links":5263},[5264,5265,5266],{"id":5190,"depth":59,"text":5191},{"id":5208,"depth":59,"text":5209},{"id":5218,"depth":59,"text":5219},[253],{"content_references":5269,"triage":5272},[5270],{"type":5147,"title":5271,"url":5258,"context":5150},"Tokenization_Drift.ipynb",{"relevance":78,"novelty":72,"quality":72,"actionability":72,"composite":268,"reasoning":5273},"Category: AI & LLMs. The article provides a deep dive into tokenization drift, a critical issue for AI product builders, and offers actionable strategies like Jaccard token overlap to measure risk and Automated Prompt Optimization to enhance model performance. This directly addresses the audience's need for practical applications in AI integration.","\u002Fsummaries\u002Ffix-tokenization-drift-by-matching-sft-token-patte-summary","2026-05-03 07:06:45","2026-05-03 17:01:43",{"title":5180,"description":46},{"loc":5274},"68a7b0ecb194f703","MarkTechPost","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.marktechpost.com\u002F2026\u002F05\u002F03\u002Fwhat-is-tokenization-drift-and-how-to-fix-it\u002F","summaries\u002Ffix-tokenization-drift-by-matching-sft-token-patte-summary",[5284,281,45],"prompt-engineering","Minor formatting like spaces or newlines causes tokenization drift, shifting prompts out-of-distribution and dropping accuracy. Use Jaccard token overlap (>80% safe) to measure risk; Automated Prompt Optimization (APO) selects best templates, boosting simulated accuracy from 40-50% to 83%.",[],"czI9Iky0fO9jCRQG35lT6t_CZ32a4RGSamrwkoKWOPY",{"id":5289,"title":5290,"ai":5291,"body":5296,"categories":5351,"created_at":254,"date_modified":254,"description":46,"extension":255,"faq":254,"featured":256,"kicker_label":254,"meta":5352,"navigation":68,"path":5368,"published_at":5369,"question":254,"scraped_at":5370,"seo":5371,"sitemap":5372,"source_id":5373,"source_name":5280,"source_type":277,"source_url":5374,"stem":5375,"tags":5376,"thumbnail_url":254,"tldr":5378,"tweet":254,"unknown_tags":5379,"__hash__":5380},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Ftrl-code-guide-sft-to-grpo-llm-alignment-on-t4-gpu-summary.md","TRL Code Guide: SFT to GRPO LLM Alignment on T4 GPU",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":5292,"output_tokens":5293,"processing_time_ms":5294,"cost_usd":5295},9458,2615,35753,0.00269195,{"type":14,"value":5297,"toc":5345},[5298,5302,5309,5313,5323,5327,5333,5337],[17,5299,5301],{"id":5300},"lora-and-trl-setup-enables-post-training-on-limited-hardware","LoRA and TRL Setup Enables Post-Training on Limited Hardware",[22,5303,5304,5305,5308],{},"Use LoRA (r=8, alpha=16, dropout=0.05, targets=",[29,5306,5307],{},"'q_proj','k_proj','v_proj','o_proj'",") with TRL trainers to adapt Qwen\u002FQwen2.5-0.5B-Instruct on T4 GPU (16GB). Common args across stages: num_train_epochs=1, gradient_checkpointing=True, bf16 if supported else fp16, logging_steps=10, report_to=\"none\", save_strategy=\"no\". Install stack: torchao>=0.16, trl>=0.20, transformers>=4.45, peft>=0.13, bitsandbytes. Helpers like chat_generate apply chat template, generate with temp=0.7\u002Ftop_p=0.9. Cleanup VRAM with gc.collect() + torch.cuda.empty_cache() between stages to fit in Colab.",[17,5310,5312],{"id":5311},"sft-and-rm-build-imitation-and-reward-signals","SFT and RM Build Imitation and Reward Signals",[22,5314,5315,5316,5319,5320,5322],{},"For Supervised Fine-Tuning, load trl-lib\u002FCapybara (train",[29,5317,5318],{},":300","), use SFTConfig(per_device_train_batch_size=2, gradient_accumulation_steps=4, learning_rate=2e-4, max_length=768). Trainer imitates high-quality chat responses; post-train inference on \"Explain bias-variance tradeoff in two sentences\" yields coherent output. Reward Modeling on trl-lib\u002Fultrafeedback_binarized (train",[29,5321,5318],{},") uses RewardConfig(batch_size=2, accum_steps=2, lr=1e-4, max_length=512), LoRA task_type=\"SEQ_CLS\". Trains to score chosen vs. rejected pairs, producing a preference-based reward without explicit RL.",[17,5324,5326],{"id":5325},"dpo-skips-rm-for-direct-preference-alignment","DPO Skips RM for Direct Preference Alignment",[22,5328,5329,5330,5332],{},"DPOTrainer on same ultrafeedback_binarized",[29,5331,5318],{}," simplifies via implicit rewards: DPOConfig(batch_size=1, accum_steps=4, lr=5e-6, beta=0.1, max_length=512, max_prompt_length=256). Beta controls KL-divergence from reference policy, preventing mode collapse. Optimizes policy to prefer chosen over rejected responses directly, reducing steps vs. traditional RM+PPO.",[17,5334,5336],{"id":5335},"grpo-uses-custom-rewards-to-sharpen-reasoning","GRPO Uses Custom Rewards to Sharpen Reasoning",[22,5338,5339,5340,5344],{},"GRPOTrainer generates num_generations=4 completions per prompt (max_prompt_length=128, max_completion_length=96, max_steps=15), ranks via reward_funcs. Custom dataset: 200 synthetic math problems (e.g., \"Solve 17 + 28 =\", gold=eval). Rewards: correctness_reward (1.0 if last extracted number matches gold else 0), brevity_reward (max(0,1-len(c)\u002F200)",[5341,5342,5343],"em",{},"0.2). GRPOConfig(lr=1e-5, batch=2, accum=2). Inference on \"17+28?\", \"9","7?\", \"100-47?\" produces accurate, concise answers like final numbers, improving verifiable task performance over base.",{"title":46,"searchDepth":59,"depth":59,"links":5346},[5347,5348,5349,5350],{"id":5300,"depth":59,"text":5301},{"id":5311,"depth":59,"text":5312},{"id":5325,"depth":59,"text":5326},{"id":5335,"depth":59,"text":5336},[253],{"content_references":5353,"triage":5366},[5354,5357,5359,5361,5363],{"type":260,"title":5355,"url":5356,"context":5150},"TRL","https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002Fhuggingface\u002Ftrl",{"type":5152,"title":5358,"context":5150},"trl-lib\u002FCapybara",{"type":5152,"title":5360,"context":5150},"trl-lib\u002Fultrafeedback_binarized",{"type":260,"title":5362,"context":5150},"Qwen\u002FQwen2.5-0.5B-Instruct",{"type":5147,"title":5364,"url":5365,"context":262},"trl_llm_post_training_sft_dpo_grpo_marktechpost.py","https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002FMarktechpost\u002FAI-Agents-Projects-Tutorials\u002Fblob\u002Fmain\u002FLLM%20Projects\u002Ftrl_llm_post_training_sft_dpo_grpo_marktechpost.py",{"relevance":78,"novelty":72,"quality":72,"actionability":78,"composite":5162,"reasoning":5367},"Category: AI & LLMs. The article provides a detailed guide on using TRL and LoRA for LLM post-training, addressing practical applications for developers looking to implement AI features. It includes specific configurations and techniques that can be directly applied in production, making it highly actionable.","\u002Fsummaries\u002Ftrl-code-guide-sft-to-grpo-llm-alignment-on-t4-gpu-summary","2026-05-01 20:52:08","2026-05-03 17:01:49",{"title":5290,"description":46},{"loc":5368},"79f82c07ea7441fe","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.marktechpost.com\u002F2026\u002F05\u002F01\u002Fa-coding-guide-on-llm-post-training-with-trl-from-supervised-fine-tuning-to-dpo-and-grpo-reasoning\u002F","summaries\u002Ftrl-code-guide-sft-to-grpo-llm-alignment-on-t4-gpu-summary",[281,45,5377],"machine-learning","Train Qwen2.5-0.5B via SFT, RM, DPO, GRPO using TRL+LoRA on Colab T4: configs include r=8 LoRA, 300-sample datasets, epochs=1, small batches\u002Faccum for memory efficiency, custom math rewards boost reasoning.",[],"4miREre7IX2LguMbkA_nsqybys6v0iG-V2aT-eEsJ4g"]