[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":-1},["ShallowReactive",2],{"summary-16d0d1b82072a099-agentatlas-moving-beyond-outcome-only-llm-agent-ev-summary":3,"summaries-facets-categories":108,"summary-related-16d0d1b82072a099-agentatlas-moving-beyond-outcome-only-llm-agent-ev-summary":4125},{"id":4,"title":5,"ai":6,"body":13,"categories":74,"created_at":76,"date_modified":76,"description":68,"extension":77,"faq":76,"featured":78,"kicker_label":76,"meta":79,"navigation":91,"path":92,"published_at":93,"question":76,"scraped_at":93,"seo":94,"sitemap":95,"source_id":96,"source_name":97,"source_type":98,"source_url":84,"stem":99,"tags":100,"thumbnail_url":76,"tldr":105,"tweet":76,"unknown_tags":106,"__hash__":107},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002F16d0d1b82072a099-agentatlas-moving-beyond-outcome-only-llm-agent-ev-summary.md","AgentAtlas: Moving Beyond Outcome-Only LLM Agent Evaluation",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":9,"output_tokens":10,"processing_time_ms":11,"cost_usd":12},"openrouter","google\u002Fgemini-3.1-flash-lite",4094,558,3303,0.0018605,{"type":14,"value":15,"toc":67},"minimark",[16,21,30,34,37,41,44],[17,18,20],"h2",{"id":19},"the-problem-with-outcome-based-benchmarking","The Problem with Outcome-Based Benchmarking",[22,23,24,25,29],"p",{},"Current evaluation frameworks for LLM agents rely heavily on outcome-based leaderboards, which measure success rates on specific tasks. While useful for high-level performance tracking, these metrics fail to explain ",[26,27,28],"em",{},"why"," an agent succeeds or fails. They treat agents as black boxes, ignoring the intermediate reasoning steps, tool usage patterns, and error recovery processes that define robust agentic behavior. This \"success-only\" approach masks critical failure modes and makes it difficult for developers to debug or improve agent architectures.",[17,31,33],{"id":32},"agentatlas-a-process-oriented-evaluation-framework","AgentAtlas: A Process-Oriented Evaluation Framework",[22,35,36],{},"AgentAtlas proposes a shift toward process-oriented evaluation. Instead of focusing solely on the final output, the framework analyzes the trajectory of an agent's interactions. By mapping the agent's decision-making path, developers can identify where an agent deviates from optimal behavior, whether it gets stuck in repetitive loops, or if it relies on inefficient tool-calling sequences. This granular visibility allows for more targeted interventions, such as refining system prompts, adjusting tool definitions, or implementing better state management.",[17,38,40],{"id":39},"implications-for-agent-development","Implications for Agent Development",[22,42,43],{},"By moving beyond binary success metrics, AgentAtlas enables a more diagnostic approach to AI engineering. It encourages builders to treat agent performance as a function of the entire interaction lifecycle. This framework helps in:",[45,46,47,55,61],"ul",{},[48,49,50,54],"li",{},[51,52,53],"strong",{},"Identifying Failure Modes:"," Distinguishing between reasoning errors, tool-use failures, and environmental constraints.",[48,56,57,60],{},[51,58,59],{},"Optimizing Tool Usage:"," Analyzing whether an agent is using the right tools at the right time or if it is over-relying on specific, potentially expensive, or inaccurate tools.",[48,62,63,66],{},[51,64,65],{},"Improving Reliability:"," Providing the data necessary to build more predictable agents that handle edge cases gracefully rather than simply failing at the end of a task.",{"title":68,"searchDepth":69,"depth":69,"links":70},"",2,[71,72,73],{"id":19,"depth":69,"text":20},{"id":32,"depth":69,"text":33},{"id":39,"depth":69,"text":40},[75],"AI & LLMs",null,"md",false,{"content_references":80,"triage":86},[81],{"type":82,"title":83,"url":84,"context":85},"paper","AgentAtlas: Beyond Outcome Leaderboards for LLM Agents","https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2605.20530","reviewed",{"relevance":87,"novelty":88,"quality":88,"actionability":88,"composite":89,"reasoning":90},5,4,4.35,"Category: AI & LLMs. The article presents a new evaluation framework for LLM agents that addresses a critical pain point in AI engineering—understanding agent behavior beyond simple success metrics. It offers actionable insights for developers on how to refine agent performance through process-oriented analysis.",true,"\u002Fsummaries\u002F16d0d1b82072a099-agentatlas-moving-beyond-outcome-only-llm-agent-ev-summary","2026-05-22 07:00:19",{"title":5,"description":68},{"loc":92},"16d0d1b82072a099","arXiv cs.AI","article","summaries\u002F16d0d1b82072a099-agentatlas-moving-beyond-outcome-only-llm-agent-ev-summary",[101,102,103,104],"llm","agents","machine-learning","research","AgentAtlas shifts the focus of LLM agent evaluation from simple success\u002Ffailure leaderboards to granular, process-oriented analysis of agent behavior and decision-making patterns.",[],"8DuK-tzmeguR0kwsGtmfwlTrhWmyvb4sSufz40X78Gg",[109,112,115,117,120,123,125,127,129,131,133,135,138,140,142,144,146,148,150,152,154,156,158,160,162,164,167,170,172,174,177,179,181,184,186,188,190,192,194,196,198,200,202,204,206,209,211,213,215,217,219,221,223,225,227,229,231,233,235,237,239,241,243,245,247,249,251,253,255,257,259,261,263,265,267,269,271,273,275,277,279,281,283,285,287,289,291,293,295,297,299,301,303,305,307,309,311,313,315,317,319,321,323,325,327,329,331,333,335,337,339,341,343,345,347,349,351,353,355,357,359,361,363,365,367,369,371,373,375,377,379,381,383,385,387,389,391,393,395,397,399,401,403,405,407,409,411,413,415,417,419,421,423,425,427,429,431,433,435,437,439,441,443,445,447,449,451,453,455,457,459,461,463,465,467,469,471,473,475,477,479,481,483,485,487,489,491,493,495,497,499,501,503,505,507,509,511,513,515,517,519,521,523,525,527,529,531,533,535,537,539,541,543,545,547,549,551,553,555,557,559,561,563,565,567,569,571,573,575,577,579,581,583,585,587,589,591,593,595,597,599,601,603,605,607,609,611,613,615,617,619,621,623,625,627,629,631,633,635,637,639,641,643,645,647,649,651,653,655,657,659,661,663,665,667,669,671,673,675,677,679,681,683,685,687,689,691,693,695,697,699,701,703,705,707,709,711,713,715,717,719,721,723,725,727,729,731,733,735,737,739,741,743,745,747,749,751,753,755,757,759,761,763,765,767,769,771,773,775,777,779,781,783,785,787,789,791,793,795,797,799,801,803,805,807,809,811,813,815,817,819,821,823,825,827,829,831,833,835,837,839,841,843,845,847,849,851,853,855,857,859,861,863,865,867,869,871,873,875,877,879,881,883,885,887,889,891,893,895,897,899,901,903,905,907,909,911,913,915,917,919,921,923,925,927,929,931,933,935,937,939,941,943,945,947,949,951,953,955,957,959,961,963,965,967,969,971,973,975,977,979,981,983,985,987,989,991,993,995,997,999,1001,1003,1005,1007,1009,1011,1013,1015,1017,1019,1021,1023,1025,1027,1029,1031,1033,1035,1037,1039,1041,1043,1045,1047,1049,1051,1053,1055,1057,1059,1061,1063,1065,1067,1069,1071,1073,1075,1077,1079,1081,1083,1085,1087,1089,1091,1093,1095,1097,1099,1101,1103,1105,1107,1109,1111,1113,1115,1117,1119,1121,1123,1125,1127,1129,1131,1133,1135,1137,1139,1141,1143,1145,1147,1149,1151,1153,1155,1157,1159,1161,1163,1165,1167,1169,1171,1173,1175,1177,1179,1181,1183,1185,1187,1189,1191,1193,1195,1197,1199,1201,1203,1205,1207,1209,1211,1213,1215,1217,1219,1221,1223,1225,1227,1229,1231,1233,1235,1237,1239,1241,1243,1245,1247,1249,1251,1253,1255,1257,1259,1261,1263,1265,1267,1269,1271,1273,1275,1277,1279,1281,1283,1285,1287,1289,1291,1293,1295,1297,1299,1301,1303,1305,1307,1309,1311,1313,1315,1317,1319,1321,1323,1325,1327,1329,1331,1333,1335,1337,1339,1341,1343,1345,1347,1349,1351,1353,1355,1357,1359,1361,1363,1365,1367,1369,1371,1373,1375,1377,1379,1381,1383,1385,1387,1389,1391,1393,1395,1397,1399,1401,1403,1405,1407,1409,1411,1413,1415,1417,1419,1421,1423,1425,1427,1429,1431,1433,1435,1437,1439,1441,1443,1445,1447,1449,1451,1453,1455,1457,1459,1461,1463,1465,1467,1469,1471,1473,1475,1477,1479,1481,1483,1485,1487,1489,1491,1493,1495,1497,1499,1501,1503,1505,1507,1509,1511,1513,1515,1517,1519,1521,1523,1525,1527,1529,1531,1533,1535,1537,1539,1541,1543,1545,1547,1549,1551,1553,1555,1557,1559,1561,1563,1565,1567,1569,1571,1573,1575,1577,1579,1581,1583,1585,1587,1589,1591,1593,1595,1597,1599,1601,1603,1605,1607,1609,1611,1613,1615,1617,1619,1621,1623,1625,1627,1629,1631,1633,1635,1637,1639,1641,1643,1645,1647,1649,1651,1653,1655,1657,1659,1661,1663,1665,1667,1669,1671,1673,1675,1677,1679,1681,1683,1685,1687,1689,1691,1693,1695,1697,1699,1701,1703,1705,1707,1709,1711,1713,1715,1717,1719,1721,1723,1725,1727,1729,1731,1733,1735,1737,1739,1741,1743,1745,1747,1749,1751,1753,1755,1757,1759,1761,1763,1765,1767,1769,1771,1773,1775,1777,1779,1781,1783,1785,1787,1789,1791,1793,1795,1797,1799,1801,1803,1805,1807,1809,1811,1813,1815,1817,1819,1821,1823,1825,1827,1829,1831,1833,1835,1837,1839,1841,1843,1845,1847,1849,1851,1853,1855,1857,1859,1861,1863,1865,1867,1869,1871,1873,1875,1877,1879,1881,1883,1885,1887,1889,1891,1893,1895,1897,1899,1901,1903,1905,1907,1909,1911,1913,1915,1917,1919,1921,1923,1925,1927,1929,1931,1933,1935,1937,1939,1941,1943,1945,1947,1949,1951,1953,1955,1957,1959,1961,1963,1965,1967,1969,1971,1973,1975,1977,1979,1981,1983,1985,1987,1989,1991,1993,1995,1997,1999,2001,2003,2005,2007,2009,2011,2013,2015,2017,2019,2021,2023,2025,2027,2029,2031,2033,2035,2037,2039,2041,2043,2045,2047,2049,2051,2053,2055,2057,2059,2061,2063,2065,2067,2069,2071,2073,2075,2077,2079,2081,2083,2085,2087,2089,2091,2093,2095,2097,2099,2101,2103,2105,2107,2109,2111,2113,2115,2117,2119,2121,2123,2125,2127,2129,2131,2133,2135,2137,2139,2141,2143,2145,2147,2149,2151,2153,2155,2157,2159,2161,2163,2165,2167,2169,2171,2173,2175,2177,2179,2181,2183,2185,2187,2189,2191,2193,2195,2197,2199,2201,2203,2205,2207,2209,2211,2213,2215,2217,2219,2221,2223,2225,2227,2229,2231,2233,2235,2237,2239,2241,2243,2245,2247,2249,2251,2253,2255,2257,2259,2261,2263,2265,2267,2269,2271,2273,2275,2277,2279,2281,2283,2285,2287,2289,2291,2293,2295,2297,2299,2301,2303,2305,2307,2309,2311,2313,2315,2317,2319,2321,2323,2325,2327,2329,2331,2333,2335,2337,2339,2341,2343,2345,2347,2349,2351,2353,2355,2357,2359,2361,2363,2365,2367,2369,2371,2373,2375,2377,2379,2381,2383,2385,2387,2389,2391,2393,2395,2397,2399,2401,2403,2405,2407,2409,2411,2413,2415,2417,2419,2421,2423,2425,2427,2429,2431,2433,2435,2437,2439,2441,2443,2445,2447,2449,2451,2453,2455,2457,2459,2461,2463,2465,2467,2469,2471,2473,2475,2477,2479,2481,2483,2485,2487,2489,2491,2493,2495,2497,2499,2501,2503,2505,2507,2509,2511,2513,2515,2517,2519,2521,2523,2525,2527,2529,2531,2533,2535,2537,2539,2541,2543,2545,2547,2549,2551,2553,2555,2557,2559,2561,2563,2565,2567,2569,2571,2573,2575,2577,2579,2581,2583,2585,2587,2589,2591,2593,2595,2597,2599,2601,2603,2605,2607,2609,2611,2613,2615,2617,2619,2621,2623,2625,2627,2629,2631,2633,2635,2637,2639,2641,2643,2645,2647,2649,2651,2653,2655,2657,2659,2661,2663,2665,2667,2669,2671,2673,2675,2677,2679,2681,2683,2685,2687,2689,2691,2693,2695,2697,2699,2701,2703,2705,2707,2709,2711,2713,2715,2717,2719,2721,2723,2725,2727,2729,2731,2733,2735,2737,2739,2741,2743,2745,2747,2749,2751,2753,2755,2757,2759,2761,2763,2765,2767,2769,2771,2773,2775,2777,2779,2781,2783,2785,2787,2789,2791,2793,2795,2797,2799,2801,2803,2805,2807,2809,2811,2813,2815,2817,2819,2821,2823,2825,2827,2829,2831,2833,2835,2837,2839,2841,2843,2845,2847,2849,2851,2853,2855,2857,2859,2861,2863,2865,2867,2869,2871,2873,2875,2877,2879,2881,2883,2885,2887,2889,2891,2893,2895,2897,2899,2901,2903,2905,2907,2909,2911,2913,2915,2917,2919,2921,2923,2925,2927,2929,2931,2933,2935,2937,2939,2941,2943,2945,2947,2949,2951,2953,2955,2957,2959,2961,2963,2965,2967,2969,2971,2973,2975,2977,2979,2981,2983,2985,2987,2989,2991,2993,2995,2997,2999,3001,3003,3005,3007,3009,3011,3013,3015,3017,3019,3021,3023,3025,3027,3029,3031,3033,3035,3037,3039,3041,3043,3045,3047,3049,3051,3053,3055,3057,3059,3061,3063,3065,3067,3069,3071,3073,3075,3077,3079,3081,3083,3085,3087,3089,3091,3093,3095,3097,3099,3101,3103,3105,3107,3109,3111,3113,3115,3117,3119,3121,3123,3125,3127,3129,3131,3133,3135,3137,3139,3141,3143,3145,3147,3149,3151,3153,3155,3157,3159,3161,3163,3165,3167,3169,3171,3173,3175,3177,3179,3181,3183,3185,3187,3189,3191,3193,3195,3197,3199,3201,3203,3205,3207,3209,3211,3213,3215,3217,3219,3221,3223,3225,3227,3229,3231,3233,3235,3237,3239,3241,3243,3245,3247,3249,3251,3253,3255,3257,3259,3261,3263,3265,3267,3269,3271,3273,3275,3277,3279,3281,3283,3285,3287,3289,3291,3293,3295,3297,3299,3301,3303,3305,3307,3309,3311,3313,3315,3317,3319,3321,3323,3325,3327,3329,3331,3333,3335,3337,3339,3341,3343,3345,3347,3349,3351,3353,3355,3357,3359,3361,3363,3365,3367,3369,3371,3373,3375,3377,3379,3381,3383,3385,3387,3389,3391,3393,3395,3397,3399,3401,3403,3405,3407,3409,3411,3413,3415,3417,3419,3421,3423,3425,3427,3429,3431,3433,3435,3437,3439,3441,3443,3445,3447,3449,3451,3453,3455,3457,3459,3461,3463,3465,3467,3469,3471,3473,3475,3477,3479,3481,3483,3485,3487,3489,3491,3493,3495,3497,3499,3501,3503,3505,3507,3509,3511,3513,3515,3517,3519,3521,3523,3525,3527,3529,3531,3533,3535,3537,3539,3541,3543,3545,3547,3549,3551,3553,3555,3557,3559,3561,3563,3565,3567,3569,3571,3573,3575,3577,3579,3581,3583,3585,3587,3589,3591,3593,3595,3597,3599,3601,3603,3605,3607,3609,3611,3613,3615,3617,3619,3621,3623,3625,3627,3629,3631,3633,3635,3637,3639,3641,3643,3645,3647,3649,3651,3653,3655,3657,3659,3661,3663,3665,3667,3669,3671,3673,3675,3677,3679,3681,3683,3685,3687,3689,3691,3693,3695,3697,3699,3701,3703,3705,3707,3709,3711,3713,3715,3717,3719,3721,3723,3725,3727,3729,3731,3733,3735,3737,3739,3741,3743,3745,3747,3749,3751,3753,3755,3757,3759,3761,3763,3765,3767,3769,3771,3773,3775,3777,3779,3781,3783,3785,3787,3789,3791,3793,3795,3797,3799,3801,3803,3805,3807,3809,3811,3813,3815,3817,3819,3821,3823,3825,3827,3829,3831,3833,3835,3837,3839,3841,3843,3845,3847,3849,3851,3853,3855,3857,3859,3861,3863,3865,3867,3869,3871,3873,3875,3877,3879,3881,3883,3885,3887,3889,3891,3893,3895,3897,3899,3901,3903,3905,3907,3909,3911,3913,3915,3917,3919,3921,3923,3925,3927,3929,3931,3933,3935,3937,3939,3941,3943,3945,3947,3949,3951,3953,3955,3957,3959,3961,3963,3965,3967,3969,3971,3973,3975,3977,3979,3981,3983,3985,3987,3989,3991,3993,3995,3997,3999,4001,4003,4005,4007,4009,4011,4013,4015,4017,4019,4021,4023,4025,4027,4029,4031,4033,4035,4037,4039,4041,4043,4045,4047,4049,4051,4053,4055,4057,4059,4061,4063,4065,4067,4069,4071,4073,4075,4077,4079,4081,4083,4085,4087,4089,4091,4093,4095,4097,4099,4101,4103,4105,4107,4109,4111,4113,4115,4117,4119,4121,4123],{"categories":110},[111],"Developer Productivity",{"categories":113},[114],"Business & SaaS",{"categories":116},[75],{"categories":118},[119],"AI Automation",{"categories":121},[122],"Product Strategy",{"categories":124},[75],{"categories":126},[111],{"categories":128},[114],{"categories":130},[],{"categories":132},[75],{"categories":134},[],{"categories":136},[137],"AI News & Trends",{"categories":139},[119],{"categories":141},[119],{"categories":143},[137],{"categories":145},[119],{"categories":147},[119],{"categories":149},[119],{"categories":151},[75],{"categories":153},[75],{"categories":155},[75],{"categories":157},[137],{"categories":159},[75],{"categories":161},[75],{"categories":163},[],{"categories":165},[166],"Design & Frontend",{"categories":168},[169],"Data Science & Visualization",{"categories":171},[137],{"categories":173},[],{"categories":175},[176],"Software Engineering",{"categories":178},[75],{"categories":180},[119],{"categories":182},[183],"Marketing & Growth",{"categories":185},[166],{"categories":187},[75],{"categories":189},[119],{"categories":191},[],{"categories":193},[],{"categories":195},[166],{"categories":197},[119],{"categories":199},[111],{"categories":201},[176],{"categories":203},[166],{"categories":205},[75],{"categories":207},[208],"DevOps & Cloud",{"categories":210},[119],{"categories":212},[137],{"categories":214},[],{"categories":216},[],{"categories":218},[119],{"categories":220},[176],{"categories":222},[],{"categories":224},[114],{"categories":226},[],{"categories":228},[],{"categories":230},[119],{"categories":232},[75],{"categories":234},[75],{"categories":236},[119],{"categories":238},[75],{"categories":240},[75],{"categories":242},[],{"categories":244},[176],{"categories":246},[],{"categories":248},[],{"categories":250},[176],{"categories":252},[],{"categories":254},[176],{"categories":256},[75],{"categories":258},[75],{"categories":260},[183],{"categories":262},[166],{"categories":264},[166],{"categories":266},[75],{"categories":268},[119],{"categories":270},[176],{"categories":272},[75],{"categories":274},[75],{"categories":276},[119],{"categories":278},[119],{"categories":280},[169],{"categories":282},[137],{"categories":284},[119],{"categories":286},[119],{"categories":288},[183],{"categories":290},[119],{"categories":292},[122],{"categories":294},[176],{"categories":296},[],{"categories":298},[119],{"categories":300},[],{"categories":302},[119],{"categories":304},[176],{"categories":306},[208],{"categories":308},[166],{"categories":310},[75],{"categories":312},[],{"categories":314},[75],{"categories":316},[],{"categories":318},[119],{"categories":320},[],{"categories":322},[75],{"categories":324},[],{"categories":326},[111],{"categories":328},[176],{"categories":330},[114],{"categories":332},[75],{"categories":334},[75],{"categories":336},[137],{"categories":338},[75],{"categories":340},[],{"categories":342},[75],{"categories":344},[],{"categories":346},[176],{"categories":348},[169],{"categories":350},[],{"categories":352},[75],{"categories":354},[166],{"categories":356},[],{"categories":358},[166],{"categories":360},[119],{"categories":362},[],{"categories":364},[75],{"categories":366},[119],{"categories":368},[137],{"categories":370},[114],{"categories":372},[75],{"categories":374},[],{"categories":376},[119],{"categories":378},[75],{"categories":380},[122],{"categories":382},[],{"categories":384},[75],{"categories":386},[122],{"categories":388},[119],{"categories":390},[119],{"categories":392},[],{"categories":394},[169],{"categories":396},[75],{"categories":398},[],{"categories":400},[111],{"categories":402},[114],{"categories":404},[75],{"categories":406},[119],{"categories":408},[176],{"categories":410},[75],{"categories":412},[],{"categories":414},[],{"categories":416},[75],{"categories":418},[75],{"categories":420},[],{"categories":422},[166],{"categories":424},[],{"categories":426},[75],{"categories":428},[],{"categories":430},[119],{"categories":432},[75],{"categories":434},[166],{"categories":436},[],{"categories":438},[75],{"categories":440},[75],{"categories":442},[114],{"categories":444},[119],{"categories":446},[75],{"categories":448},[75],{"categories":450},[166],{"categories":452},[119],{"categories":454},[],{"categories":456},[],{"categories":458},[137],{"categories":460},[],{"categories":462},[75],{"categories":464},[114,183],{"categories":466},[],{"categories":468},[75],{"categories":470},[119],{"categories":472},[],{"categories":474},[],{"categories":476},[75],{"categories":478},[],{"categories":480},[75],{"categories":482},[208],{"categories":484},[],{"categories":486},[137],{"categories":488},[166],{"categories":490},[],{"categories":492},[137],{"categories":494},[119],{"categories":496},[137],{"categories":498},[75],{"categories":500},[183],{"categories":502},[],{"categories":504},[114],{"categories":506},[75],{"categories":508},[119],{"categories":510},[],{"categories":512},[75,208],{"categories":514},[75],{"categories":516},[75],{"categories":518},[75],{"categories":520},[119],{"categories":522},[75,176],{"categories":524},[169],{"categories":526},[75],{"categories":528},[183],{"categories":530},[119],{"categories":532},[75],{"categories":534},[119],{"categories":536},[],{"categories":538},[119],{"categories":540},[75],{"categories":542},[75,114],{"categories":544},[],{"categories":546},[166],{"categories":548},[166],{"categories":550},[],{"categories":552},[],{"categories":554},[137],{"categories":556},[],{"categories":558},[111],{"categories":560},[176],{"categories":562},[75],{"categories":564},[166],{"categories":566},[119],{"categories":568},[176],{"categories":570},[137],{"categories":572},[166],{"categories":574},[],{"categories":576},[75],{"categories":578},[75],{"categories":580},[75],{"categories":582},[75],{"categories":584},[137],{"categories":586},[111],{"categories":588},[75],{"categories":590},[119],{"categories":592},[208],{"categories":594},[166],{"categories":596},[119],{"categories":598},[],{"categories":600},[],{"categories":602},[166],{"categories":604},[137],{"categories":606},[169],{"categories":608},[],{"categories":610},[75],{"categories":612},[75],{"categories":614},[114],{"categories":616},[75],{"categories":618},[75],{"categories":620},[75],{"categories":622},[137],{"categories":624},[],{"categories":626},[119],{"categories":628},[176],{"categories":630},[],{"categories":632},[75],{"categories":634},[75],{"categories":636},[119],{"categories":638},[],{"categories":640},[],{"categories":642},[75],{"categories":644},[],{"categories":646},[114],{"categories":648},[119],{"categories":650},[119],{"categories":652},[],{"categories":654},[111],{"categories":656},[75],{"categories":658},[114],{"categories":660},[137],{"categories":662},[111],{"categories":664},[],{"categories":666},[],{"categories":668},[],{"categories":670},[137],{"categories":672},[137],{"categories":674},[],{"categories":676},[176],{"categories":678},[],{"categories":680},[114],{"categories":682},[],{"categories":684},[],{"categories":686},[111],{"categories":688},[],{"categories":690},[183],{"categories":692},[119],{"categories":694},[114],{"categories":696},[119],{"categories":698},[176],{"categories":700},[],{"categories":702},[122],{"categories":704},[166],{"categories":706},[176],{"categories":708},[75],{"categories":710},[119],{"categories":712},[114],{"categories":714},[75],{"categories":716},[],{"categories":718},[],{"categories":720},[176],{"categories":722},[169],{"categories":724},[122],{"categories":726},[119],{"categories":728},[75],{"categories":730},[],{"categories":732},[208],{"categories":734},[],{"categories":736},[119],{"categories":738},[],{"categories":740},[111],{"categories":742},[],{"categories":744},[75],{"categories":746},[75],{"categories":748},[166],{"categories":750},[183],{"categories":752},[119],{"categories":754},[],{"categories":756},[176],{"categories":758},[111],{"categories":760},[],{"categories":762},[137],{"categories":764},[75,208],{"categories":766},[75],{"categories":768},[137],{"categories":770},[75],{"categories":772},[75],{"categories":774},[114],{"categories":776},[75],{"categories":778},[],{"categories":780},[75],{"categories":782},[114],{"categories":784},[],{"categories":786},[119],{"categories":788},[176],{"categories":790},[166],{"categories":792},[137],{"categories":794},[169],{"categories":796},[111],{"categories":798},[75],{"categories":800},[119],{"categories":802},[176],{"categories":804},[],{"categories":806},[],{"categories":808},[122],{"categories":810},[],{"categories":812},[75],{"categories":814},[],{"categories":816},[166],{"categories":818},[176],{"categories":820},[166],{"categories":822},[75],{"categories":824},[166],{"categories":826},[],{"categories":828},[],{"categories":830},[137],{"categories":832},[119],{"categories":834},[119],{"categories":836},[75],{"categories":838},[75],{"categories":840},[75],{"categories":842},[114],{"categories":844},[75],{"categories":846},[],{"categories":848},[176],{"categories":850},[176],{"categories":852},[114],{"categories":854},[],{"categories":856},[75],{"categories":858},[75],{"categories":860},[114],{"categories":862},[137],{"categories":864},[183],{"categories":866},[75],{"categories":868},[119],{"categories":870},[],{"categories":872},[166],{"categories":874},[],{"categories":876},[75],{"categories":878},[75],{"categories":880},[],{"categories":882},[114],{"categories":884},[119],{"categories":886},[],{"categories":888},[208],{"categories":890},[169],{"categories":892},[176],{"categories":894},[183],{"categories":896},[75],{"categories":898},[176],{"categories":900},[119],{"categories":902},[],{"categories":904},[],{"categories":906},[119],{"categories":908},[111],{"categories":910},[119],{"categories":912},[122],{"categories":914},[114],{"categories":916},[],{"categories":918},[75],{"categories":920},[122],{"categories":922},[75],{"categories":924},[75],{"categories":926},[183],{"categories":928},[75],{"categories":930},[166],{"categories":932},[119],{"categories":934},[],{"categories":936},[],{"categories":938},[208],{"categories":940},[176],{"categories":942},[],{"categories":944},[119],{"categories":946},[75],{"categories":948},[166,75],{"categories":950},[111],{"categories":952},[],{"categories":954},[75],{"categories":956},[111],{"categories":958},[166],{"categories":960},[119],{"categories":962},[176],{"categories":964},[],{"categories":966},[75],{"categories":968},[],{"categories":970},[],{"categories":972},[75],{"categories":974},[111],{"categories":976},[75],{"categories":978},[],{"categories":980},[119],{"categories":982},[122],{"categories":984},[75],{"categories":986},[75],{"categories":988},[75],{"categories":990},[166],{"categories":992},[119],{"categories":994},[208],{"categories":996},[166],{"categories":998},[119],{"categories":1000},[75],{"categories":1002},[75],{"categories":1004},[75],{"categories":1006},[176],{"categories":1008},[],{"categories":1010},[137],{"categories":1012},[],{"categories":1014},[122],{"categories":1016},[119],{"categories":1018},[166],{"categories":1020},[75],{"categories":1022},[119],{"categories":1024},[176],{"categories":1026},[166],{"categories":1028},[119],{"categories":1030},[137],{"categories":1032},[],{"categories":1034},[75],{"categories":1036},[166],{"categories":1038},[75],{"categories":1040},[111],{"categories":1042},[137],{"categories":1044},[75],{"categories":1046},[183],{"categories":1048},[75],{"categories":1050},[119],{"categories":1052},[119],{"categories":1054},[75],{"categories":1056},[119],{"categories":1058},[119],{"categories":1060},[75],{"categories":1062},[119],{"categories":1064},[166],{"categories":1066},[75],{"categories":1068},[],{"categories":1070},[],{"categories":1072},[176],{"categories":1074},[],{"categories":1076},[111],{"categories":1078},[208],{"categories":1080},[75],{"categories":1082},[],{"categories":1084},[111],{"categories":1086},[114],{"categories":1088},[183],{"categories":1090},[],{"categories":1092},[114],{"categories":1094},[],{"categories":1096},[75],{"categories":1098},[176],{"categories":1100},[],{"categories":1102},[],{"categories":1104},[],{"categories":1106},[],{"categories":1108},[75],{"categories":1110},[119],{"categories":1112},[208],{"categories":1114},[111],{"categories":1116},[176],{"categories":1118},[75],{"categories":1120},[176],{"categories":1122},[122],{"categories":1124},[75],{"categories":1126},[183],{"categories":1128},[114],{"categories":1130},[75],{"categories":1132},[75],{"categories":1134},[75],{"categories":1136},[75,111],{"categories":1138},[176],{"categories":1140},[176],{"categories":1142},[166],{"categories":1144},[119],{"categories":1146},[75],{"categories":1148},[],{"categories":1150},[],{"categories":1152},[],{"categories":1154},[176],{"categories":1156},[169],{"categories":1158},[137],{"categories":1160},[166],{"categories":1162},[176],{"categories":1164},[],{"categories":1166},[75],{"categories":1168},[75],{"categories":1170},[],{"categories":1172},[119],{"categories":1174},[75],{"categories":1176},[75],{"categories":1178},[],{"categories":1180},[119],{"categories":1182},[75],{"categories":1184},[114],{"categories":1186},[],{"categories":1188},[111],{"categories":1190},[75],{"categories":1192},[111],{"categories":1194},[75],{"categories":1196},[176],{"categories":1198},[183],{"categories":1200},[119],{"categories":1202},[75,166],{"categories":1204},[137],{"categories":1206},[75],{"categories":1208},[166],{"categories":1210},[],{"categories":1212},[176],{"categories":1214},[208],{"categories":1216},[166],{"categories":1218},[119],{"categories":1220},[],{"categories":1222},[],{"categories":1224},[],{"categories":1226},[],{"categories":1228},[176],{"categories":1230},[119],{"categories":1232},[119],{"categories":1234},[208],{"categories":1236},[75],{"categories":1238},[75],{"categories":1240},[119],{"categories":1242},[75],{"categories":1244},[75],{"categories":1246},[],{"categories":1248},[166],{"categories":1250},[],{"categories":1252},[],{"categories":1254},[119],{"categories":1256},[],{"categories":1258},[],{"categories":1260},[183],{"categories":1262},[183],{"categories":1264},[119],{"categories":1266},[176],{"categories":1268},[],{"categories":1270},[75],{"categories":1272},[75],{"categories":1274},[176],{"categories":1276},[166],{"categories":1278},[166],{"categories":1280},[119],{"categories":1282},[111],{"categories":1284},[75],{"categories":1286},[166],{"categories":1288},[166],{"categories":1290},[119],{"categories":1292},[119],{"categories":1294},[75],{"categories":1296},[],{"categories":1298},[75],{"categories":1300},[],{"categories":1302},[75],{"categories":1304},[119],{"categories":1306},[137],{"categories":1308},[176],{"categories":1310},[75],{"categories":1312},[111],{"categories":1314},[75],{"categories":1316},[],{"categories":1318},[119],{"categories":1320},[119],{"categories":1322},[],{"categories":1324},[75],{"categories":1326},[111],{"categories":1328},[75],{"categories":1330},[111],{"categories":1332},[111],{"categories":1334},[],{"categories":1336},[],{"categories":1338},[119],{"categories":1340},[137],{"categories":1342},[119],{"categories":1344},[75],{"categories":1346},[75],{"categories":1348},[137],{"categories":1350},[169],{"categories":1352},[122],{"categories":1354},[137],{"categories":1356},[166],{"categories":1358},[],{"categories":1360},[],{"categories":1362},[137],{"categories":1364},[],{"categories":1366},[],{"categories":1368},[],{"categories":1370},[],{"categories":1372},[176],{"categories":1374},[176],{"categories":1376},[169],{"categories":1378},[],{"categories":1380},[75],{"categories":1382},[75],{"categories":1384},[169],{"categories":1386},[176],{"categories":1388},[],{"categories":1390},[],{"categories":1392},[119],{"categories":1394},[119],{"categories":1396},[137],{"categories":1398},[137],{"categories":1400},[119],{"categories":1402},[119],{"categories":1404},[111],{"categories":1406},[75,208],{"categories":1408},[],{"categories":1410},[166],{"categories":1412},[111],{"categories":1414},[119],{"categories":1416},[166],{"categories":1418},[],{"categories":1420},[119],{"categories":1422},[119],{"categories":1424},[75],{"categories":1426},[183],{"categories":1428},[176],{"categories":1430},[166],{"categories":1432},[],{"categories":1434},[119],{"categories":1436},[75],{"categories":1438},[119],{"categories":1440},[119],{"categories":1442},[119],{"categories":1444},[183],{"categories":1446},[75],{"categories":1448},[119],{"categories":1450},[75],{"categories":1452},[],{"categories":1454},[183],{"categories":1456},[137],{"categories":1458},[176],{"categories":1460},[75],{"categories":1462},[119],{"categories":1464},[],{"categories":1466},[],{"categories":1468},[75],{"categories":1470},[119],{"categories":1472},[137],{"categories":1474},[119],{"categories":1476},[119],{"categories":1478},[],{"categories":1480},[75],{"categories":1482},[],{"categories":1484},[],{"categories":1486},[119],{"categories":1488},[],{"categories":1490},[],{"categories":1492},[169],{"categories":1494},[75],{"categories":1496},[169],{"categories":1498},[137],{"categories":1500},[75],{"categories":1502},[75],{"categories":1504},[119],{"categories":1506},[75],{"categories":1508},[],{"categories":1510},[],{"categories":1512},[208],{"categories":1514},[75],{"categories":1516},[],{"categories":1518},[],{"categories":1520},[111],{"categories":1522},[],{"categories":1524},[],{"categories":1526},[75],{"categories":1528},[],{"categories":1530},[],{"categories":1532},[176],{"categories":1534},[137],{"categories":1536},[183],{"categories":1538},[114],{"categories":1540},[75],{"categories":1542},[75],{"categories":1544},[114],{"categories":1546},[],{"categories":1548},[166],{"categories":1550},[119],{"categories":1552},[114],{"categories":1554},[75],{"categories":1556},[75],{"categories":1558},[111],{"categories":1560},[75],{"categories":1562},[],{"categories":1564},[111],{"categories":1566},[75],{"categories":1568},[183],{"categories":1570},[119],{"categories":1572},[137],{"categories":1574},[114],{"categories":1576},[75],{"categories":1578},[75],{"categories":1580},[119],{"categories":1582},[],{"categories":1584},[75],{"categories":1586},[111],{"categories":1588},[75],{"categories":1590},[75],{"categories":1592},[],{"categories":1594},[137],{"categories":1596},[75],{"categories":1598},[75],{"categories":1600},[],{"categories":1602},[114],{"categories":1604},[114],{"categories":1606},[75],{"categories":1608},[75],{"categories":1610},[],{"categories":1612},[],{"categories":1614},[],{"categories":1616},[75],{"categories":1618},[137],{"categories":1620},[],{"categories":1622},[208],{"categories":1624},[75],{"categories":1626},[75],{"categories":1628},[],{"categories":1630},[75],{"categories":1632},[75],{"categories":1634},[75],{"categories":1636},[75,208],{"categories":1638},[75],{"categories":1640},[75],{"categories":1642},[166],{"categories":1644},[119],{"categories":1646},[],{"categories":1648},[119],{"categories":1650},[119],{"categories":1652},[75],{"categories":1654},[75],{"categories":1656},[75],{"categories":1658},[111],{"categories":1660},[111],{"categories":1662},[176],{"categories":1664},[166],{"categories":1666},[119],{"categories":1668},[],{"categories":1670},[75],{"categories":1672},[137],{"categories":1674},[75],{"categories":1676},[75],{"categories":1678},[114],{"categories":1680},[],{"categories":1682},[208],{"categories":1684},[166],{"categories":1686},[166],{"categories":1688},[119],{"categories":1690},[137],{"categories":1692},[119],{"categories":1694},[75],{"categories":1696},[],{"categories":1698},[75],{"categories":1700},[],{"categories":1702},[],{"categories":1704},[75],{"categories":1706},[75],{"categories":1708},[75],{"categories":1710},[119],{"categories":1712},[75],{"categories":1714},[75],{"categories":1716},[],{"categories":1718},[169],{"categories":1720},[119],{"categories":1722},[],{"categories":1724},[],{"categories":1726},[75],{"categories":1728},[75],{"categories":1730},[75],{"categories":1732},[137],{"categories":1734},[],{"categories":1736},[166],{"categories":1738},[208],{"categories":1740},[137],{"categories":1742},[176],{"categories":1744},[176],{"categories":1746},[137],{"categories":1748},[137],{"categories":1750},[208],{"categories":1752},[],{"categories":1754},[137],{"categories":1756},[75],{"categories":1758},[111],{"categories":1760},[75],{"categories":1762},[137],{"categories":1764},[],{"categories":1766},[176],{"categories":1768},[169],{"categories":1770},[75],{"categories":1772},[137],{"categories":1774},[176],{"categories":1776},[119],{"categories":1778},[137],{"categories":1780},[208],{"categories":1782},[119],{"categories":1784},[75],{"categories":1786},[75],{"categories":1788},[75],{"categories":1790},[],{"categories":1792},[114],{"categories":1794},[],{"categories":1796},[],{"categories":1798},[75],{"categories":1800},[75],{"categories":1802},[75],{"categories":1804},[75],{"categories":1806},[],{"categories":1808},[169],{"categories":1810},[111],{"categories":1812},[],{"categories":1814},[75],{"categories":1816},[75],{"categories":1818},[208],{"categories":1820},[208],{"categories":1822},[],{"categories":1824},[119],{"categories":1826},[137],{"categories":1828},[137],{"categories":1830},[75],{"categories":1832},[119],{"categories":1834},[],{"categories":1836},[166],{"categories":1838},[75],{"categories":1840},[75],{"categories":1842},[],{"categories":1844},[75],{"categories":1846},[],{"categories":1848},[176],{"categories":1850},[208],{"categories":1852},[75],{"categories":1854},[176],{"categories":1856},[114],{"categories":1858},[75],{"categories":1860},[],{"categories":1862},[119],{"categories":1864},[111],{"categories":1866},[111],{"categories":1868},[],{"categories":1870},[75],{"categories":1872},[166],{"categories":1874},[119],{"categories":1876},[],{"categories":1878},[75],{"categories":1880},[75],{"categories":1882},[119],{"categories":1884},[],{"categories":1886},[119],{"categories":1888},[176],{"categories":1890},[],{"categories":1892},[75],{"categories":1894},[],{"categories":1896},[75],{"categories":1898},[],{"categories":1900},[75],{"categories":1902},[75],{"categories":1904},[],{"categories":1906},[75],{"categories":1908},[137],{"categories":1910},[75],{"categories":1912},[75],{"categories":1914},[111],{"categories":1916},[75],{"categories":1918},[137],{"categories":1920},[119],{"categories":1922},[],{"categories":1924},[75],{"categories":1926},[166],{"categories":1928},[183],{"categories":1930},[75],{"categories":1932},[],{"categories":1934},[],{"categories":1936},[],{"categories":1938},[111],{"categories":1940},[137],{"categories":1942},[119],{"categories":1944},[75],{"categories":1946},[166],{"categories":1948},[119],{"categories":1950},[],{"categories":1952},[119],{"categories":1954},[],{"categories":1956},[75],{"categories":1958},[119],{"categories":1960},[75],{"categories":1962},[],{"categories":1964},[75],{"categories":1966},[75],{"categories":1968},[137],{"categories":1970},[166],{"categories":1972},[119],{"categories":1974},[166],{"categories":1976},[114],{"categories":1978},[],{"categories":1980},[],{"categories":1982},[75],{"categories":1984},[111],{"categories":1986},[137],{"categories":1988},[],{"categories":1990},[166],{"categories":1992},[],{"categories":1994},[176],{"categories":1996},[176],{"categories":1998},[166],{"categories":2000},[],{"categories":2002},[75],{"categories":2004},[],{"categories":2006},[183],{"categories":2008},[75],{"categories":2010},[208],{"categories":2012},[176],{"categories":2014},[],{"categories":2016},[119],{"categories":2018},[75],{"categories":2020},[111],{"categories":2022},[119],{"categories":2024},[119],{"categories":2026},[75],{"categories":2028},[],{"categories":2030},[111],{"categories":2032},[75],{"categories":2034},[114],{"categories":2036},[176],{"categories":2038},[166],{"categories":2040},[],{"categories":2042},[],{"categories":2044},[],{"categories":2046},[119],{"categories":2048},[176],{"categories":2050},[166],{"categories":2052},[137],{"categories":2054},[75],{"categories":2056},[137],{"categories":2058},[166],{"categories":2060},[],{"categories":2062},[166],{"categories":2064},[137],{"categories":2066},[114],{"categories":2068},[176],{"categories":2070},[75],{"categories":2072},[137],{"categories":2074},[183],{"categories":2076},[],{"categories":2078},[],{"categories":2080},[169],{"categories":2082},[75,176],{"categories":2084},[137],{"categories":2086},[75],{"categories":2088},[119],{"categories":2090},[75],{"categories":2092},[119],{"categories":2094},[75],{"categories":2096},[75],{"categories":2098},[],{"categories":2100},[176],{"categories":2102},[75],{"categories":2104},[169],{"categories":2106},[119],{"categories":2108},[183],{"categories":2110},[208],{"categories":2112},[],{"categories":2114},[111],{"categories":2116},[119],{"categories":2118},[119],{"categories":2120},[176],{"categories":2122},[75],{"categories":2124},[75],{"categories":2126},[],{"categories":2128},[],{"categories":2130},[],{"categories":2132},[208],{"categories":2134},[137],{"categories":2136},[75],{"categories":2138},[75],{"categories":2140},[75],{"categories":2142},[],{"categories":2144},[169],{"categories":2146},[114],{"categories":2148},[],{"categories":2150},[75],{"categories":2152},[119],{"categories":2154},[208],{"categories":2156},[],{"categories":2158},[166],{"categories":2160},[166],{"categories":2162},[],{"categories":2164},[176],{"categories":2166},[75],{"categories":2168},[166],{"categories":2170},[75],{"categories":2172},[],{"categories":2174},[137],{"categories":2176},[75],{"categories":2178},[75],{"categories":2180},[166],{"categories":2182},[119],{"categories":2184},[137],{"categories":2186},[],{"categories":2188},[119],{"categories":2190},[166],{"categories":2192},[75],{"categories":2194},[],{"categories":2196},[75],{"categories":2198},[75],{"categories":2200},[208],{"categories":2202},[137],{"categories":2204},[169],{"categories":2206},[169],{"categories":2208},[],{"categories":2210},[],{"categories":2212},[],{"categories":2214},[119],{"categories":2216},[176],{"categories":2218},[176],{"categories":2220},[75],{"categories":2222},[75],{"categories":2224},[],{"categories":2226},[],{"categories":2228},[75],{"categories":2230},[],{"categories":2232},[119],{"categories":2234},[75],{"categories":2236},[],{"categories":2238},[75],{"categories":2240},[114],{"categories":2242},[75],{"categories":2244},[183],{"categories":2246},[119],{"categories":2248},[75],{"categories":2250},[75],{"categories":2252},[75],{"categories":2254},[176],{"categories":2256},[],{"categories":2258},[137],{"categories":2260},[119],{"categories":2262},[],{"categories":2264},[137],{"categories":2266},[119],{"categories":2268},[75],{"categories":2270},[119],{"categories":2272},[],{"categories":2274},[114],{"categories":2276},[119],{"categories":2278},[],{"categories":2280},[176],{"categories":2282},[75],{"categories":2284},[111],{"categories":2286},[137],{"categories":2288},[208],{"categories":2290},[119],{"categories":2292},[119],{"categories":2294},[111],{"categories":2296},[],{"categories":2298},[75],{"categories":2300},[],{"categories":2302},[],{"categories":2304},[166],{"categories":2306},[75,114],{"categories":2308},[75],{"categories":2310},[],{"categories":2312},[111],{"categories":2314},[169],{"categories":2316},[75],{"categories":2318},[176],{"categories":2320},[75],{"categories":2322},[119],{"categories":2324},[75],{"categories":2326},[75],{"categories":2328},[75],{"categories":2330},[137],{"categories":2332},[119],{"categories":2334},[75],{"categories":2336},[],{"categories":2338},[],{"categories":2340},[119],{"categories":2342},[75],{"categories":2344},[208],{"categories":2346},[],{"categories":2348},[75],{"categories":2350},[119],{"categories":2352},[],{"categories":2354},[119],{"categories":2356},[75],{"categories":2358},[183],{"categories":2360},[169],{"categories":2362},[119],{"categories":2364},[75],{"categories":2366},[208],{"categories":2368},[],{"categories":2370},[75],{"categories":2372},[183],{"categories":2374},[166],{"categories":2376},[75],{"categories":2378},[75],{"categories":2380},[],{"categories":2382},[183],{"categories":2384},[137],{"categories":2386},[75],{"categories":2388},[75],{"categories":2390},[111],{"categories":2392},[],{"categories":2394},[],{"categories":2396},[166],{"categories":2398},[75],{"categories":2400},[169],{"categories":2402},[183],{"categories":2404},[119],{"categories":2406},[183],{"categories":2408},[137],{"categories":2410},[],{"categories":2412},[],{"categories":2414},[75],{"categories":2416},[119],{"categories":2418},[75],{"categories":2420},[75],{"categories":2422},[],{"categories":2424},[75,176],{"categories":2426},[137],{"categories":2428},[119],{"categories":2430},[176],{"categories":2432},[75],{"categories":2434},[111],{"categories":2436},[],{"categories":2438},[],{"categories":2440},[111],{"categories":2442},[176],{"categories":2444},[183],{"categories":2446},[75],{"categories":2448},[176],{"categories":2450},[],{"categories":2452},[166,75],{"categories":2454},[208],{"categories":2456},[111],{"categories":2458},[],{"categories":2460},[114],{"categories":2462},[114],{"categories":2464},[75],{"categories":2466},[75],{"categories":2468},[176],{"categories":2470},[119],{"categories":2472},[137],{"categories":2474},[183],{"categories":2476},[166],{"categories":2478},[75],{"categories":2480},[75],{"categories":2482},[75],{"categories":2484},[111],{"categories":2486},[75],{"categories":2488},[119],{"categories":2490},[137],{"categories":2492},[],{"categories":2494},[],{"categories":2496},[169],{"categories":2498},[176],{"categories":2500},[75],{"categories":2502},[166],{"categories":2504},[75],{"categories":2506},[169],{"categories":2508},[75],{"categories":2510},[75],{"categories":2512},[75],{"categories":2514},[119],{"categories":2516},[119],{"categories":2518},[75,114],{"categories":2520},[],{"categories":2522},[166],{"categories":2524},[],{"categories":2526},[75],{"categories":2528},[137],{"categories":2530},[111],{"categories":2532},[111],{"categories":2534},[119],{"categories":2536},[75],{"categories":2538},[75],{"categories":2540},[114],{"categories":2542},[176],{"categories":2544},[183],{"categories":2546},[75],{"categories":2548},[],{"categories":2550},[137],{"categories":2552},[75],{"categories":2554},[75],{"categories":2556},[75],{"categories":2558},[75],{"categories":2560},[75],{"categories":2562},[176],{"categories":2564},[137],{"categories":2566},[176],{"categories":2568},[176],{"categories":2570},[75],{"categories":2572},[75],{"categories":2574},[119],{"categories":2576},[137],{"categories":2578},[75],{"categories":2580},[166],{"categories":2582},[75],{"categories":2584},[75],{"categories":2586},[208],{"categories":2588},[75],{"categories":2590},[122],{"categories":2592},[119],{"categories":2594},[75],{"categories":2596},[137],{"categories":2598},[119],{"categories":2600},[183],{"categories":2602},[75],{"categories":2604},[],{"categories":2606},[75],{"categories":2608},[75],{"categories":2610},[],{"categories":2612},[],{"categories":2614},[],{"categories":2616},[114],{"categories":2618},[75],{"categories":2620},[119],{"categories":2622},[137],{"categories":2624},[137],{"categories":2626},[137],{"categories":2628},[137],{"categories":2630},[],{"categories":2632},[111],{"categories":2634},[119],{"categories":2636},[137],{"categories":2638},[75],{"categories":2640},[111],{"categories":2642},[119],{"categories":2644},[75],{"categories":2646},[75,119],{"categories":2648},[119],{"categories":2650},[208],{"categories":2652},[137],{"categories":2654},[137],{"categories":2656},[119],{"categories":2658},[75],{"categories":2660},[],{"categories":2662},[137],{"categories":2664},[183],{"categories":2666},[111],{"categories":2668},[75],{"categories":2670},[75],{"categories":2672},[],{"categories":2674},[176],{"categories":2676},[],{"categories":2678},[111],{"categories":2680},[119],{"categories":2682},[137],{"categories":2684},[75],{"categories":2686},[137],{"categories":2688},[111],{"categories":2690},[137],{"categories":2692},[137],{"categories":2694},[],{"categories":2696},[114],{"categories":2698},[119],{"categories":2700},[137],{"categories":2702},[137],{"categories":2704},[137],{"categories":2706},[137],{"categories":2708},[137],{"categories":2710},[137],{"categories":2712},[137],{"categories":2714},[137],{"categories":2716},[137],{"categories":2718},[137],{"categories":2720},[169],{"categories":2722},[111],{"categories":2724},[75],{"categories":2726},[75],{"categories":2728},[119],{"categories":2730},[],{"categories":2732},[75,111],{"categories":2734},[],{"categories":2736},[119],{"categories":2738},[137],{"categories":2740},[119],{"categories":2742},[75],{"categories":2744},[75],{"categories":2746},[75],{"categories":2748},[75],{"categories":2750},[75],{"categories":2752},[119],{"categories":2754},[114],{"categories":2756},[],{"categories":2758},[166],{"categories":2760},[137],{"categories":2762},[75],{"categories":2764},[],{"categories":2766},[],{"categories":2768},[119],{"categories":2770},[166],{"categories":2772},[75],{"categories":2774},[],{"categories":2776},[75],{"categories":2778},[],{"categories":2780},[183],{"categories":2782},[75],{"categories":2784},[],{"categories":2786},[],{"categories":2788},[137],{"categories":2790},[111],{"categories":2792},[75],{"categories":2794},[114],{"categories":2796},[75],{"categories":2798},[114],{"categories":2800},[166],{"categories":2802},[],{"categories":2804},[137],{"categories":2806},[],{"categories":2808},[166],{"categories":2810},[75],{"categories":2812},[183],{"categories":2814},[],{"categories":2816},[183],{"categories":2818},[],{"categories":2820},[],{"categories":2822},[119],{"categories":2824},[],{"categories":2826},[114],{"categories":2828},[111],{"categories":2830},[166],{"categories":2832},[176],{"categories":2834},[],{"categories":2836},[],{"categories":2838},[75],{"categories":2840},[111],{"categories":2842},[183],{"categories":2844},[],{"categories":2846},[119],{"categories":2848},[119],{"categories":2850},[137],{"categories":2852},[176],{"categories":2854},[75],{"categories":2856},[119],{"categories":2858},[75],{"categories":2860},[119],{"categories":2862},[75],{"categories":2864},[122],{"categories":2866},[183],{"categories":2868},[137],{"categories":2870},[],{"categories":2872},[183],{"categories":2874},[],{"categories":2876},[176],{"categories":2878},[119],{"categories":2880},[],{"categories":2882},[75],{"categories":2884},[119],{"categories":2886},[114],{"categories":2888},[111],{"categories":2890},[75],{"categories":2892},[166],{"categories":2894},[176],{"categories":2896},[176],{"categories":2898},[75],{"categories":2900},[169],{"categories":2902},[75],{"categories":2904},[119],{"categories":2906},[114],{"categories":2908},[166],{"categories":2910},[119],{"categories":2912},[75],{"categories":2914},[75],{"categories":2916},[119],{"categories":2918},[137],{"categories":2920},[],{"categories":2922},[111],{"categories":2924},[75],{"categories":2926},[75],{"categories":2928},[119],{"categories":2930},[75],{"categories":2932},[75],{"categories":2934},[],{"categories":2936},[166],{"categories":2938},[114],{"categories":2940},[137],{"categories":2942},[75],{"categories":2944},[75],{"categories":2946},[166],{"categories":2948},[75],{"categories":2950},[183],{"categories":2952},[169],{"categories":2954},[75],{"categories":2956},[137],{"categories":2958},[75],{"categories":2960},[119],{"categories":2962},[208],{"categories":2964},[75],{"categories":2966},[119],{"categories":2968},[169],{"categories":2970},[],{"categories":2972},[119],{"categories":2974},[176],{"categories":2976},[166],{"categories":2978},[75],{"categories":2980},[111],{"categories":2982},[176],{"categories":2984},[114],{"categories":2986},[176],{"categories":2988},[75],{"categories":2990},[],{"categories":2992},[119],{"categories":2994},[119],{"categories":2996},[75],{"categories":2998},[169],{"categories":3000},[],{"categories":3002},[137],{"categories":3004},[],{"categories":3006},[137],{"categories":3008},[75],{"categories":3010},[75],{"categories":3012},[119],{"categories":3014},[119],{"categories":3016},[119],{"categories":3018},[],{"categories":3020},[137],{"categories":3022},[],{"categories":3024},[75],{"categories":3026},[75],{"categories":3028},[],{"categories":3030},[166],{"categories":3032},[119],{"categories":3034},[183],{"categories":3036},[111],{"categories":3038},[],{"categories":3040},[75],{"categories":3042},[],{"categories":3044},[111],{"categories":3046},[137],{"categories":3048},[176],{"categories":3050},[75],{"categories":3052},[75],{"categories":3054},[75],{"categories":3056},[176],{"categories":3058},[137],{"categories":3060},[166],{"categories":3062},[75],{"categories":3064},[75],{"categories":3066},[75],{"categories":3068},[137],{"categories":3070},[75],{"categories":3072},[137],{"categories":3074},[137],{"categories":3076},[119],{"categories":3078},[119],{"categories":3080},[176],{"categories":3082},[137],{"categories":3084},[119],{"categories":3086},[75],{"categories":3088},[176],{"categories":3090},[166],{"categories":3092},[],{"categories":3094},[119],{"categories":3096},[],{"categories":3098},[],{"categories":3100},[],{"categories":3102},[114],{"categories":3104},[119],{"categories":3106},[75],{"categories":3108},[119],{"categories":3110},[111],{"categories":3112},[119],{"categories":3114},[183],{"categories":3116},[],{"categories":3118},[119],{"categories":3120},[],{"categories":3122},[111],{"categories":3124},[119],{"categories":3126},[],{"categories":3128},[119],{"categories":3130},[75],{"categories":3132},[137],{"categories":3134},[75],{"categories":3136},[119],{"categories":3138},[137],{"categories":3140},[119],{"categories":3142},[176],{"categories":3144},[166],{"categories":3146},[111],{"categories":3148},[],{"categories":3150},[119],{"categories":3152},[166],{"categories":3154},[208],{"categories":3156},[137],{"categories":3158},[75],{"categories":3160},[166],{"categories":3162},[111],{"categories":3164},[],{"categories":3166},[119],{"categories":3168},[75],{"categories":3170},[119],{"categories":3172},[75],{"categories":3174},[166],{"categories":3176},[],{"categories":3178},[119],{"categories":3180},[122],{"categories":3182},[137],{"categories":3184},[119],{"categories":3186},[114],{"categories":3188},[],{"categories":3190},[75],{"categories":3192},[122],{"categories":3194},[75],{"categories":3196},[119],{"categories":3198},[137],{"categories":3200},[111],{"categories":3202},[208],{"categories":3204},[75],{"categories":3206},[75],{"categories":3208},[75],{"categories":3210},[137],{"categories":3212},[114],{"categories":3214},[75],{"categories":3216},[166],{"categories":3218},[137],{"categories":3220},[208],{"categories":3222},[75],{"categories":3224},[],{"categories":3226},[],{"categories":3228},[75],{"categories":3230},[208],{"categories":3232},[169],{"categories":3234},[119],{"categories":3236},[119],{"categories":3238},[137],{"categories":3240},[75],{"categories":3242},[111],{"categories":3244},[166],{"categories":3246},[119],{"categories":3248},[119],{"categories":3250},[75],{"categories":3252},[183],{"categories":3254},[75],{"categories":3256},[119],{"categories":3258},[],{"categories":3260},[75],{"categories":3262},[75],{"categories":3264},[137],{"categories":3266},[111],{"categories":3268},[],{"categories":3270},[75],{"categories":3272},[75],{"categories":3274},[176],{"categories":3276},[166],{"categories":3278},[75,119],{"categories":3280},[183,114],{"categories":3282},[75],{"categories":3284},[],{"categories":3286},[119],{"categories":3288},[],{"categories":3290},[176],{"categories":3292},[75],{"categories":3294},[],{"categories":3296},[75],{"categories":3298},[137],{"categories":3300},[],{"categories":3302},[119],{"categories":3304},[75],{"categories":3306},[],{"categories":3308},[166],{"categories":3310},[119],{"categories":3312},[75],{"categories":3314},[111],{"categories":3316},[119],{"categories":3318},[75],{"categories":3320},[],{"categories":3322},[208],{"categories":3324},[183],{"categories":3326},[114],{"categories":3328},[114],{"categories":3330},[111],{"categories":3332},[111],{"categories":3334},[75],{"categories":3336},[119],{"categories":3338},[75],{"categories":3340},[75],{"categories":3342},[111],{"categories":3344},[75],{"categories":3346},[183],{"categories":3348},[137],{"categories":3350},[75],{"categories":3352},[119],{"categories":3354},[75],{"categories":3356},[],{"categories":3358},[176],{"categories":3360},[],{"categories":3362},[176],{"categories":3364},[119],{"categories":3366},[111],{"categories":3368},[],{"categories":3370},[208],{"categories":3372},[75],{"categories":3374},[],{"categories":3376},[137],{"categories":3378},[119],{"categories":3380},[176],{"categories":3382},[75],{"categories":3384},[119],{"categories":3386},[176],{"categories":3388},[119],{"categories":3390},[137],{"categories":3392},[111],{"categories":3394},[137],{"categories":3396},[176],{"categories":3398},[75],{"categories":3400},[166],{"categories":3402},[75],{"categories":3404},[75],{"categories":3406},[75],{"categories":3408},[75],{"categories":3410},[75],{"categories":3412},[119],{"categories":3414},[75],{"categories":3416},[119],{"categories":3418},[75],{"categories":3420},[111],{"categories":3422},[75],{"categories":3424},[119],{"categories":3426},[166],{"categories":3428},[111],{"categories":3430},[119],{"categories":3432},[166],{"categories":3434},[],{"categories":3436},[75],{"categories":3438},[75],{"categories":3440},[75],{"categories":3442},[176],{"categories":3444},[],{"categories":3446},[119],{"categories":3448},[183],{"categories":3450},[75],{"categories":3452},[137],{"categories":3454},[183],{"categories":3456},[119],{"categories":3458},[114],{"categories":3460},[114],{"categories":3462},[75],{"categories":3464},[75],{"categories":3466},[111],{"categories":3468},[],{"categories":3470},[119],{"categories":3472},[75],{"categories":3474},[],{"categories":3476},[111],{"categories":3478},[75],{"categories":3480},[119],{"categories":3482},[119],{"categories":3484},[],{"categories":3486},[176],{"categories":3488},[176],{"categories":3490},[183],{"categories":3492},[166],{"categories":3494},[],{"categories":3496},[75],{"categories":3498},[119],{"categories":3500},[111],{"categories":3502},[75],{"categories":3504},[176],{"categories":3506},[111],{"categories":3508},[137],{"categories":3510},[137],{"categories":3512},[],{"categories":3514},[137],{"categories":3516},[119],{"categories":3518},[166],{"categories":3520},[169],{"categories":3522},[75],{"categories":3524},[],{"categories":3526},[137],{"categories":3528},[176],{"categories":3530},[114],{"categories":3532},[75],{"categories":3534},[111],{"categories":3536},[208],{"categories":3538},[111],{"categories":3540},[],{"categories":3542},[],{"categories":3544},[137],{"categories":3546},[],{"categories":3548},[119],{"categories":3550},[119],{"categories":3552},[119],{"categories":3554},[],{"categories":3556},[75],{"categories":3558},[],{"categories":3560},[137],{"categories":3562},[111],{"categories":3564},[166],{"categories":3566},[75],{"categories":3568},[137],{"categories":3570},[137],{"categories":3572},[],{"categories":3574},[137],{"categories":3576},[111],{"categories":3578},[119],{"categories":3580},[75],{"categories":3582},[],{"categories":3584},[119],{"categories":3586},[119],{"categories":3588},[111],{"categories":3590},[],{"categories":3592},[],{"categories":3594},[],{"categories":3596},[166],{"categories":3598},[119],{"categories":3600},[75],{"categories":3602},[],{"categories":3604},[],{"categories":3606},[],{"categories":3608},[166],{"categories":3610},[],{"categories":3612},[75],{"categories":3614},[111],{"categories":3616},[],{"categories":3618},[],{"categories":3620},[166],{"categories":3622},[75],{"categories":3624},[137],{"categories":3626},[],{"categories":3628},[183],{"categories":3630},[137],{"categories":3632},[183],{"categories":3634},[169],{"categories":3636},[75],{"categories":3638},[75],{"categories":3640},[],{"categories":3642},[],{"categories":3644},[119],{"categories":3646},[],{"categories":3648},[],{"categories":3650},[119],{"categories":3652},[75],{"categories":3654},[],{"categories":3656},[119],{"categories":3658},[137],{"categories":3660},[75],{"categories":3662},[183],{"categories":3664},[75],{"categories":3666},[169],{"categories":3668},[119],{"categories":3670},[119],{"categories":3672},[],{"categories":3674},[],{"categories":3676},[],{"categories":3678},[137],{"categories":3680},[],{"categories":3682},[],{"categories":3684},[166],{"categories":3686},[111],{"categories":3688},[],{"categories":3690},[114],{"categories":3692},[183],{"categories":3694},[75],{"categories":3696},[176],{"categories":3698},[111],{"categories":3700},[169],{"categories":3702},[114],{"categories":3704},[176],{"categories":3706},[176],{"categories":3708},[],{"categories":3710},[],{"categories":3712},[119],{"categories":3714},[111],{"categories":3716},[166],{"categories":3718},[111],{"categories":3720},[119],{"categories":3722},[208],{"categories":3724},[75],{"categories":3726},[111],{"categories":3728},[119],{"categories":3730},[],{"categories":3732},[75],{"categories":3734},[137],{"categories":3736},[176],{"categories":3738},[],{"categories":3740},[166],{"categories":3742},[137],{"categories":3744},[111],{"categories":3746},[119],{"categories":3748},[75],{"categories":3750},[114],{"categories":3752},[119,208],{"categories":3754},[119],{"categories":3756},[176],{"categories":3758},[75],{"categories":3760},[75],{"categories":3762},[169],{"categories":3764},[183],{"categories":3766},[119],{"categories":3768},[],{"categories":3770},[119],{"categories":3772},[75],{"categories":3774},[114],{"categories":3776},[],{"categories":3778},[],{"categories":3780},[75],{"categories":3782},[169],{"categories":3784},[75],{"categories":3786},[],{"categories":3788},[137],{"categories":3790},[],{"categories":3792},[137],{"categories":3794},[176],{"categories":3796},[111],{"categories":3798},[176],{"categories":3800},[75],{"categories":3802},[119],{"categories":3804},[75],{"categories":3806},[75],{"categories":3808},[183],{"categories":3810},[176],{"categories":3812},[],{"categories":3814},[137],{"categories":3816},[75],{"categories":3818},[],{"categories":3820},[75],{"categories":3822},[75],{"categories":3824},[119],{"categories":3826},[75],{"categories":3828},[119],{"categories":3830},[75],{"categories":3832},[75],{"categories":3834},[75],{"categories":3836},[75],{"categories":3838},[114],{"categories":3840},[],{"categories":3842},[122],{"categories":3844},[137],{"categories":3846},[119],{"categories":3848},[75],{"categories":3850},[],{"categories":3852},[176],{"categories":3854},[75],{"categories":3856},[75],{"categories":3858},[75],{"categories":3860},[119],{"categories":3862},[137],{"categories":3864},[75],{"categories":3866},[75],{"categories":3868},[75],{"categories":3870},[114],{"categories":3872},[75],{"categories":3874},[119],{"categories":3876},[166],{"categories":3878},[],{"categories":3880},[169],{"categories":3882},[75],{"categories":3884},[],{"categories":3886},[137],{"categories":3888},[183],{"categories":3890},[],{"categories":3892},[],{"categories":3894},[137],{"categories":3896},[137],{"categories":3898},[75],{"categories":3900},[183],{"categories":3902},[111],{"categories":3904},[119],{"categories":3906},[75],{"categories":3908},[119],{"categories":3910},[75],{"categories":3912},[114],{"categories":3914},[],{"categories":3916},[169],{"categories":3918},[],{"categories":3920},[137],{"categories":3922},[169],{"categories":3924},[176],{"categories":3926},[119],{"categories":3928},[166],{"categories":3930},[169],{"categories":3932},[169],{"categories":3934},[],{"categories":3936},[137],{"categories":3938},[75],{"categories":3940},[75],{"categories":3942},[176],{"categories":3944},[],{"categories":3946},[137],{"categories":3948},[137],{"categories":3950},[137],{"categories":3952},[],{"categories":3954},[119],{"categories":3956},[75],{"categories":3958},[],{"categories":3960},[111],{"categories":3962},[114],{"categories":3964},[],{"categories":3966},[75],{"categories":3968},[75],{"categories":3970},[],{"categories":3972},[176],{"categories":3974},[],{"categories":3976},[],{"categories":3978},[],{"categories":3980},[],{"categories":3982},[75],{"categories":3984},[137],{"categories":3986},[],{"categories":3988},[],{"categories":3990},[75],{"categories":3992},[75],{"categories":3994},[75],{"categories":3996},[169],{"categories":3998},[75],{"categories":4000},[169],{"categories":4002},[],{"categories":4004},[169],{"categories":4006},[169],{"categories":4008},[208],{"categories":4010},[119],{"categories":4012},[176],{"categories":4014},[],{"categories":4016},[],{"categories":4018},[169],{"categories":4020},[176],{"categories":4022},[176],{"categories":4024},[176],{"categories":4026},[],{"categories":4028},[111],{"categories":4030},[176],{"categories":4032},[176],{"categories":4034},[111],{"categories":4036},[176],{"categories":4038},[114],{"categories":4040},[176],{"categories":4042},[176],{"categories":4044},[176],{"categories":4046},[169],{"categories":4048},[137],{"categories":4050},[137],{"categories":4052},[75],{"categories":4054},[176],{"categories":4056},[169],{"categories":4058},[208],{"categories":4060},[169],{"categories":4062},[169],{"categories":4064},[169],{"categories":4066},[],{"categories":4068},[114],{"categories":4070},[],{"categories":4072},[208],{"categories":4074},[176],{"categories":4076},[176],{"categories":4078},[176],{"categories":4080},[119],{"categories":4082},[137,114],{"categories":4084},[169],{"categories":4086},[],{"categories":4088},[],{"categories":4090},[169],{"categories":4092},[],{"categories":4094},[169],{"categories":4096},[137],{"categories":4098},[119],{"categories":4100},[],{"categories":4102},[176],{"categories":4104},[75],{"categories":4106},[166],{"categories":4108},[],{"categories":4110},[75],{"categories":4112},[],{"categories":4114},[137],{"categories":4116},[111],{"categories":4118},[169],{"categories":4120},[],{"categories":4122},[176],{"categories":4124},[137],[4126,4175,4257,4343],{"id":4127,"title":4128,"ai":4129,"body":4134,"categories":4154,"created_at":76,"date_modified":76,"description":68,"extension":77,"faq":76,"featured":78,"kicker_label":76,"meta":4155,"navigation":91,"path":4165,"published_at":4166,"question":76,"scraped_at":4166,"seo":4167,"sitemap":4168,"source_id":4169,"source_name":97,"source_type":98,"source_url":4159,"stem":4170,"tags":4171,"thumbnail_url":76,"tldr":4172,"tweet":76,"unknown_tags":4173,"__hash__":4174},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002F2e67a7fe7007f050-internalizing-self-critique-via-reinforcement-lear-summary.md","Internalizing Self-Critique via Reinforcement Learning (ICRL)",{"provider":7,"model":8,"input_tokens":4130,"output_tokens":4131,"processing_time_ms":4132,"cost_usd":4133},4088,431,2743,0.0016685,{"type":14,"value":4135,"toc":4150},[4136,4140,4143,4147],[17,4137,4139],{"id":4138},"the-shift-from-external-to-internalized-critique","The Shift from External to Internalized Critique",[22,4141,4142],{},"Traditional AI systems often rely on external verifiers or multi-agent setups to critique outputs, which introduces latency and dependency on external compute or prompt-based feedback loops. ICRL (Internalizing Self-Critique with Reinforcement Learning) proposes a framework where the model learns to perform this critique internally. By treating the critique process as a learned behavior within the agent's policy, the model can identify and rectify errors during the generation process without requiring an explicit, separate verification step.",[17,4144,4146],{"id":4145},"reinforcement-learning-for-self-correction","Reinforcement Learning for Self-Correction",[22,4148,4149],{},"The core mechanism of ICRL involves training the model to optimize for a reward signal that accounts for both task completion and self-correction accuracy. Instead of relying on static prompt engineering or external feedback, the agent is trained to generate a 'critique' latent or token sequence that informs its own subsequent generation. This approach forces the model to develop a more robust internal representation of 'correctness,' as it is directly penalized for failing to catch its own errors during the reinforcement learning phase. This method effectively compresses the multi-step reasoning process into a more efficient, internalized loop, leading to higher accuracy in complex reasoning tasks where external verifiers might struggle to provide granular, context-aware feedback.",{"title":68,"searchDepth":69,"depth":69,"links":4151},[4152,4153],{"id":4138,"depth":69,"text":4139},{"id":4145,"depth":69,"text":4146},[75],{"content_references":4156,"triage":4161},[4157],{"type":82,"title":4158,"url":4159,"context":4160},"ICRL: Learning to Internalize Self-Critique with Reinforcement Learning","https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2605.15224","cited",{"relevance":4162,"novelty":88,"quality":88,"actionability":69,"composite":4163,"reasoning":4164},3,3.25,"Category: AI & LLMs. The article discusses a novel approach to improving AI model performance through internalized self-critique, which is relevant to AI engineering. However, it lacks practical applications or frameworks that the audience can directly implement in their projects.","\u002Fsummaries\u002F2e67a7fe7007f050-internalizing-self-critique-via-reinforcement-lear-summary","2026-05-18 07:11:46",{"title":4128,"description":68},{"loc":4165},"2e67a7fe7007f050","summaries\u002F2e67a7fe7007f050-internalizing-self-critique-via-reinforcement-lear-summary",[101,102,103,104],"ICRL improves model performance by training agents to internalize self-critique mechanisms through reinforcement learning, moving beyond external verification to autonomous error correction.",[],"xmVVDHC3Y82VlgMv4XfwybbnobbUXetwUS0m9zZgsno",{"id":4176,"title":4177,"ai":4178,"body":4184,"categories":4218,"created_at":76,"date_modified":76,"description":68,"extension":77,"faq":76,"featured":78,"kicker_label":76,"meta":4219,"navigation":91,"path":4245,"published_at":4246,"question":76,"scraped_at":4246,"seo":4247,"sitemap":4248,"source_id":4249,"source_name":4250,"source_type":98,"source_url":4251,"stem":4252,"tags":4253,"thumbnail_url":76,"tldr":4254,"tweet":76,"unknown_tags":4255,"__hash__":4256},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002Ffd797e93058cd1d0-parameter-golf-creativity-in-tiny-ml-models-summary.md","Parameter Golf: Creativity in Tiny ML Models",{"provider":7,"model":4179,"input_tokens":4180,"output_tokens":4181,"processing_time_ms":4182,"cost_usd":4183},"x-ai\u002Fgrok-4.1-fast",6948,2080,34202,0.00240695,{"type":14,"value":4185,"toc":4213},[4186,4190,4193,4196,4200,4203,4206,4210],[17,4187,4189],{"id":4188},"tight-constraints-spark-technical-innovation","Tight Constraints Spark Technical Innovation",[22,4191,4192],{},"Parameter Golf required minimizing held-out loss on FineWeb dataset within a 16 MB limit for model weights plus training code and 10 minutes on 8 H100s. This setup rewarded creativity: record-track leaders combined optimizer tuning (e.g., Muon weight decay, spectral embedding init, residual-mix scheduling in #60 by @notapplica), quantization (GPTQ-lite in #414 by @signalrush; full Hessian GPTQ in #1060 by @dexhunter), test-time adaptation (per-document LoRA in #77 by @samacqua; self-generated calibration in #1019 by @abaybektursun), and novel ideas like CaseOps tokenizer (#1729 by @romeerp), XSA attention (#265 by @unnir), SmearGate\u002FBigramHash features (#65 by @aquariouseworkman), and mini depth recurrence (#1204 by @msisovic). Nonrecord track saw alternatives like state-space models, JEPA, Designator attention, and byte-level H-Net beat the 1.22 BPB baseline, with top at 1.12 BPB, proving non-transformers viable under constraints.",[22,4194,4195],{},"These approaches show disciplined stacking of prior wins outperforms isolated changes, while pushing quantization and eval edges demands organizer scrutiny to stay rule-compliant.",[17,4197,4199],{"id":4198},"ai-coding-agents-transform-competitions","AI Coding Agents Transform Competitions",[22,4201,4202],{},"Agents slashed experimentation costs, enabling rapid setup, code inspection, and idea testing—most submitters used them, amplified by RunPod's $1M compute sponsorship. This lowered entry barriers, sped community progress (e.g., @notapplica's agent-run Live Updates bulletin explained leaderboards), and surfaced talent. Drawbacks: submission noise from agent-copied invalid tweaks, requiring a Codex-based triage bot to flag hundreds of daily PRs for review. Agents fostered community tools for rule-checking, but many top scores iterated small changes on leaders rather than breakthroughs.",[22,4204,4205],{},"Net effect: agents make open challenges more accessible and dynamic, shifting focus from implementation friction to taste and persistence, though they demand automated review scaling.",[17,4207,4209],{"id":4208},"implications-for-future-ml-research","Implications for Future ML Research",[22,4211,4212],{},"The 8-week event validated constrained problems for talent discovery and idea surfacing, with verified record-breakers spanning tuning to from-scratch features. Organizers reproduced all leaderboard entries, confirming timeliness. Alternatives held against transformers, hinting agents cheapen prototyping risky architectures. OpenAI plans more challenges; eligible participants can join via form for updates.",{"title":68,"searchDepth":69,"depth":69,"links":4214},[4215,4216,4217],{"id":4188,"depth":69,"text":4189},{"id":4198,"depth":69,"text":4199},{"id":4208,"depth":69,"text":4209},[137],{"content_references":4220,"triage":4242},[4221,4226,4229,4233,4236,4239],{"type":4222,"title":4223,"url":4224,"context":4225},"other","Parameter Golf GitHub Repo","https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002Fopenai\u002Fparameter-golf","mentioned",{"type":4222,"title":4227,"url":4228,"context":4225},"OpenAI Model Craft Parameter Golf Challenge Terms and Conditions","https:\u002F\u002Fcdn.openai.com\u002Fpdf\u002Fd5caec5a-ee81-419d-b0d7-39f1424d819c\u002FOpenAI%20Model%20Craft_%20Parameter%20Golf%20Challenge%20Terms%20and%20Conditions.pdf",{"type":4222,"title":4230,"url":4231,"context":4232},"Challenge Participant Form","https:\u002F\u002Fjobs.ashbyhq.com\u002Fopenai\u002Fform\u002Fopen-ai-challenge-parameter-golf","recommended",{"type":4222,"title":4234,"url":4235,"context":4232},"CiprianFlorim-Ifrim’s combination state-space model and JEPA submission","https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002Fopenai\u002Fparameter-golf\u002Fblob\u002Fmain\u002Frecords\u002Ftrack_non_record_16mb\u002F2026-03-26_37M_LeWM_Jepa_Mamba2_10L_UNet_INT4FP8QAT_Brotli\u002FREADME.md",{"type":4222,"title":4237,"url":4238,"context":4232},"ddavidgao’s Designator\u002FGuided Attention submission","https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002Fopenai\u002Fparameter-golf\u002Fblob\u002Fmain\u002Frecords\u002Ftrack_non_record_16mb\u002F2026-03-23_DGAttention_DavidGao\u002FREADME.md",{"type":4222,"title":4240,"url":4241,"context":4232},"DariusFeher’s Byte-Level H-Net submission","https:\u002F\u002Fgithub.com\u002Fopenai\u002Fparameter-golf\u002Fblob\u002Fmain\u002Frecords\u002Ftrack_non_record_16mb\u002F2026-03-29_HNet_ByteVsSubword_Study\u002FREADME.md",{"relevance":88,"novelty":4162,"quality":88,"actionability":4162,"composite":4243,"reasoning":4244},3.6,"Category: AI & LLMs. The article discusses the Parameter Golf challenge, which highlights practical innovations in model optimization and the role of AI agents in enhancing research efficiency, addressing the audience's interest in actionable AI techniques. It provides specific examples of techniques used in the challenge, though it lacks a clear step-by-step guide for implementation.","\u002Fsummaries\u002Ffd797e93058cd1d0-parameter-golf-creativity-in-tiny-ml-models-summary","2026-05-13 12:01:01",{"title":4177,"description":68},{"loc":4245},"fd797e93058cd1d0","OpenAI News","https:\u002F\u002Fopenai.com\u002Findex\u002Fwhat-parameter-golf-taught-us","summaries\u002Ffd797e93058cd1d0-parameter-golf-creativity-in-tiny-ml-models-summary",[103,102,104,101],"OpenAI's 16MB\u002F10-min ML challenge drew 1,000+ participants and 2,000+ submissions, showcasing optimizations, quantization, novel architectures, and AI agents' role in accelerating research while creating review challenges.",[],"BTcH2ww5JGpqfKFVPggtTCqjhlqMca7zmRGWQP1Oiug",{"id":4258,"title":4259,"ai":4260,"body":4265,"categories":4299,"created_at":76,"date_modified":76,"description":68,"extension":77,"faq":76,"featured":78,"kicker_label":76,"meta":4300,"navigation":91,"path":4330,"published_at":4331,"question":76,"scraped_at":4332,"seo":4333,"sitemap":4334,"source_id":4335,"source_name":4336,"source_type":98,"source_url":4337,"stem":4338,"tags":4339,"thumbnail_url":76,"tldr":4340,"tweet":76,"unknown_tags":4341,"__hash__":4342},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002F43d59384b095ae51-ai-intelligence-compression-over-scale-summary.md","AI Intelligence: Compression Over Scale",{"provider":7,"model":4179,"input_tokens":4261,"output_tokens":4262,"processing_time_ms":4263,"cost_usd":4264},8112,1718,13616,0.0024589,{"type":14,"value":4266,"toc":4294},[4267,4271,4274,4277,4281,4284,4287,4291],[17,4268,4270],{"id":4269},"scale-fails-where-compression-succeeds","Scale Fails Where Compression Succeeds",[22,4272,4273],{},"Current trillion-parameter LLMs memorize internet-scale data but fail novel reasoning tasks like ARC puzzles, scoring near zero while humans hit ~90% via hypothesis generation and backtracking. They interpolate training data (Manifold Hypothesis) but hallucinate on out-of-distribution problems, acting as 'stochastic parrots' (Brown et al., 2020). Chollet's intelligence formula—skill \u002F (data × compute)—exposes their inefficiency: planetary data and server farms for basic concepts.",[22,4275,4276],{},"Minimum Description Length (MDL) redefines intelligence as the shortest program explaining data, like Occam's Razor for code. CompressARC proves it: a zero-pretrained 76,000-parameter model solves 20% of ARC at inference by searching compressed algorithmic states, disrupting brute-force trends (Liao & Gu, 2025). Build reasoning agents prioritizing sample efficiency—needing millions of examples signals a database, not intelligence.",[17,4278,4280],{"id":4279},"neuro-symbolic-shift-llm-code-for-verifiable-reasoning","Neuro-Symbolic Shift: LLM + Code for Verifiable Reasoning",[22,4282,4283],{},"Epochs evolved from rigid symbolic AI (combinatorial explosion, Ellis et al., 2021) to flawed text prompting (LLMs destroy geometry, Moskvichev et al., 2023). Now, ARC-AGI-3 uses Kahneman's dual-process: System 1 LLM generates Python hypotheses; System 2 interpreter executes, debugs via loops (Gao et al., 2023). Code output enables static analysis, theorem provers (Z3), and auditability—safer than natural language for enterprises.",[22,4285,4286],{},"Active inference (o1, DeepSeek-R1) adds iterative search: synthesize code, run, analyze diffs, self-improve. Tool orchestration (ViperGPT) routes to external verifiers. LARC shows ARC logic translates to text, making LLMs 'General Pattern Machines' (Acquaviva et al., 2022). AlphaCode enforces modular structure, boosting reasoning (Li et al., 2022). A 1.5B-parameter distilled model crushes 13B baselines via test-time logic (Anjum, 2025).",[17,4288,4290],{"id":4289},"trade-offs-and-democratization-path","Trade-offs and Democratization Path",[22,4292,4293],{},"Test-time compute explodes inference costs with thousands of scripts, risks infinite loops, and sparks benchmark races (ARC-AGI-3 interactive environments). Yet Program-Aided Distillation (PaD) transfers trajectories to small open-source models, enabling local System-2 AI, bypassing copyright via native synthesis, and ensuring auditability (Zhu et al., 2024). Pivot to neuro-symbolic agents over oracles for safe, efficient AGI.",{"title":68,"searchDepth":69,"depth":69,"links":4295},[4296,4297,4298],{"id":4269,"depth":69,"text":4270},{"id":4279,"depth":69,"text":4280},{"id":4289,"depth":69,"text":4290},[],{"content_references":4301,"triage":4328},[4302,4307,4310,4313,4318,4323],{"type":82,"title":4303,"author":4304,"publisher":4305,"url":4306,"context":4160},"On the measure of intelligence","Chollet, F.","arXiv preprint arXiv:1911.01547","https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F1911.01547",{"type":82,"title":4308,"author":4309,"context":4160},"Language Models are Few-Shot Learners","Brown et al.",{"type":82,"title":4311,"author":4312,"context":4160},"CompressARC","Liao & Gu",{"type":82,"title":4314,"author":4315,"publisher":4316,"url":4317,"context":4160},"DreamCoder: Bootstrapping inductive program synthesis with wake-sleep library learning","Ellis, K. et al.","Proceedings of the 42nd ACM SIGPLAN Conference (PLDI)","https:\u002F\u002Fdoi.org\u002F10.1145\u002F3453483.3454080",{"type":82,"title":4319,"author":4320,"publisher":4321,"url":4322,"context":4160},"Exploring human behavior during abstract rule inference and problem solving with the cognitive abstraction and reasoning corpus","Ahn, C. et al.","arXiv preprint arXiv:2602.22408","https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fpdf\u002F2602.22408v1",{"type":82,"title":4324,"author":4325,"publisher":4326,"url":4327,"context":4160},"Abstraction and analogy-making in artificial intelligence","Mitchell, M.","Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences","https:\u002F\u002Fdoi.org\u002F10.1111\u002Fnyas.14658",{"relevance":4162,"novelty":88,"quality":88,"actionability":69,"composite":4163,"reasoning":4329},"Category: AI & LLMs. The article discusses the concept of intelligence as data compression rather than scale, which is relevant to AI engineering and LLMs. However, while it presents novel insights into model efficiency and reasoning, it lacks practical applications or frameworks that the audience can directly implement.","\u002Fsummaries\u002F43d59384b095ae51-ai-intelligence-compression-over-scale-summary","2026-05-01 20:30:03","2026-05-03 17:00:35",{"title":4259,"description":68},{"loc":4330},"43d59384b095ae51","Level Up Coding","https:\u002F\u002Flevelup.gitconnected.com\u002Fintelligence-is-compression-not-memorization-2ca43cb7573e?source=rss----5517fd7b58a6---4","summaries\u002F43d59384b095ae51-ai-intelligence-compression-over-scale-summary",[101,102,103,104],"True intelligence compresses data into minimal algorithmic rules via MDL, not memorizes petabytes. A 76k-parameter model solves 20% of ARC puzzles at inference, outpacing trillion-parameter LLMs through neuro-symbolic code generation.",[],"e4h9NqAVCJAWxJ_uWJNBz3Q7ijNcDt2cUVLwVJTbqNc",{"id":4344,"title":4345,"ai":4346,"body":4351,"categories":4387,"created_at":76,"date_modified":76,"description":4388,"extension":77,"faq":76,"featured":78,"kicker_label":76,"meta":4389,"navigation":91,"path":4390,"published_at":4391,"question":76,"scraped_at":4392,"seo":4393,"sitemap":4394,"source_id":4395,"source_name":4396,"source_type":4397,"source_url":4398,"stem":4399,"tags":4400,"thumbnail_url":76,"tldr":4401,"tweet":76,"unknown_tags":4402,"__hash__":4403},"summaries\u002Fsummaries\u002F495ed25951caccda-turboquant-6x-lossless-kv-cache-compression-summary.md","TurboQuant: 6x Lossless KV Cache Compression",{"provider":7,"model":4179,"input_tokens":4347,"output_tokens":4348,"processing_time_ms":4349,"cost_usd":4350},7839,1710,10189,0.00240015,{"type":14,"value":4352,"toc":4381},[4353,4357,4360,4364,4367,4371,4374,4378],[17,4354,4356],{"id":4355},"kv-cache-as-core-llm-memory-bottleneck","KV Cache as Core LLM Memory Bottleneck",[22,4358,4359],{},"LLMs rely on the KV cache—their working memory storing key-value pairs for every input token—to maintain context across long prompts, conversations, codebases, or agent tasks. This cache grows quadratically with sequence length, consuming most GPU HBM during inference. Supply is constrained: HBM production faces helium shortages from Iran conflicts, rising power costs, and fab delays (half-decade timelines). Demand explodes with agents burning 100M-1B tokens per interaction versus simple chats, hitting 25B tokens\u002Fyear per AI-native enterprise engineer. Memory prices surged hundreds of percent, inflating BOM costs even for consumer PCs. Traditional fixes like vector quantization add 1-2 bits overhead per value (quantization constants), partially undoing gains.",[17,4361,4363],{"id":4362},"turboquants-two-stage-lossless-compression","TurboQuant's Two-Stage Lossless Compression",[22,4365,4366],{},"TurboQuant eliminates overhead via PolarQuant rotation: rotates KV vectors into a predictable polar coordinate system (radius for signal strength, angles for meaning), like simplifying '3 blocks east, 4 north' to '5 blocks at 37°'. This makes data retrievable without per-block normalization, avoiding extra bits. QJL (Quantized Johnson-Lindenstrauss) then corrects residual errors (e.g., 36.5° vs. 37°) using a single-bit mathematical checker, eliminating bias in attention scores for perfect reconstruction. Result: 6x memory reduction (up to 10x, 32 bits to 3 bits per value), 8x chip speedup via higher concurrency. Data-oblivious, model-agnostic algorithm works universally.",[17,4368,4370],{"id":4369},"proven-performance-and-production-hurdles","Proven Performance and Production Hurdles",[22,4372,4373],{},"Tested on real tasks: question answering, code generation, summarization, needle-in-haystack retrieval (finds phrases in 100k compressed tokens). Maintains accuracy losslessly. Not production-ready yet—6x compression alters concurrency math, requiring firmware\u002Fstack updates for higher simultaneous users per GPU to maximize profitability. Software speed (vs. hardware fabs) positions it as fastest memory fix.",[17,4375,4377],{"id":4376},"strategic-wins-and-multi-angle-attacks","Strategic Wins and Multi-Angle Attacks",[22,4379,4380],{},"Google gains dual edge: TurboQuant authors optimize Gemini\u002FTPUs, bypassing HBM shortages for cost advantages. Nvidia's narrative weakens—6x from software undercuts 'buy more chips' pitch amid endless demand. Enterprises extract more from existing GPUs; middleware loses as FMs capture efficiencies. Five attack vectors emerge: (1) Quantization (TurboQuant, 2-bit asymmetric, ZipCache); (2) Eviction\u002Fsparsity (H2O.ai heavy hitters, SnapKV sliding windows); (3) Architectural redesign (DeepSeek-V2 latent attention, IBM Granite\u002FNvidia Neotron linear SSMs); (4) Offloading\u002Fpaging (ShadowKV GPU-CPU, FlexGen disk for throughput). Paired with innovations like Percepta (WASM interpreter compiled into PyTorch weights for deterministic compute, e.g., 100% Sudoku at 33k tokens\u002Fsec sans tool calls), signals 2026 architecture shift: 6-8x memory, native compute, step-change capabilities without smarter base models.",{"title":68,"searchDepth":69,"depth":69,"links":4382},[4383,4384,4385,4386],{"id":4355,"depth":69,"text":4356},{"id":4362,"depth":69,"text":4363},{"id":4369,"depth":69,"text":4370},{"id":4376,"depth":69,"text":4377},[],"Full Story w\u002F Prompts: https:\u002F\u002Fnatesnewsletter.substack.com\u002Fp\u002Fyour-gpus-just-got-6x-more-valuable?r=1z4sm5&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true\n___________________\nWhat's really happening inside AI memory — and why it's the bottleneck threatening every LLM deployment at scale?\n\nThe common story is that we just need more chips — but the reality is more interesting: a new Google paper may have just changed the math without touching the hardware.\n\nIn this video, I share the inside scoop on TurboQuant, Google's lossless KV cache compression breakthrough:\n\n• Why the AI memory crisis is structural, not temporary \n• How TurboQuant achieves 6x compression with zero data loss\n• What lossless KV cache optimization means for LLM architecture \n• Where Google, NVIDIA, and enterprises each stand to win or lose\n\nThe operators and builders who start treating memory as a years-long constraint — and take control of their own context layers now — will hold a real structural advantage as this rolls toward production.\n\nChapters \n00:00 Introduction: TurboQuant and the Memory Problem \n01:15 The AI Memory Crisis, Explained \n03:00 Why Memory Supply Is Structurally Constrained \n05:00 Demand Explosion: Agents and Token Consumption \n06:30 How Traditional Compression Fails \n08:00 TurboQuant Part One: PolarQuant Rotation \n09:30 TurboQuant Part Two: QJL Error Correction \n11:00 Test Results Across Real LLM Tasks \n12:30 Why TurboQuant Isn't in Production Yet 14:00 What Is the KV Cache? \n15:30 Percepta: Embedding Compute Inside an LLM \n17:00 Strategic Implications: Google, NVIDIA, Enterprises \n18:30 Five Angles Attacking the Memory Problem \n20:00 Sovereign Memory: Your Takeaway\n\nSubscribe for daily AI strategy and news. For deeper playbooks and analysis: https:\u002F\u002Fnatesnewsletter.substack.com\u002F\n\nListen to this video as a podcast.\n-   Spotify: https:\u002F\u002Fopen.spotify.com\u002Fshow\u002F0gkFdjd1wptEKJKLu9LbZ4\n-   Apple Podcasts: https:\u002F\u002Fpodcasts.apple.com\u002Fus\u002Fpodcast\u002Fai-news-strategy-daily-with-nate-b-jones\u002Fid1877109372",{},"\u002Fsummaries\u002F495ed25951caccda-turboquant-6x-lossless-kv-cache-compression-summary","2026-04-11 15:00:59","2026-04-11 20:55:38",{"title":4345,"description":4388},{"loc":4390},"495ed25951caccda","AI News & Strategy Daily | Nate B Jones","video","https:\u002F\u002Fwww.youtube.com\u002Fwatch?v=erV_8yrGMA8","summaries\u002F495ed25951caccda-turboquant-6x-lossless-kv-cache-compression-summary",[101,103,104,102],"Google's TurboQuant achieves 6x KV cache compression and 8x speedup in LLMs without data loss, easing structural memory shortages by optimizing existing GPUs.",[],"sNaI2Faqi1oeROu63-0myGtm5S8tfvXMM75cJc0WMqc"]